To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
'Final Diagnosis' by Arthur Hailey, though often perceived as a medical thriller, transcends the typical portrayal of medical dramas. Instead of focusing on the high-stakes drama of operating rooms and emergency situations, Hailey intricately delves into the realm of pathology, shedding light on the often-overlooked role of pathologists in the medical field. This essay aims to critically analyze the novel, exploring the themes of institutional resistance to change, the significance of pathology, and the interplay between experience and innovation.
The narrative unfolds within the backdrop of Three Counties, an aging hospital grappling with financial constraints and outdated facilities.
The focal point is the Pathology department, led by the experienced Dr. Joe Pearson, a man resistant to change. Despite the dire need for modernization in the department, Dr. Pearson staunchly adheres to traditional methods, creating a tension that permeates the entire hospital.
Hailey astutely captures the hospital's internal politics, delving into the lives of nurses, interns, and residents.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Blood Groups
5 (893)
“ Thank you so much for accepting my assignment the night before it was due. I look forward to working with you moving forward ”
The struggle for funds and the reluctance to embrace modern practices hinder the hospital's ability to attract skilled doctors. This institutional resistance becomes evident when a critical test, essential for the well-being of a pregnant patient, is denied due to budget constraints, setting the stage for a clash between the old guard and a young, visionary pathologist.
One of the novel's distinctive features is Hailey's choice to highlight pathology, a less-explored field in mainstream literature. The story introduces Dr.
Coleman, a brilliant and ambitious young pathologist who challenges the status quo. The conflict escalates when a denied test results in a premature birth, leading to the tragic death of an infant. This heartbreaking event becomes a catalyst for change, exposing the consequences of clinging to outdated practices in the field of pathology.
Dr. Coleman's relentless pursuit of innovation, symbolized by his insistence on ordering a critical test, serves as a metaphor for the inevitability of progress. The novel effectively underscores the indispensable role of pathology in diagnosis and treatment, making the readers acutely aware of its significance in the medical landscape.
The clash between Dr. Pearson and Dr. Coleman serves as a microcosm of the broader tension between experience and innovation within institutional settings. Dr. Pearson, with 35 years of experience, represents the old guard that is resistant to change. His reluctance stems from a fear of losing control and a belief in the efficacy of established methods. On the other hand, Dr. Coleman, a young and intellectually superior pathologist, embodies the enthusiasm for progress and the willingness to challenge traditional norms.
The eventual resignation of Dr. Pearson marks a symbolic shift in power, with Dr. Coleman assuming the leadership of the Pathology department. The poignant dialogue between the two characters during this transition encapsulates the essence of the narrative, shedding light on the inevitable transformation that occurs as one progresses in their career. It raises profound questions about the balance between experience and innovation in a rapidly evolving medical landscape.
'Final Diagnosis' offers readers a compelling exploration of the dynamics of change within the medical profession. By choosing pathology as the focal point, Hailey masterfully unveils the intricacies of a hospital struggling with outdated practices and the resistance to innovation. The clash between the seasoned Dr. Pearson and the visionary Dr. Coleman serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the broader challenges faced by institutions in adapting to evolving practices.
This critical analysis underscores the novel's significance in portraying the critical role of pathologists, the need for institutional change, and the delicate balance between experience and innovation. 'Final Diagnosis' stands as a testament to Arthur Hailey's ability to weave a narrative that not only entertains but also prompts reflection on the complexities of the medical profession.
As we delve deeper into the nuances of 'Final Diagnosis,' it becomes imperative to consider the broader implications of the novel's themes. The portrayal of institutional resistance opens a window into the challenges faced by real-world hospitals striving to modernize and meet the evolving needs of patients. The characters, particularly Dr. Pearson and Dr. Coleman, become archetypes representing the perpetual struggle between tradition and progress within the medical field.
The significance of the premature birth incident reverberates beyond the confines of the narrative, prompting readers to contemplate the real-world consequences of outdated medical practices. Hailey's meticulous exploration of pathology as a field not only adds a unique dimension to the novel but also serves as a call for greater appreciation of the often-overlooked contributions of pathologists in the healthcare system.
In conclusion, 'Final Diagnosis' emerges as a literary work that transcends its genre, offering readers a profound exploration of the challenges inherent in the medical profession. Through the lens of pathology, the novel provides insights into the complexities of institutional change, the critical role of pathologists, and the delicate balance required to navigate the evolving landscape of healthcare. As we navigate the pages of 'Final Diagnosis,' we are not merely spectators to a medical drama but participants in a reflective journey that prompts us to question, learn, and envision a future where progress coexists harmoniously with experience.
The Dynamics of Change: A Critical Analysis of 'Final Diagnosis'. (2016, Oct 11). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/the-final-diagnosis-book-review-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
