To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
In the realm of ever-changing identities, the fabric of who we are is woven from the threads of our experiences. Parker J Palmer suggests that identity is a culmination of our past encounters with people and places, a notion echoed in the elegiac poem ‘The Death of the Bird’ by A. D Hope and the poignant short story ‘The Window’ by Pham Thi Hoai. These works delve into the intricate dance between identity and environment, revealing how our sense of self is malleable and susceptible to the influences of the world around us.
The Death of the Bird by A.
D Hope employs a subtle shift in mood to underscore the fragility of identity. The bird, initially guided by the warmth of familiarity and love, embarks on a migratory journey. The poet's choice of words, describing the bird as 'uncertain of her place' and a 'vanishing speck,' paints a vivid picture of vulnerability in an unfamiliar environment. This stark contrast in mood emphasizes the transformative power of external surroundings, illustrating that our identity is intricately tied to the places we hold dear.
As we delve deeper into the thematic undercurrents of The Death of the Bird, the metaphorical significance of the bird's journey becomes more pronounced.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Identity
4.7 (657)
“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”
The warm passage to the cooling station mirrors the comfort derived from a familiar environment, where love and a sense of belonging provide a secure haven. However, the poet skillfully navigates the emotional terrain, introducing an element of uncertainty that disrupts the bird's once secure identity.
The poignant portrayal of the bird as a 'vanishing speck in those inane dominions' creates a powerful visual imagery, starkly contrasting the delicate creature against the harsh backdrop of an unfamiliar world.
This dramatic shift in mood exemplifies how identity is not merely a static entity but a fluid construct, susceptible to change when the foundational connection with a place is severed. The bird's vulnerability echoes the human experience, where a rupture in our connection with the familiar can leave us adrift, questioning our sense of self. The Death of the Bird becomes a profound exploration of the delicate balance between rootedness and the unsettling prospect of change, reinforcing Palmer's assertion that our identity is a product of our external environment.
Turning our gaze to The Window by Pham Thi Hoai, the exploration of identity takes on a nuanced dimension. The ever-changing window serves as a metaphor for the constant evolution of the narrator's surroundings. Hoai skillfully weaves the Rubik cube analogy into the narrative, drawing parallels between the puzzle's need for perpetual change and the narrator's environment. This dynamic setting becomes a crucible for the narrator's evolving identity.
The narrator's introspective musings provide a window into the intricate interplay between external stimuli and internal transformation. The Rubik cube becomes a symbol of the perpetual state of flux, reflecting the instability inherent in the narrator's surroundings. The narrative takes an unexpected turn as the narrator expresses a yearning for romantic connection, a desire incongruent with her earlier dismissal of romanticism. This reveals the profound impact of external influences on shaping one's identity, echoing the sentiments expressed in The Death of the Bird.
Hoai further delves into the layers of identity through the narrator's meticulous examination of people from her window. The discounting list of superficial attributes—occupation, age, blood type—serves as a commentary on societal norms that often define identity in limited terms. However, the author transcends these surface-level considerations, directing attention to the capacity for love as a hidden, intrinsic aspect of identity.
Despite this revelation, the narrator remains distanced from those around her, reminiscent of the bird's struggle to connect with its companions. The poignant change in tense at the story's end, with the narrator anticipating the man's return, creates a melancholic atmosphere, hinting at an eternal waiting and a perpetual sense of unfulfilled connection. This suggests that, like the bird, the narrator's identity is inextricably linked to her surroundings, yet remains elusive and unattainable.
Examining the thematic threads woven through The Death of the Bird and The Window, a nuanced understanding of identity emerges. These works illuminate the intricate dance between internal and external forces, illustrating that our identities are not predetermined but shaped by the dynamic interplay with our surroundings.
Returning to Parker J Palmer's perspective on identity, the notion that our past experiences form the tapestry of who we are becomes increasingly relevant. The Death of the Bird and The Window serve as literary mirrors reflecting the profound impact of external influences on our sense of self. The intricate layers of identity are laid bare, revealing a mosaic of connections, disruptions, and transformations that characterize the human experience.
In conclusion, the analysis of these two works vividly illustrates that our identities are not static but rather a result of the dynamic interplay between self and environment. The poems and stories we live become integral chapters in the book of our identity, each experience and connection leaving an indelible mark. As we navigate the ever-shifting landscape of our lives, it becomes evident that to truly understand ourselves, we must first understand the ever-changing nature of our identities.
Changing Identity: An Exploration through Poetry and Prose. (2018, Oct 13). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/changing-identity-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
