Reconsidering Social Hierarchy in Shakespeare's 'The Tempest'

William Shakespeare's 'The Tempest' is a profound exploration of social dynamics, power, and hierarchy. Through the characters of Prospero and Caliban, the play delves into the multifaceted layers of societal structure, shedding light on the influence of intellect, passion, and the consequences of colonization. This essay seeks to analyze and expand upon the intricate interplay of these elements within the broader context of Shakespeare's timeless work.

The Intellectual Authority of Prospero

At the heart of 'The Tempest' lies the enigmatic figure of Prospero, whose intellectual prowess and mastery of the magical arts place him at the pinnacle of the social hierarchy on the island.

In the closing scene, Prospero's acknowledgment of Caliban as "This thing of darkness I/ Acknowledge mine" encapsulates his deep-rooted belief in his legitimate control over the island, justified by his act of colonization.

Prospero's source of authority is twofold: his magical abilities and the wealth of knowledge contained within his books. These elements not only serve as tools for his dominance but also symbolize the broader societal construct where education and intellectual acumen determine one's position.

Get quality help now

writer-marian

Verified writer

Proficient in: Gender

4.8 (309)

“ Writer-marian did a very good job with my paper, she got straight to the point, she made it clear and organized ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

The connection between Prospero's intellect and his authoritarian rule becomes apparent in his interactions with other characters.

While Prospero holds a firm conviction in his superiority, the play offers glimpses of his empathetic side. In the denouement, Prospero forgives Caliban for his plot against him, showcasing a nuanced perspective that challenges the rigidity of the social hierarchy. This forgiveness marks a crucial moment of self-reflection for Prospero, as he begins to recognize the limitations of his autocratic rule and the need for a more balanced and compassionate approach.

The Tyranny of Colonization

Prospero's role as a colonizer is central to understanding the dynamics of social hierarchy within 'The Tempest.' His arrival on the island, coupled with his assertion of dominance over Caliban, mirrors the historical context of European colonization during Shakespeare's time. The play critiques the oppressive nature of colonization, highlighting Prospero's dual role as both tyrant and colonizer.

The initial encounter between Prospero and Caliban serves as a microcosm of the broader colonial narrative. Despite saving Caliban from Sycorax, Prospero strips him of his freedom and imposes servitude. This act reflects the typical colonizer's approach, emphasizing social hierarchy through actions that deny others their rights. The contrasting statuses of Ariel and Caliban, both recipients of Prospero's "mercy," underscore the arbitrary nature of the social order established by the colonizer.

Prospero's tyrannical tendencies are evident in his treatment of both Ariel and Caliban. When Ariel reminds him of a promise, Prospero reacts with fury, emphasizing his autocratic stance. The colonizer's mindset is further revealed when Prospero calls for Caliban, boasting of saving him from Sycorax while simultaneously subjecting him to a life of servitude. This oppressive behavior exemplifies the hierarchical structures inherent in colonial narratives, reinforcing the overarching theme of societal inequality.

The Strained Relationship: Prospero, Caliban, and Social Hierarchy

The strained relationship between Prospero and Caliban is rooted in their conflicting ideologies and the societal hierarchy imposed by the colonizer. Caliban's rightful ownership of the island clashes with Prospero's belief in the inherent superiority of the white European over the islander. This tension reaches its zenith when Caliban attempts to rape Miranda, Prospero's daughter, leading to a rupture in their already fragile relationship.

Prospero, justifying his claim on Caliban, cites humane care and lodging, overlooking the oppressive conditions to which he subjects Caliban. The colonizer's narrative revolves around the belief that he liberated Caliban by killing Sycorax, enabling him to assert ownership. This dichotomy between Prospero's claims of care and the reality of subjugation highlights the play's critical examination of social hierarchy and the consequences of colonization.

As 'The Tempest' unfolds, Prospero's compassionate side emerges, culminating in forgiveness for Caliban's transgressions. The complexities of their relationship challenge the binary notions of master and slave, suggesting a potential evolution beyond conventional power dynamics. Prospero's realization of his own shortcomings opens the door to a more egalitarian future, disrupting the established social hierarchy.

Breaking the Social Hierarchy

While Caliban's rebellion may not achieve conventional success, it serves as a catalyst for change in the dynamics between Prospero and himself. Prospero's final act of forgiveness signifies a transformative moment, challenging the established social hierarchy and signaling the possibility of a more equitable relationship. This pivotal moment showcases Prospero's evolving understanding of power, responsibility, and the need for compassion in interpersonal relationships.

Expanding on this theme, it is essential to consider the broader implications of Prospero's transformation. The play invites us to reflect on the potential for societal change beyond the confines of the island. In forgiving Caliban, Prospero takes a step towards dismantling the ingrained social hierarchies that permeate society. The narrative encourages audiences to question not only the characters' roles but also the societal norms that perpetuate inequality.

Moreover, the character of Miranda, Prospero's daughter, adds another layer to the discourse on social hierarchy. As a woman in a patriarchal society, Miranda's agency is limited, even though she is the object of desire and contention between Prospero and Caliban. Examining Miranda's position within this intricate web of power dynamics provides insights into gender roles, emphasizing the interconnectedness of various social hierarchies.

In conclusion, 'The Tempest' offers a rich tapestry of social commentary through the characters of Prospero and Caliban. The play not only critiques the oppressive nature of colonization but also delves into the intricate interplay of intellect, passion, and forgiveness within the societal framework. As Prospero reevaluates his role as a colonizer and acknowledges the flaws in his autocratic rule, the play invites audiences to contemplate the potential for breaking free from traditional power structures and fostering a more inclusive and compassionate society.