Comparative Societal Impact in Gatsby & Scarlet

Introduction:

In examining two quintessential works of American literature, "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne and "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald, we uncover a profound exploration of societal dynamics across different epochs and cultures in American history. Despite their disparate settings, both novels intertwine in their scrutiny of the tension between appearance and reality, as well as the clash between individual and societal values. This comparative analysis seeks to delve into the intricacies of these thematic parallels, shedding light on the consequences faced by the characters as they navigate the societal norms that surround them.

Comparison of Relationships:

The exploration of adulterous relationships serves as a poignant starting point for the comparison between the two novels. In "The Scarlet Letter," the clandestine love between Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale stands in stark contrast to the rigid Puritan society that condemns their connection. Despite the profound personal value their love holds, the prevailing societal norms submerge their individual values and desires, resulting in significant anguish for both protagonists.

Get quality help now

RhizMan

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

4.9 (247)

“ Rhizman is absolutely amazing at what he does . I highly recommend him if you need an assignment done ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

This sets the stage for an in-depth exploration of societal influences on personal relationships.

In "The Great Gatsby," a similar submerging process transpires as the narrative revolves around Jay Gatsby's unrequited love for Daisy Buchanan. Unlike the Puritanical society of Hawthorne's creation, the 1920s Jazz Age offers a more tolerant view of adulterous relationships. However, social values of the time play a pivotal role in Gatsby's pursuit of Daisy. The pursuit of social status through material wealth becomes a conduit for Gatsby's aspirations, leading to the submersion of his and Daisy's true desires.

This exploration delves into the impact of societal values on personal fulfillment, drawing a parallel with the theme explored in "The Scarlet Letter."

Social Values and Individual Suffering:

The examination of societal values and their repercussions on individual lives forms a central motif in both novels. In Hawthorne's Puritanical setting, Hester and Arthur face public condemnation for their genuine love, as societal norms refuse to make concessions for individual circumstances or the depth of their emotions. Their suffering is exacerbated by the rigid adherence to collective values, underscoring the poignant clash between personal authenticity and societal expectations.

Contrastingly, in Fitzgerald's depiction of the Jazz Age, Gatsby and Daisy emerge as publicly admired figures. However, their suffering is not rooted in public condemnation but rather in the seduction by the hollow values of materialism and the elusive "American Dream." The love shared by Gatsby and Daisy becomes an extension of this emptiness, mirroring the superficiality of the era itself. This juxtaposition explores the nuanced ways in which societal values can inflict suffering on individuals, even in the absence of overt condemnation.

Cultural Context:

The historical and cultural contexts of both novels serve as critical lenses through which to view the corruption of values. Hawthorne's "The Scarlet Letter" unveils a Puritanical culture where excessive religiosity pervades, leading to the perverse marginalization of Hester Prynne. The opening chapters vividly depict the austere Puritans and their fervent adherence to moral codes, setting the stage for the judgment and alienation faced by Hester. The character of Roger Chillingworth, consumed by self-righteous revenge, further personifies the corruption within this society.

In contrast, Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby" paints a picture of excess in the Jazz Age, characterized by non-religious hedonism fueled by wealth and materialism. The likes of Tom and Daisy Buchanan engage in marital affairs and criminal activities, mirroring the moral decay of the era. Gatsby's pursuit of materialism as a means to achieve the idealized "American Dream" illustrates the corruption of values in the pursuit of social standing. This exploration provides a comparative lens into the divergent excesses that shape the cultural landscapes of both novels.

Characters' Demise through Excess:

Both novels unfold with a tragic inevitability as characters, driven by their excesses, bring about their own downfalls. In "The Scarlet Letter," the characters of Chillingworth and the self-deceiving Dimmesdale, much like Gatsby, become architects of their own demise. Chillingworth's vengeful pursuit leads him to transform into a metaphorical fiend, violating the sanctity of Dimmesdale's heart. The consequences of their actions unfold with a sense of inevitability, illustrating the destructive power of unchecked excess.

In "The Great Gatsby," the characters' devotion to hedonistic excess and the pursuit of wealth results in their own undoing. Tom and Daisy Buchanan's reckless behavior, epitomized by their callousness and carelessness, leads to Gatsby's tragic end. The characters, blinded by their pursuits, fail to anticipate the repercussions of their actions, underscoring the overarching theme of self-inflicted demise through excess.

Nick Carraway's Role and Moral Center:

The narrative voice of Nick Carraway in "The Great Gatsby" serves as a lens through which to explore the impact of amoral lives on an individual. Nick's ironic tone pervades the narrative, providing a critical perspective on the morally bankrupt characters around him. His quest for a moral center, symbolized by his return to the Mid-West, reflects a desire to distance himself from the corrosive influences of the Jazz Age. Nick becomes a conduit for the reader to navigate the moral ambiguity of the era, contributing to the overall commentary on societal decay.

Similarity in Protagonists' Desires:

A pivotal similarity between the two novels lies in the central theme of protagonists driven by unfulfilled desires. Gatsby's relentless pursuit of Daisy mirrors Hester's consummation of her passion for Arthur in "The Scarlet Letter." Both novels unfold as narratives of unrequited love set against the backdrop of distinctly different Americas. Hester and Arthur transgress societal boundaries secretly, leading to their forced separation to conceal their transgression. Similarly, Daisy and Gatsby's forbidden relationship, constrained by class-based societal norms, remains unconsummated, echoing the overarching theme of unfulfilled desires constrained by societal expectations.

Unfulfilled Desire and Societal Constraints:

The grand narrative arc of both "The Scarlet Letter" and "The Great Gatsby" converges on the exploration of unfulfilled desires shackled by societal constraints. In Hawthorne's tale, the forbidden nature of Hester and Arthur's love necessitates their separation, compelling them to conceal their transgressions. Daisy and Gatsby face a different set of societal constraints — the rigid class divisions of the Jazz Age. The societal stigma attached to their union prevents the consummation of their love, echoing the broader theme of societal constraints shaping the trajectories of star-crossed lovers.

Conclusion:

As we traverse the landscapes of Hawthorne's Puritanical society and Fitzgerald's Jazz Age, a resounding theme emerges — the profound impact of societal values on the lives of individuals. Whether it be the overt condemnation faced by Hester and Arthur or the subtle yet insidious influence of materialism on Gatsby and Daisy, both novels offer poignant commentaries on the clash between personal desires and societal expectations. In the end, the characters seek moral centers from the excesses that surround them, with Nick Carraway retreating to the Mid-West and Hester finding solace in a New England village. Through this comparative analysis, we gain a richer understanding of the timeless resonance of these American classics and the enduring relevance of their societal critiques.