Balancing Ethics: Protecting Animals through Law Enforcement

Animals around the globe face mistreatment and abuse, often at the hands of individuals who show little regard for their well-being. Despite existing laws designed to protect animals—whether they are domestic, farm, or wildlife animals—compliance remains a significant issue. This essay argues that greater attention should be directed towards enforcing existing laws for animal welfare rather than considering the creation of a separate Bill of Rights for animals, as it may be perceived as an extreme measure. While animals undeniably deserve protection from intentional harm, the key lies in the stringent enforcement of already established laws.

The Ethical Imperative of Humane Scientific Experimentation

One compelling reason to advocate for the protection of animals is the unethical treatment they endure during scientific experiments. It is crucial to acknowledge that not all experiments cause harm, as exemplified by a study at Oxford University. In this experiment, two birds, Betty and Abel, were presented with a choice between a straight wire and a hooked wire to extract a piece of meat from a tube.

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Animal Bill Of Rights

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

The birds were merely observed, and no harm befell them. However, the ethical question arises when animals are subjected to experiments that inflict cruelty upon them. If experiments involving animals are deemed necessary, they should be conducted with meticulous care to ensure the well-being of the animals involved.

Combatting Cruelty in the Name of Entertainment

Another significant aspect demanding our attention is the mistreatment of animals for entertainment purposes. Wildlife animals, including lions, tigers, bears, deer, and cheetahs, fall victim to hunting practices that target them for their meat or fur.

Similarly, fishing, considered a form of sports entertainment, often inflicts unseen pain on the caught fish. In Victoria Braithwaite's article, "Hooked on a Myth," the alarming reality of sportsmen worldwide dragging millions of fish to shore on barbed hooks is highlighted. It underscores the urgency for society to reflect on the consequences of such activities and recognize the sentience of animals, even if they do not express pain vocally.

Research Ethics: Balancing Scientific Progress and Animal Welfare

The ethical dilemma extends to the realm of research, particularly when it involves animals closely related to humans, such as apes, gorillas, and chimpanzees. The notion that our closest relatives should be subjected to research to understand human functions raises ethical concerns. As Franz de Waal of Emory University points out in Ed Yong's article, "Of Primates and Personhood," there exists a risk of creating a hierarchy of rights if certain animals are granted special consideration due to their genetic proximity to humans. This prompts the question: should only animals closely related to us receive rights, leaving others vulnerable to exploitation?

The belief in special obligations to great apes challenges us to reconsider the treatment of all animals in research settings. Animals like monkeys, dogs, and rats, though genetically different, are still subjected to experimentation without adequate care. This lack of consideration for the well-being of animals reflects an inhumane perspective, where the convenience of humans takes precedence over the ethical treatment of living beings.

Conclusion: Enforcing Existing Laws for Animal Welfare

The worldwide mistreatment and abuse of animals necessitate urgent attention, but the proposed solution should align with the severity of the problem. While animals undeniably require protection from harm, creating a Bill of Rights for animals might be an extreme measure. Instead, a more practical approach involves strict enforcement of existing laws that are designed to safeguard animals. Society must recognize the ethical imperative of humane treatment in scientific experiments, combat cruelty in the name of entertainment, and reevaluate the ethics surrounding animal research. By adhering to and reinforcing established laws, we can strike a balance between scientific progress and animal welfare, ultimately ensuring a more humane coexistence between humans and animals.