Navigating Identity: Leanita McClain's Struggle as a Middle-Class Black Woman Free Essay Example

To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”

The Middle Class Black's Burden: A Reflection on Leanita McClain's Struggle

Leanita McClain, a prominent African American journalist, faced a unique struggle as a successful middle-class black woman. Despite her achievements, she was met with criticism from both her own community and white individuals who dismissed her success as merely a product of talent rather than affirmative action. This dual pressure forced McClain to navigate a complex path, torn between the expectations of her race and her personal aspirations. In her poignant essay, "The Middle Class Black's Burden," McClain employs precise rhetorical strategies to articulate the weight of her experience, utilizing elements such as Compare/Contrast, Author's Tone, and Logical Appeal.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get your custom essay on

“ Navigating Identity: Leanita McClain’s Struggle as a Middle-Class Black Woman ”

Get custom paper

NEW! smart matching with writer

McClain skillfully employs the rhetorical strategy of compare/contrast to illustrate the burden she carries. By juxtaposing her humble childhood with her current status as a middle-class black woman, she highlights the stark differences in perception. Her peers accused her of betraying her roots by embracing a middle-class lifestyle, leading to feelings of alienation and betrayal.

McClain eloquently expresses this conflict in her essay, stating, "It is impossible for me to forget where I came from as long as I am prey to the jiv hustler who does not hesitate to exploit my childhood friendship." This comparison effectively conveys the impact of societal expectations on her identity.

Furthermore, McClain's tone throughout the essay plays a crucial role in conveying her emotional turmoil. Her tone oscillates between confusion and despondency, reflecting the internal struggle she faces. Uncertain whether to align herself with her community or pursue her individual ambitions, McClain finds herself torn between conflicting loyalties.

As she poignantly expresses, "I have a foot in each world, but I cannot fool myself about either. I can see the transparent deceptions of some whites and the bitter hopelessness of some blacks." This emotional depth adds a layer of complexity to her narrative, resonating with readers on a personal level.

Lastly, McClain employs Logical Appeal as a rhetorical strategy to underscore the rationale behind her perceived burden. By utilizing ethos and pathos, she establishes her credibility as an African American journalist while also appealing to the emotions of her audience. Despite her professional success, the judgment she faces from both white and black individuals leaves her feeling isolated and misunderstood. In her essay, "My Turn," she candidly reveals, "Some of my liberal white acquaintances pat me on the head, hinting that I am a freak,[...] , I may live among them, but it is difficult to live with them." This logical appeal effectively conveys the internal conflict she grapples with, shedding light on the complexities of her experience.

In conclusion, McClain's adept use of rhetorical strategies not only enhances the reader's understanding but also illuminates the challenges faced by a middle-class black woman in a society rife with prejudice and judgment. Her nuanced approach to Compare/Contrast, Author's Tone, and Logical Appeal enriches the thematic depth of her narrative, offering a poignant reflection on identity and belonging.

References