To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
The tumultuous years of 1789 and 1917 marked significant turning points in European history, witnessing the rise of radical changes and political upheavals. In 1789, France embarked on the transformative journey of the French Revolution, while in 1917, Russia experienced its own revolution. These historical events, although occurring in different times, share striking similarities in their origins, progressions, and consequences. This essay explores the social and political parallels and distinctions between the French and Russian revolutions, shedding light on the factors that shaped the destiny of Europe in the aftermath of these upheavals.
The genesis of the French Revolution in 1789 can be traced back to a severe fiscal crisis exacerbated by France's financial support for the American Revolution.
Famine gripped the nation, leading to widespread discontent among the peasants. The Estates-General, a form of parliament, was established, but the frustration of the third estate, the ordinary people, culminated in the Tennis Court Oath on June 20th, 1789. This marked the inception of a bottom-up revolution, driven by the lower class.
Similarly, the Russian Revolution of 1917 emerged from a backdrop of famine and poverty.
Verified writer
Proficient in: French Revolution
4.7 (657)
“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”
The Bloody Sunday incident in 1905, where peasants marched toward the Winter Palace, echoed the bottom-up dynamics seen in France. In response, Tsar Nicholas II implemented the Duma, a parliamentary body, in an attempt to quell the crisis. However, dissatisfaction persisted, leading to a full-scale revolution in 1917.
Both revolutions also saw the influence of literature shaping public discourse. France drew inspiration from Voltaire's ideas on the separation of church and state, while Russia was influenced by Karl Marx and his socialist ideals outlined in the Communist Manifesto.
As the revolutions unfolded, notable similarities in their progression became evident.
Both France and Russia experienced foreign intervention during critical junctures. The Declaration of Pillnitz in 1791 saw Prussia and the Holy Roman Empire supporting Louis XVI, leading to France declaring war. In the Russian Revolution, the Allied powers, including Great Britain, America, and France, intervened against communism.
Class tension was a common thread in both revolutions, manifesting as a divide between parliament and the streets. In France, the Third Estate opposed the monarchy, while in Russia, the Soviets were at odds with the Duma. The revolutions transcended parliamentary realms, with public uprisings such as the storming of Bastille in 1789 and the Winter Palace in 1917.
The aftermath of the French and Russian revolutions exhibited both similarities and differences. In both cases, the reigning monarchies faced dire consequences, with King Louis XVI and Tsar Nicholas II, along with their families, meeting tragic ends.
Both revolutions descended into periods of civil war and chaos. The Reign of Terror in France resulted in the deaths of thousands of civilians, while in Russia, the post-war period in the 1920s saw more civilian casualties due to poverty and famine than the First World War and the revolution combined.
Ultimately, both revolutions culminated in totalitarian governmental control. Napoleon emerged as the dictator in France, and Lenin seized power in Russia, later succeeded by Stalin. Despite their different initial goals – France seeking a capitalistic democratic state and Russia aspiring to communism – both countries ended up with totalitarian regimes, mirroring their pre-revolutionary states.
Interestingly, the trajectories of France and Russia diverged in the long run. While both initially succumbed to totalitarian rule, France eventually transitioned into a democracy. In contrast, the Soviet Union emerged as the first socialist state, emphasizing communism.
It is crucial to note that, following these revolutions, both France and Russia assumed pivotal roles in world politics. France became a significant player in World War I, while Russia, later transformed into the Soviet Union, became a major global power during the Cold War.
In conclusion, the French and Russian revolutions of 1789 and 1917, respectively, share compelling similarities in their origins, progression, and aftermath. Both were ignited by financial crises, involved the implementation of parliamentary bodies, and witnessed the influence of literature in shaping ideologies. The revolutions unfolded with foreign interventions, class tensions, and public uprisings against the monarchy. The aftermath brought about totalitarian rule in both cases, though their ultimate trajectories diverged with France embracing democracy and the Soviet Union championing socialism. These revolutions, despite their nuanced differences, left an indelible mark on Europe and the global stage, reshaping political, social, and economic landscapes for generations to come.
Comparative Analysis: French and Russian Revolutions. (2016, Mar 01). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/french-and-russian-revolution-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
