Addressing Coupon Accounting Abuse: A Comprehensive Analysis

Business organizations have long grappled with the persistent challenges of incentive, opportunity, and rationalization that contribute to fraudulent activities within their ranks. The manifestation of fraud can take various forms, necessitating the implementation of robust internal controls to mitigate such risks. Despite the existence of preventive measures, businesses remain vulnerable to fraudulent activities. This essay focuses on a case study involving coupon accounting abuse, exploring questions related to company controls, strategies for preventing abuse, parties affected, and the classification of the fraud involved.

The Dynamics of Coupon Accounting Abuse

Question 1: Can a Company with a Good Control Environment Experience Coupon Accounting Abuse?

Ensuring a strong control environment is crucial for deterring fraud, yet even the most robust controls provide only reasonable assurance. In the case of coupon accounting abuse, where the brand manager is the perpetrator, the challenge intensifies. The phenomenon known as management override allows managers to bypass internal controls, posing a formidable obstacle for detection, even in companies with exemplary control mechanisms.

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Abuse

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Preventing Coupon Abuse: A Multifaceted Approach

Question 2: What Steps Can a Company Take to Prevent Coupon Abuse?

To curtail fraud abuse effectively, companies must adopt a multifaceted approach. First and foremost, a comprehensive code of ethics should be instituted, with rigorous training for all employees and managers to instill a strong ethical culture within the organization. The recruitment process should include thorough background checks to ensure the hiring of trustworthy individuals, and a clear segregation of duties should be established.

In the specific case of coupon accounting, where the brand manager holds complete control over estimating the coupon liability, additional precautions are warranted.

An essential step involves requiring approval of the estimate by another manager within the company, introducing a crucial layer of oversight. Furthermore, both internal and independent auditors should be informed about the significant impact coupons can have on the company's financial statements. Establishing a risk management group, in the form of a committee, can facilitate and coordinate the overall risk management process, tailoring strategies to the organization's size and nature (CIMA, 2009).

Parties Impacted by Coupon Accounting Abuse

Question 3: Who Might Be Harmed by Coupon Accounting Abuse?

Fraud, though often perceived as a victimless crime, inflicts considerable social and psychological damage on individuals, businesses, and society at large (CIMA, 2009). In the case at hand, the brand manager inflicts harm on multiple parties by manipulating the estimated redemption rate from 4% to 2%. This deceptive practice artificially inflates revenue, presenting a misleading picture of the company's profitability to managers and shareholders perusing financial statements.

Managers relying on inaccurate financial data may make decisions detrimental to the business, and shareholders will bear the brunt of added liability expenses in the subsequent year. Simultaneously, the brand manager jeopardizes their own well-being, facing termination and legal prosecution if their fraudulent activities come to light.

Management Fraud or Employee Fraud?

Question 4: Is the Example Management Fraud or Employee Fraud?

The perpetration of coupon accounting abuse aligns more closely with the characteristics of management fraud. Typically involving senior or high-level management, this form of fraud encompasses intentional misrepresentation of financial statements and improper use of company resources (Gottlieb, 2011). In this case, the brand manager, positioned as a senior figure, exhibits a myopic perspective, driven by the knowledge of managing another brand in the subsequent year.

This scenario reflects a growing trend in the workplace where managerial positions become susceptible to fraudulent activities. To combat such misconduct effectively, collaborative efforts are required from business management, external auditors, and all employees. Recognizing that fraud has far-reaching consequences, the implementation of stringent internal controls, conducive working environments, enhanced requirements for external auditors, and the establishment of codes of ethics can collectively contribute to countering fraud and malfeasance within corporate settings (Farrell, Franco, 1999).

Conclusion

In conclusion, coupon accounting abuse represents a significant challenge for businesses, requiring a nuanced and comprehensive approach to prevention and detection. While a strong control environment provides a foundation for deterring fraud, the dynamic nature of managerial override necessitates additional measures to safeguard against internal malfeasance. Implementing a code of ethics, thorough screening processes, segregation of duties, and proactive communication with auditors are essential steps in preventing coupon abuse.

Furthermore, recognizing the parties harmed by such fraudulent activities underscores the need for vigilance and corrective action. In the case of the brand manager manipulating coupon liabilities, the ramifications extend beyond financial misrepresentation, affecting decision-making processes and shareholder trust. By categorizing this example as management fraud, it becomes evident that targeted efforts to fortify ethical standards among senior management are imperative.

Ultimately, combating fraud in the corporate landscape demands a collective commitment from all stakeholders. Through meticulous internal controls, ethical guidelines, and collaborative efforts between management, auditors, and employees, businesses can strive towards a more resilient and fraud-resistant future.