An Analysis of "A Smile to Remember" by Charles Bukowski

The Complex Narration of Familial Struggle: Unveiling "A Smile to Remember" by Charles Bukowski

Charles Bukowski's poem, "A Smile to Remember," intricately weaves a poignant tale of an ordinary family grappling with tragic complexities. It appears that the child narrating the poem is none other than Bukowski himself, offering a glimpse into his tumultuous childhood. The seemingly innocuous introduction of goldfish becomes a symbolic thread that unravels the deeper layers of the family's struggles.

The Deceptive Facade of Happiness

At first glance, the title may mislead readers into expecting a "feel-good" or "love" poem.

The mention of goldfish and the mother's constant encouragement for happiness creates an image of an idyllic family striving for joy. However, this façade is quickly shattered as we delve deeper into the verses. The mother, despite enduring a wretched existence due to her abusive husband, perpetually smiles and urges her family to be happy.

The poet cleverly introduces a contrast in the fifth line, asserting, "and she was right: it’s better to be happy if you.

Get quality help now

Prof. Finch

Verified writer

Proficient in: Childhood

4.7 (346)

“ This writer never make an mistake for me always deliver long before due date. Am telling you man this writer is absolutely the best. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

" The abrupt stop after "you" and the subsequent standalone line with the word "can" underscores the underlying desolation within the family. Bukowski prompts readers to question the authenticity of the depicted happiness, leaving them to ponder if the mother and the child genuinely experience joy. The mother's acknowledgment that the child "never smiles" hints at the pervasive sorrow enveloping their lives.

Understanding the Father's Demons

Amidst the turmoil, Bukowski takes a compassionate turn, attempting to understand the father's inner demons.

Described as "raging inside his 6-foot-two frame," the reader is confronted with the father's internal struggles, transcending the image of a mere abusive figure. The poet invites contemplation on the root causes—be it mental illness, substance abuse, or temperamental disposition—behind the father's violent behavior.

Bukowski strategically places his mother at the center of the stanza, portraying her as a "poor fish" battered by the weekly onslaught of abuse. The symbolism of the goldfish shifts from a mere pet to representing the mother's futile attempt to showcase happiness amidst adversity. The child, keenly aware of the facade, recognizes the mother's smile as "the saddest smile I ever saw," revealing the profound impact of the family's struggles on even the youngest member.

Unveiling the True Symbolism: The Demise of the Goldfish

In the concluding stanza, the death of the goldfish takes on a profound symbolic significance. The vivid imagery of lifeless fish floating on their sides, eyes still open, prompts a reevaluation of the initial perception of the goldfish as a mere pet. Now, the goldfish becomes a metaphor for the mother herself—a woman attempting to hold together a shattered family.

The narrative flips as the reader realizes that the poem transcends a portrayal of abuse. It becomes a poignant exploration of a frayed woman desperately trying to maintain a semblance of normalcy. The smiling facade, once perceived as a shield against the harsh reality, crumbles with the death of the goldfish. The mother, standing there with a smile, may harbor a realization that relief will eventually come—perhaps in death, putting an end to her prolonged misery and allowing her to escape the pretense of a happy existence.

Conclusion: Unmasking the Layers of "A Smile to Remember"

Charles Bukowski's "A Smile to Remember" unfolds as a rich tapestry of familial struggles, veiled behind the facade of a seemingly happy home. The symbolism of the goldfish transcends its initial portrayal, becoming a powerful metaphor for the mother's resilience in the face of adversity. The poet skillfully navigates the complexities of abusive relationships, inviting readers to empathize with the characters and question the nature of happiness in the midst of profound suffering.

As the poem concludes, the reader is left with a haunting image of a smiling mother, standing amidst the remnants of shattered illusions. "A Smile to Remember" challenges preconceived notions and prompts a reflection on the masks individuals wear to conceal their pain. In this exploration of Bukowski's childhood, the poet beckons readers to contemplate the human capacity to endure, the complexities of familial bonds, and the fragility of happiness in the face of adversity.