New England and Chesapeake: Divergent Paths by 1700

Categories: Slavery And Freedom

The development of the New England and Chesapeake regions by 1700 was marked by profound differences, primarily rooted in their distinct religious backgrounds. Although sharing a common English origin and language, these regions experienced disparate trajectories, leading to the emergence of two markedly different societies. This essay explores the pivotal role of religion in shaping the daily lives, societal structures, and economic endeavors of New England and Chesapeake, while delving into the profound impact of divergent motivations and values.

Religious Foundations: New England as a Haven for Puritans

New England served as a refuge for religious separatists escaping persecution in England, particularly the Puritans.

This highly religious group sought a haven where they could practice their faith freely. In contrast, Chesapeake attracted individuals driven by economic motives, with a focus on exploiting the lucrative opportunities presented by tobacco cultivation. The distinction in motivations laid the groundwork for the formation of fundamentally different societies.

The Puritans, driven by a desire for religious freedom and communal living, established close-knit communities that centered around congregationalism.

Get quality help now
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Slavery And Freedom

star star star star 5 (339)

“ KarrieWrites did such a phenomenal job on this assignment! He completed it prior to its deadline and was thorough and informative. ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

Governor John Winthrop articulated their vision in "A Model of Christian Charity," aspiring to create a "city upon a hill." This vision aimed at establishing a societal model for the world to emulate. In just a decade, Massachusetts Bay Colony's population burgeoned from 700 to over 20,000, showcasing the success of their communal ideals.

In contrast, Chesapeake attracted individuals primarily seeking economic prosperity. The "gold diggers" who settled in this region were focused on maximizing profits rather than establishing communal societies. The Articles of Agreement in Springfield, Massachusetts, in 1636, highlight the meticulous planning of New England towns, ensuring equitable distribution of resources, regardless of social status.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

The dichotomy extended to the very composition of the settlers. New England was founded by families rather than single men seeking quick wealth, influencing societal values. Governor John Winthrop's emphasis on creating a society where individuals are knit together reflected in the planned communities of New England, fostering a sense of unity. In contrast, immigrants destined for Virginia often traveled as isolated men and women, indicating a distinct lack of communal ethos.

Societal Structures: Equality in the North, Slavery in the South

One of the defining differences between New England and Chesapeake was their stance on societal equality. While New Englanders championed the idea that every man should be equal, the Chesapeake region embraced slavery to meet the labor demands of the burgeoning tobacco industry. Indentured servitude and the headright system were attempted solutions in Chesapeake, with servants working for a set period or obtaining land in return. However, the reliance on slavery set the southern region on a distinct path, contributing to a societal structure that starkly contrasted the egalitarian ethos of New England.

Religious institutions also played a crucial role in shaping societal structures. The establishment of the Anglican and Congregational churches in 1775 reflected the religious divide between the regions. The Anglican Church became the official faith in the southern colonies, reinforcing a hierarchical societal structure. In contrast, Congregationalism, rooted in Puritan values, shaped the egalitarian structure of New England communities, emphasizing the importance of education and religious freedom.

Moreover, the Articles of Agreement in Springfield, Massachusetts, in 1636 exemplify the meticulous planning of New England towns, ensuring equitable distribution of resources irrespective of social status. This planned approach fostered a sense of community and unity, contributing to the development of a society centered around shared values and goals. The contrast with the Chesapeake region, where towns lacked such planning and communal ethos, further highlights the impact of societal structures on the divergence of these two regions.

Economic Pursuits: Agriculture in the South, Commerce and Education in the North

The economic pursuits of New England and Chesapeake further highlighted their divergence. In the South, the fertile soil and humid climate facilitated the growth of cash crops such as tobacco, rice, and indigo. This agricultural focus shaped the economy of the southern colonies, relying on enslaved labor to maximize profits. In contrast, the rocky soil of New England necessitated alternative economic endeavors.

New England's economy was characterized by commerce, trade, and education. The pursuit of knowledge was intrinsic to Puritan values, leading to the establishment of free schools for all children in the community—an unprecedented concept in Europe at the time. Fishing in the rich waters off the Massachusetts coast became a significant economic activity, further differentiating the North from the agrarian economy of the South.

The geographical differences between the regions also played a significant role in shaping their economic pursuits. The hot and humid climate of the South, coupled with fertile soil, made agriculture, particularly cash crops, the predominant way of life. In contrast, the rocky soil of New England limited agricultural output, prompting settlers to turn to the sea and dense forests for their livelihoods. The availability of rich fishing areas off the Massachusetts coast contributed to the flourishing maritime trade, reinforcing the economic disparities between the two regions.

Conclusion: Religious Influence as the Crucible of Divergence

In conclusion, the divergent paths of New England and Chesapeake by 1700 were deeply rooted in their contrasting religious backgrounds, motivations, and societal values. The Puritans' quest for religious freedom and communal living shaped New England into a society that valued equality, education, and close-knit communities. On the other hand, the economic pursuits of Chesapeake, driven by the lure of wealth, resulted in a society where slavery and hierarchical structures prevailed.

These differences in religious fervor, economic goals, and societal structures created two distinct regions that, despite sharing a common English origin, evolved into separate entities. The impact of these formative years is evident in the enduring cultural, economic, and social disparities between New England and Chesapeake, highlighting the enduring influence of early religious choices on the trajectory of American colonial development.

As we reflect on this historical juncture, it becomes clear that the influence of religious ideals extended beyond spiritual matters, permeating every facet of society. From the establishment of communities to the structuring of economies, the choices made by the early settlers left an indelible mark on the development of the New England and Chesapeake regions. The enduring legacy of these divergent paths continues to shape the cultural and social landscape of the United States, underscoring the importance of understanding the historical roots that have shaped the nation we know today.

Updated: Dec 15, 2023
Cite this page

New England and Chesapeake: Divergent Paths by 1700. (2016, Aug 03). Retrieved from

New England and Chesapeake: Divergent Paths by 1700 essay
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment