StudyMoose App
24/7 writing help on your phone
Save to my list
Remove from my list
In the rich tapestry of literature, marriage and family serve as integral themes, shaping characters' lives and influencing the narrative trajectory. Karen van der Zee's novel "A Secret Sorrow" and Gail Godwin's short story "A Sorrowful Woman" both delve into the complexities of marital relationships and family dynamics, offering profound insights into the human experience. This essay aims to dissect the contrasting portrayals of marriage and family in these two works, exploring the emotional conflicts faced by their female protagonists and the ultimate implications for their lives.
Karen van der Zee's "A Secret Sorrow" introduces us to Faye, a protagonist whose conflict with marriage arises before the union itself. Faye's deep yearning for children becomes a source of misery and torment as she fears her inability to conceive may thwart her chance at marital bliss with Kai, the man she loves. The narrative weaves a tale of love, desire, and the societal expectations surrounding marriage, emphasizing Faye's belief that only through marriage and children can true happiness be achieved.
4.7 (348)
“ Amazing as always, gave her a week to finish a big assignment and came through way ahead of time. ”
The anxiety Faye experiences stems from the fear of losing Kai due to her perceived inadequacy. She articulates this fear, stating, "Every time we see some pregnant woman, every time we're with somebody else's children, I'll feel I've failed you!" (Zee 35). Van der Zee crafts a storyline where marriage is not only the resolution but also the key to unlocking Faye's fulfillment. Even in the face of Faye's inability to bear children, the narrative takes an idyllic turn as she and Kai marry and eventually adopt children, painting a picture of domestic bliss under the Texan skies.
Contrastingly, Gail Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" presents an unconventional and somber perspective on marriage and family life. The unnamed protagonist in Godwin's story experiences conflict after securing marriage and motherhood. In stark contrast to Faye's desires, this protagonist finds sorrow in the very roles that society traditionally considers sources of fulfillment.
The woman in Godwin's narrative, despite having a loving husband and child, becomes increasingly detached from her familial responsibilities. The mundane tasks of homemaking and childcare, symbolized by baking and doing laundry, contribute to her sense of defeat and sorrow. The story takes an unexpected turn as the protagonist isolates herself from her family, communicating solely through notes under her bedroom door, revealing a deep aversion to the roles of wife and mother.
Examining the two narratives side by side, the discrepancy in their depictions of marriage becomes evident. In "A Secret Sorrow," marriage is portrayed as the panacea to Faye's emotional turmoil, a pathway to unending happiness. Van der Zee constructs a narrative where the monotony of marriage is absent, and Faye's family life is described as idyllic, basking in the warmth of familial love and contentment.
In stark contrast, Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" maintains a tone of coldness and sorrow throughout. The protagonist's aversion to her roles as wife and mother challenges conventional notions of familial happiness. Godwin depicts the family as a burden, with the protagonist's sorrow intensifying at the sight of her loved ones, ultimately leading to her self-imposed imprisonment and tragic demise.
The pivotal moments where the protagonists interact with their families provide insightful glimpses into their emotional landscapes. In "A Secret Sorrow," Faye, sitting with her husband and watching her children play, perceives life as "good and filled with love" (Zee 37). Van der Zee paints a picture of familial harmony, suggesting that Faye's marriage is a source of joy and fulfillment.
Conversely, in "A Sorrowful Woman," Godwin's protagonist expresses a profound sadness and sickness at the sight of her family, articulating, "The sight of them made her so sad and sick she did not want to see them ever again" (Godwin 38). The author deliberately contrasts the joy in Faye's family with the melancholy in this unnamed woman's household, challenging the conventional narrative of familial bliss.
The weight attributed to marriage in both stories further emphasizes their divergent perspectives. In "A Secret Sorrow," Faye's marriage alleviates her fears and burdens, leading to a life filled with love and contentment. Van der Zee posits marriage as the resolution to Faye's internal conflicts, reinforcing the idea that a traditional family structure brings everlasting happiness.
In stark contrast, Godwin's character perceives marriage as a heavy burden, a force pressing on her, leading to her eventual immobilization. The routine duties of being a wife and mother become suffocating for the protagonist, pushing her into a self-imposed isolation. Unlike Faye, she cannot find joy in the traditional roles society assigns to women, and her sense of failure intensifies with each repetition of her domestic responsibilities.
The concluding stages of the two stories provide powerful illustrations of their differing outlooks on marriage and family. In "A Secret Sorrow," Faye's feelings are portrayed as "beautiful, complete, whole" (Zee 38) in her role as a wife and mother. Van der Zee leaves the reader with a sense of fulfillment and happiness emanating from the union of marriage and family.
In contrast, Godwin chooses an ambiguous approach to conclude "A Sorrowful Woman." Despite hints of creative energy and renewal, the story culminates in the protagonist's death, challenging traditional narratives that suggest a hopeful resolution. Godwin's narrative tone leans towards a cautionary perspective, encouraging readers to contemplate the potential consequences of societal expectations surrounding marriage.
In essence, these two works present a dichotomy in their exploration of marriage and family. "A Secret Sorrow" champions the traditional family structure as a source of ultimate happiness, portraying marriage and motherhood as the culmination of personal desires. On the other hand, "A Sorrowful Woman" challenges societal norms, highlighting the potential toll of conforming to traditional roles when they clash with individual desires and aspirations.
Ultimately, both narratives invite readers to reflect on the complexities of human relationships, societal expectations, and the quest for personal fulfillment within the context of marriage and family life. While van der Zee extols the virtues of traditional roles, Godwin prompts readers to question the assumptions embedded in these societal norms, fostering a nuanced understanding of the multifaceted nature of human experiences.
Delving deeper into the layers of meaning within these narratives, it is essential to consider the societal contexts in which these stories were penned. Karen van der Zee's "A Secret Sorrow" was published in a cultural landscape where the traditional family structure was often idealized, and societal expectations placed significant emphasis on the role of women as mothers and wives.
Conversely, Gail Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" emerged during a period marked by increased questioning of traditional gender roles and societal expectations. The feminist movement of the late 20th century brought forth a reevaluation of women's roles in society, challenging the notion that marriage and motherhood should be the sole sources of a woman's identity and fulfillment.
These contrasting perspectives on marriage and family in literature continue to resonate with contemporary audiences. The evolving discourse on gender roles, individual autonomy, and diverse family structures has sparked ongoing conversations about the expectations placed on individuals within the context of relationships.
"A Secret Sorrow" and "A Sorrowful Woman" offer readers the opportunity to engage in critical reflection on the societal norms that shape our understanding of marriage and family. The narratives become lenses through which we can examine the complexities of personal desires and societal expectations, prompting us to question whether traditional roles lead to fulfillment or, conversely, pose a risk to individual happiness.
In conclusion, the exploration of marriage and family in literature serves as a mirror reflecting societal values and expectations. Karen van der Zee's "A Secret Sorrow" and Gail Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" provide profound insights into the emotional landscapes of their female protagonists, offering divergent perspectives on the role of marriage in shaping one's sense of self and happiness.
While "A Secret Sorrow" aligns with traditional narratives of marital bliss and familial fulfillment, "A Sorrowful Woman" challenges these norms, presenting a cautionary tale of the potential consequences of societal expectations. As readers, we are encouraged to navigate the complex landscape of marriage and family, critically examining the roles assigned to individuals and questioning whether adherence to these roles leads to genuine fulfillment.
These literary works continue to hold relevance, prompting us to reevaluate our understanding of marriage and family in the ever-evolving tapestry of human relationships. As we move forward, let these narratives serve as catalysts for meaningful conversations about the diverse paths to happiness and fulfillment within the intricate dynamics of marriage and family life.
Exploring Marriage and Family in Literature. (2016, Aug 03). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/a-secret-sorrow-by-karen-van-der-zee-and-a-sorrowful-woman-gail-godwin-2-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
