Belonging Explored: 'Strictly Ballroom' vs. 'The Ink Bridge'

Belonging, a nuanced concept that encompasses personal, cultural, and social dimensions, is a fundamental aspect of human experience. The intricacies of belonging are vividly depicted in various text types, each presenting a dynamic exploration shaped by structures, language forms, and unique features. This essay aims to delve into the multifaceted nature of belonging by contrasting two distinct texts: the film 'Strictly Ballroom,' directed by Baz Luhrmann, which explores the tension between uniqueness and conformity, and the novel 'The Ink Bridge' by Neil Grant, which delves into the alienation and ignorance surrounding a foreign culture.

'Strictly Ballroom': Uniqueness Amid Conformity

In the cinematic realm of 'Strictly Ballroom,' Baz Luhrmann artfully navigates the theme of belonging through the character of Scott Hastings, a professional ballroom dancer. Scott's distinctive dance moves become a symbol of personal non-belonging, challenging the traditional norms imposed by the dance community. The film adopts a fairy tale structure, captivating the audience with its universal appeal.

Scott, positioned as the hero, faces the conflict between embracing his unique style and conforming to the rigid rules set by Barry Fife, the antagonist.

Get quality help now

writer-marian

Verified writer

Proficient in: Identity

4.8 (309)

“ Writer-marian did a very good job with my paper, she got straight to the point, she made it clear and organized ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

The familial support and camaraderie within Lez Kendall's dance studio highlight the societal pressure on Scott to conform. The tension between individuality and conformity is palpable, creating a narrative that resonates with personal, cultural, and social contexts.

Adding depth to the exploration of belonging, Luhrmann introduces Fran, a character labeled as a 'beginner' despite her two years of experience in ballroom dancing. Fran's willingness to partner with Scott signifies a rebellion against the prevailing norms.

This partnership becomes Scott's gateway to breaking free from alienation, illustrating the power dynamics that exist within the dance community. The film, much like a fairy tale, weaves a narrative of self-discovery and the pursuit of belonging against the backdrop of ballroom dancing.

'The Ink Bridge': Alienation and Cultural Ignorance

Neil Grant's novel, 'The Ink Bridge,' provides a contrasting perspective on belonging through the journey of Omed Noori. The narrative unfolds in Bamiyan, Afghanistan, portraying Omed's initial belonging within his family as the eldest sibling. However, seeking asylum in Australia thrusts him into a new world where his customs and social behavior, altered by the Taliban's punishment, lead to significant alienation.

Omed's story mirrors the struggles of adapting to a foreign culture, emphasizing the cultural and social barriers that contribute to his sense of not belonging. Grant intricately explores the dichotomy between Omed's past belonging in Afghanistan and his alienation in Australia, showcasing the profound impact of cultural differences on an individual's sense of self and community.

The novel introduces the character of the Poet of Kandahar, highlighting the emergence of belonging amidst the harsh environment of a Pakistan Refugee Camp. The bond between Omed and the Poet becomes a lifeline, offering solace and a shared sense of identity in the face of adversity. This narrative shift beautifully captures the complexities of belonging and the potential for connection even in the most unwelcoming circumstances.

Comparative Analysis: Shared Themes, Divergent Paths

Despite their differing mediums, 'Strictly Ballroom' and 'The Ink Bridge' share common threads in their exploration of belonging. Both narratives delve into the tension between individuality and societal expectations, presenting protagonists who defy norms to seek their authentic selves.

While 'Strictly Ballroom' unfolds as a vibrant dance drama with familial and societal pressures, 'The Ink Bridge' takes a more contemplative approach, examining the impact of cultural displacement on Omed's sense of belonging. The central theme remains universal — the quest for identity and connection — though the paths taken by Scott and Omed diverge.

Furthermore, both texts emphasize the transformative power of relationships in shaping one's sense of belonging. In 'Strictly Ballroom,' Scott's partnership with Fran becomes a catalyst for his liberation, challenging the established order. Similarly, 'The Ink Bridge' portrays the resilience of human connections, illustrating how the bond between Omed and the Poet transcends cultural barriers and fosters a profound sense of belonging.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the exploration of belonging is a dynamic and multifaceted journey, as exemplified by 'Strictly Ballroom' and 'The Ink Bridge.' Through the contrasting lenses of a lively dance drama and a poignant novel, these texts illuminate the personal, cultural, and social dimensions of belonging. Whether it be Scott's defiance of dance conventions or Omed's struggle with cultural displacement, both narratives resonate with the human experience of seeking connection and authenticity.

As we reflect on these stories, we recognize that belonging is not a static concept but a fluid and evolving aspect of our lives. It is shaped by our interactions, choices, and the relationships we forge. 'Strictly Ballroom' and 'The Ink Bridge' invite us to contemplate the complexities of belonging, urging us to embrace our uniqueness, defy societal expectations, and find solace in the bonds that transcend cultural divides.