The Complexity of Walter Mitty: A Journey Between Fantasy and Reality

Daydreaming is a universal phenomenon that offers a respite from the mundane aspects of daily life, allowing individuals to explore the realms of imagination. One striking example of a chronic daydreamer is Walter Mitty, the central character in James Thurber's 1942 story, "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty." Mitty's constant reliance on daydreams as an escape from reality unveils a character deeply entangled in feelings of incompetence and a strained relationship with his wife. This essay delves into the intricate layers of Walter Mitty's character, exploring the stark contrast between his imagined prowess and his palpable ineptitude in real life.

The Duality of Walter Mitty

Walter Mitty's daydreaming tendencies are evident from the story's onset as he ferries his wife to a beauty shop appointment. In the midst of mundane reality, Mitty envisions himself as the capable commander of a Navy hydroplane facing a crisis. The crew, in his daydream, places unwavering trust in his abilities, a stark contrast to the disapproval he faces from his wife in the tangible world.

Get quality help now

KarrieWrites

Verified writer

Proficient in: The Secret Life of Walter Mitty

5 (339)

“ KarrieWrites did such a phenomenal job on this assignment! He completed it prior to its deadline and was thorough and informative. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

This recurring dichotomy between Mitty's competent daydream self and his inept real-life persona serves as a thematic anchor throughout the narrative.

Mitty's awareness of his incompetence is further exemplified in his recollection of a failed attempt to remove snow chains from his car tires. The incident, as recounted by Carl Sundell, underscores Mitty's lack of mechanical aptitude, pushing him into a mental rather than a physical realm of activity. Sundell's analysis sheds light on the psychological underpinnings of Mitty's daydreams, suggesting they are an escape from a world where his hands fail him.

Moreover, Mitty's incompetence extends beyond mechanical matters. In simple tasks like parking his car correctly or remembering to buy puppy biscuits, he falters. These small failures become triggers for elaborate daydreams, such as one where he finds himself on trial for murder. Each instance of real-life inadequacy propels Mitty into a vivid and heroic imaginary realm.

The Strained Relationship with Mrs. Mitty

The core conflict in Mitty's life emerges from his relationship with his wife, Mrs. Mitty. Charles S. Holmes posits that the theme of the story revolves around the conflict between the world of fantasy and the harsh reality Mitty faces. Mrs. Mitty represents a realm where Mitty consistently falls short, unable to meet her expectations, and consequently seeks solace in his inner fantasies.

Extending this analysis, Lindner suggests that Mitty's occasional childlike behavior stems from the maternal role Mrs. Mitty assumes. This maternal dynamic becomes especially apparent at the story's conclusion when Mrs. Mitty finds him in a hotel lobby, reproaching him for forgetting puppy biscuits and neglecting to wear his new overshoes. Her admonishments echo those of a mother scolding a child, reinforcing the idea that Mitty's daydreams serve as a coping mechanism for his perceived inadequacies in the face of maternal authority.

This strained relationship with Mrs. Mitty becomes a significant factor in Mitty's need for daydreams as an escape. As Holmes observes, when Mitty feels constrained by his wife's demands and expectations, he retreats into his inner world of fantasy. The conflict between the world of Mitty's mind and the external reality is most evident in his interactions with Mrs. Mitty, further complicating the character's psychological landscape.

The Enduring Appeal of Walter Mitty

Despite the melancholy air surrounding Walter Mitty's character, he has managed to captivate readers for decades. Robert Morsberger highlights the story's popularity during World War II, indicating that it resonated with soldiers who, like Mitty, felt trapped and helpless. Charles Holmes further suggests that Mitty's secret blackouts provided emotional comic relief for those facing the challenges of wartime.

Even today, Walter Mitty remains a beloved character, continuing to entertain readers of all ages. The story's enduring popularity attests to its timeless exploration of the human psyche, the interplay between fantasy and reality, and the universal theme of seeking refuge in imagination when faced with the challenges of life.

In conclusion, "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty" transcends its initial publication in 1942, offering readers a timeless exploration of the human psyche. Walter Mitty's character, with his dual existence in both the real and imagined worlds, serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities individuals face in navigating their internal and external realities. Whether driven by a need to escape incompetence or a strained relationship, Mitty's daydreams provide solace and entertainment, resonating with audiences across generations.