Marrying for Love: Unraveling Stephanie Coontz's Perspective

Introduction

Stephanie Coontz, in her essay on "The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love," presents a compelling argument regarding the unrealistic expectations surrounding marriage, as influenced by George Bernard Shaw's perspective. Shaw's belief that marriage is an institution founded on intense, transient passions becomes a focal point for Coontz's exploration of historical attitudes towards matrimony. In this essay, we delve into Coontz's analysis, examining the historical context and societal norms that shaped the concept of marrying for love.

The Successful Marriage: Love as the Foundation

While Coontz acknowledges the historical inconceivability of choosing mates based on love, she contends that love is the cornerstone of a successful marriage.

Despite various factors contributing to the decision to marry, she argues that love stands out as the most pivotal. Marrying for financial stability or other reasons, divorced from genuine affection, may lead to an inherently unstable relationship. Coontz highlights the significance of marital vows, crafted to ensure that love remains resilient in the face of challenges, safeguarding the bond between spouses.

Get quality help now

Sweet V

Verified writer

Proficient in: Love

4.9 (984)

“ Ok, let me say I’m extremely satisfy with the result while it was a last minute thing. I really enjoy the effort put in. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Even historical societies that eventually accepted love in marriage placed stringent societal constraints on appropriate behavior for married couples.

Coontz illustrates how love, in some cultures, was viewed negatively, portraying it as an illicit and socially disapproved relationship. The societal norms dictated that the love for a spouse should not surpass that for family or God. In China, the term "love" could denote an inappropriate relationship, and parents could enforce divorce if they disapproved of their son's choice, regardless of his feelings.

Coontz successfully unveils the historical complexities and societal attitudes that shaped the perception of love within marriage.

Marrying for Love in Europe: Historical Perspectives

Exploring the European context during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, Coontz emphasizes the aristocrats' tendency to view adultery as the ultimate expression of love. The Countess of Champagne believed that genuine love was impossible between married individuals. In her eyes, if love could not flourish within marriage, the sacred vow to love and honor each other became a mockery before God. Coontz extends her analysis to the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, highlighting how families determined their children's marriages, with love considered a subsequent, not primary, factor. The essay underscores that, historically, love in marriage was perceived as a bonus rather than a necessity.

Coontz's meticulous research and inclusion of historical instances and quotes strengthen her argument, revealing that marrying for love was not always deemed the paramount consideration when selecting a life partner.

Conclusion: The Power of Love in Marriage

In conclusion, Stephanie Coontz's exploration of the radical idea of marrying for love provides valuable insights into historical perspectives and societal norms. While she adeptly argues against the prevailing historical notions, acknowledging that love was not always the primary factor in marriage, it's essential to recognize the transformative power of love. Coontz's comprehensive research and analysis bring historical complexities to light, illustrating that societal attitudes toward love in marriage have evolved over time.

For those who have experienced the profoundness of love in marriage, Coontz's historical insights may be thought-provoking. Love, as the foundation of marriage, offers a unique and fulfilling bond—a partnership that transcends the challenges of life. Ultimately, Coontz's essay sparks contemplation on the evolving nature of love within the institution of marriage and the enduring significance of this powerful and transformative emotion.

Written by Lucas Davis

Updated: Jan 18, 2024

Keep in mind: this is only a sample!

Updated: Jan 18, 2024