The Justification for the War of 1812

Introduction

In the annals of American history, the United States of America has been involved in numerous conflicts, each with its own set of motivations and justifications. One such conflict, the War of 1812, often occupies a lesser-known place in the nation's historical narrative. Paradoxically, it was in this relatively obscure war that the United States found itself most justified in taking up arms against Great Britain. This essay explores the multifaceted reasons that led to the United States declaring war on British North America in June of 1812, examining Great Britain's violation of maritime rights, its support for Native American tribes hostile to the United States, and the contentious issue of naval impressment.

The Breach of Maritime Rights

One of the primary justifications for the United States' declaration of war against Great Britain in 1812 was Britain's flagrant disregard for the maritime rights guaranteed to the United States. At the time, Europe was embroiled in the Napoleonic Wars, with Napoleon Bonaparte exerting dominant control over Continental Europe.

Get quality help now

writer-marian

Verified writer

Proficient in: America

4.8 (309)

“ Writer-marian did a very good job with my paper, she got straight to the point, she made it clear and organized ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

In response to this, Napoleon instituted the Continental System, effectively barring European nations from engaging in trade with Britain in an attempt to weaken the British economy. However, Britain's formidable naval power allowed it to enforce maritime laws and regulations.

Britain declared that no vessels could proceed to Continental Europe without obtaining a license, granting them the authority to search ships at will and confiscate cargo deemed 'contraband.' Meanwhile, the United States, not participating in the European conflict, sought to engage in trade with various European nations to secure economic benefits.

However, the British decree severely hampered American trade and caused a detrimental economic impact. Many American ship captains hesitated to engage in European trade, fearing that their vessels would be boarded, and their cargoes seized by British authorities. The American public viewed this as a breach of the country's neutrality, given its decision to remain uninvolved in the Napoleonic Wars. This abuse of naval power by Great Britain provided a compelling justification for the United States to declare war in defense of its maritime rights and to establish equitable trading conditions.

Over time, British naval pressure on the United States led to a complete halt in American trade with Continental Europe. This embargo on American trade, while driven by British interests, provoked outrage among American citizens, particularly those residing along the Atlantic coast. Many of these individuals depended on trade with Europe for their livelihoods. The British decree not only disrupted American commerce but also violated the country's stance of neutrality in the European conflict. This growing discontent among Americans, especially the Atlantic coast residents, played a pivotal role in the emergence of a group known as "The War Hawks."

The War Hawks were fervent proponents of the idea that it was the duty of the American government to declare war on Britain. They argued that Britain's violation of United States neutrality amounted to a de facto declaration of hostilities. The War Hawks exerted considerable pressure on President James Madison and the U.S. Congress to take action. Their efforts were instrumental in garnering the public support necessary for the declaration of war. In light of Britain's blatant disregard for America's maritime rights, the War Hawks' argument gained traction, ultimately leading to the United States' decision to end its neutrality and declare war on Great Britain.

The British Support for Native American Tribes

The War of 1812 also saw the United States declare war on Great Britain due to British support for Native American tribes hostile to American interests. At the time, the British maintained a close trade partnership with various Native American groups, providing not only goods but also weapons and ammunition. This support included the gifting of food, clothing, and crucially, military supplies to the Natives. British trade with these tribes directly fueled their resistance against American settlers, exacerbating the ongoing territorial conflicts between Native tribes and American colonists.

The British-Native American relationship was far from conventional trade. It involved providing arms to Native groups engaged in a brutal territorial war against American settlers. Paradoxically, the same British authorities who hindered American ships from crossing the Atlantic to prevent support for Britain's enemies were actively supplying Native Americans, who were adversaries of the United States. This inconsistency was perceived as audacious and hypocritical by the American populace and contributed significantly to pro-war sentiments.

Many Americans, especially those in the Northwestern territories, believed that the British were using Native Americans as proxies to wage war against the United States. There was a prevailing notion that the British were actively encouraging anti-American sentiments among Native tribes. This support for a formidable American adversary intensified the resentment among American colonists, as they endured the bloody consequences of these Native conflicts, with colonists and their families falling victim to Native American attacks fueled by British-supplied arms. Additionally, British authorities sought to establish a Native American buffer state between the United States and British North America, an idea vehemently opposed by the U.S. government and the American people. This fundamental disagreement further strained Anglo-American relations and fueled the justifications for war.

Naval Impressment and Violations of American Sovereignty

Another critical factor that pushed the United States towards declaring war against the mighty British Empire was the issue of naval impressment. For centuries, Britain relied on its formidable navy for defense against invasion and to establish trade blockades, thereby crippling its enemies' economies. However, maintaining this navy was a costly endeavor, and during times of peace, the British government often discharged a significant portion of its naval personnel and even decommissioned ships to save expenses.

During wartime, Britain resorted to impressment, defined as "the act or policy of seizing people or property for public service or use." Press gangs roamed the streets, apprehending individuals, including drunks and derelicts, for compulsory service in the British Navy. Service in the navy was arduous, characterized by abysmal living conditions, meager pay, and a short life expectancy. Consequently, a considerable number of British sailors deserted, seeking refuge in the United States, where they sought American citizenship. The United States often enlisted these deserters into its own navy, offering better pay and improved living conditions.

However, it was the issue of mistaken impressment that became a primary cause of the War of 1812. British naval captains, known for their arrogance and often likened to pirates, frequently confiscated cargo and took prisoners without official government authorization. Their penchant for boarding American ships during transatlantic voyages created a climate of anxiety among American captains. Most significantly, British captains demanded the return of British deserters, regardless of their current citizenship status, leading to the wrongful impressment of American-born naval personnel. This practice was perceived as a gross violation of American sovereignty and neutrality.

The United States government, along with the vocal War Hawks, considered this British practice an extreme affront to American rights and a compelling reason to wage war against Britain. In the face of such injustices committed by an overzealous and arrogant British navy, the citizens and government of the United States found themselves with little choice but to declare war against British North America in June of 1812.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the War of 1812, often referred to as the "Second War of Independence," was a conflict in which the United States found itself justified in declaring war against Great Britain. The breach of maritime rights, British support for hostile Native American tribes, and the issue of naval impressment were all significant factors that fueled the American decision to go to war. The violation of America's maritime rights was seen as an infringement on its neutrality and economic prosperity, while British support for Native Americans engaged in territorial warfare intensified resentment among American colonists. Additionally, the wrongful impressment of American naval personnel was viewed as a direct violation of American sovereignty and neutrality. Despite the formidable might of the British Empire, the injustices perpetrated by the British government and navy left the United States with little recourse but to defend its rights and declare war in June of 1812.