To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
The way artists can look at a scene in numerous various lights is really similar to what Earle Birney did when he wrote "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" and "Vancouver Lights". An artist can paint a picture of a given setting and then return and paint a totally different painting of the same topic. The 2 poems share similarities however where the description of "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" ends, the style for "Vancouver Lights" begins. The two poems based on the very same setting develop totally various concepts in the readers mind.
Evidently, Birney's poems both include extremely effective descriptions, however the two descriptions have different results on the reader.
"January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" beautifully explains exactly the title of the poem. However, the poem missing out on meat or substance, does not need the reader to examine it in any method. In contrast, the very first paragraph of "Vancouver Lights" is also a description, but this just sets the tone and enables the reader to get a sensation of the poems future.
For instance, when Birney states, "to search this quilt of light is an unpleasant pleasure"( Earle Birney, "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver) implies a surprise meaning where as, "The streets wait outside/ chained to their hydrants"( Earle Birney, Vancouver Lights) just describes.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Artists
4.7 (348)
“ Amazing as always, gave her a week to finish a big assignment and came through way ahead of time. ”
Although the poems are blogged about the very same city, the descriptions Birney composes vary and indicate different meanings. Resemblances in the 2 poems are hard to discover because they both have different agendas.
The immediate understanding of "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" totally contrasts the extreme idea procedure needed to totally understand "Vancouver lights".
Birneys wants the reader to think of mankind's insignificance and that mankind can create and damage itself in "Vancouver Lights" where as "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" needs little analyses, therefore drawing out the style appears difficult since of its simplicity.
When Birney writes, "These Rays were ours / we made and unmade them Not the shudder of continents / doused us the moon's passion nor the crash of comets" ( Earle Birney, Vancouver Lights) he acknowledges the fact that mankind are creators and destroyers, but in "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" the reader can not find a phrase that has a deeper meaning. Also, "Vancouver Lights" has numerous references to ancient symbols such as: Phoebus, Nubian, Prometheus, Nebulae and Aldebaran.
This puts "Vancouver Lights" on a different level from "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" because it requires the reader to have some pre-conceived knowledge to understand the theme and meaning of the poem. The simplicity in "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" and complexity of "Vancouver Lights" makes similarities of the two difficult to uncover, yet the reader can see a direct link between the two because of the setting.
These two poems paint completely contrasting pictures because "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" only describes while " Vancouver Lights" requires previous knowledge and in-depth thinking to unlock the theme. The simplicity of "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" creates detailed images but Birney leaves little to the readers' imagination. On the other hand, "Vancouver Lights" about the same setting, forces the reader to think and discover the theme on their own. Like an artist can paint different pictures of the same subject, Birney accomplishes this in his poems, "January Morning/Downtown Vancouver" and "Vancouver Lights".
Same Artist, Different Pictures. (2016, Sep 15). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/same-artist-different-pictures-2-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
