The Lowest Animal: Unraveling Twain's Satirical Critique

Mark Twain, celebrated for his wit and humor, presents a scathing satire in his essay "The Lowest Animal." Within this work, Twain provocatively suggests that humans are inferior to all animals, save the French. The essay is a masterful exploration of three key themes: the influence of religion on human behavior, the distinctions between higher and lower animals, and the paradox of human morality.

Religious Hypocrisy and Human Brutality

Twain launches his critique by dissecting the role of religion in shaping human conduct.

He highlights a historical episode marked by religious clashes, particularly the conflict between Catholics and Protestants. The brutality unfolds as Catholics surprise and massacre unprepared Protestants, an event met with celebration by the Pope and the Church (Twain 1247). This historical narrative serves as a stark backdrop to Twain's satirical commentary on the destructive potential of religious fervor.

The essay takes a darkly humorous turn as Twain exposes the hypocrisy embedded in religious dogma. He wryly observes, "He [man] is the only animal that loves his neighbor as himself, and cuts his throat if his theology isn't straight" (Twain 1250).

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Moral

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

This biting remark lays bare Twain's skepticism toward organized religion, portraying it as a source not only of hypocrisy but also of brutal conflict.

Twain delves deeper into the fallacies of religious thinking by highlighting the human characteristic of intellectuality and religion. He points out the paradox that, even with the capacity to reason, humans yearn for an afterlife devoid of intellectual joys (Twain 1253). In this, Twain challenges the rationality of religious beliefs, emphasizing their hypocritical and illogical nature.

Differentiating Higher and Lower Animals: A Scientific Exploration

Transitioning to a scientific lens, Twain meticulously dissects the distinctions between higher and lower animals. He accentuates the inherent violence and unnecessary killings that characterize human behavior, contrasting it with the relatively harmonious nature of animal interactions. Twain notes that higher animals engage in individual fights but refrain from organized mass violence, a sharp contrast to the indiscriminate brutality of human conflict (Twain 1250).

Twain's scientific scrutiny extends to experiments involving caged animals, exposing the stark differences in behavior between higher and lower animals. From peaceful coexistence to needless killings, Twain's observations illustrate the capacity for violence inherent in human nature. Notably, his juxtaposition of lower animals and humans from diverse cultural backgrounds in a confined space underscores the chaos and carnage that can result from needless human conflicts (Twain 1251).

The exploration of human violence is intricately tied to the theme of differentiating higher and lower animals. Twain's use of the scientific method becomes a powerful tool for highlighting the moral shortcomings of humanity.

The Paradox of Human Morality

Twain contends that while humans possess a singular superior trait—morality, they fail to employ it judiciously, rendering themselves the lowest animal. Drawing a distinction between humans and animals like cats, Twain asserts that humans carry the moral looseness descended from animals like cats but lack the unconsciousness that excuses the cat's behavior (Twain 1249).

Throughout the essay, Twain underscores the paradox of human morality. He asserts that the human ability to distinguish good from evil brings with it the conscious choice to commit evil acts. Twain argues, "there can be no evil act without the presence of consciousness of it in the doer of it" (Twain 1252). This exploration delves into the nuanced nature of human morality, highlighting the conscious choices humans make in perpetrating morally questionable actions.

Twain's examination of the moral sense becomes a focal point, emphasizing the human capacity to choose between good and evil. By illustrating that humans have the ability to make moral choices, Twain posits that their propensity for choosing evil actions places them in the category of the lowest animal.

Conclusion: Unveiling the Worst Angles of Humanity

In "The Lowest Animal," Mark Twain employs satire as a powerful tool to challenge the prevailing notion of human superiority. Through a meticulous exploration of religious hypocrisy, the distinctions between higher and lower animals, and the paradox of human morality, Twain paints a satirical picture of the worst angles of human nature. This essay stands as a poignant critique of human behavior, questioning the ethical foundation of the so-called "accent of man." Twain's acerbic wit and astute observations compel readers to reflect on the darker aspects of human existence, leaving an indelible mark on the discourse surrounding humanity's place in the natural order.