The Complex Geometry of Love in "The Knight's Tale"

Geoffrey Chaucer's "The Knight's Tale," the opening story in "The Canterbury Tales," delves into the intricate exploration of love, the most powerful and enigmatic of human emotions. Love, often considered a law unto itself, proves challenging to dissect due to its unpredictable and multifaceted nature. However, Chaucer employs the symbolic geometry of a triangle to masterfully construct a narrative framework that unveils the intricate dynamics of love through the intertwined lives of the story's central characters: Palamon, Arcite, and Emily.

The Foundation: Palamon and Arcite

At the core of the love triangle in "The Knight's Tale" lies the relationship between Palamon and Arcite.

These two men share an unbreakable bond forged by their common origin and shared destiny. Their deep affection for each other is akin to brotherly love, and until their paths diverge, they are virtually indistinguishable from one another. Initially, both are found half-dead, victims of an attack by Duke Theseus. Rescued from a pile of bodies, they are subsequently imprisoned in a tower adjacent to Theseus' garden.

Get quality help now

Sweet V

Verified writer

Proficient in: Triangle

4.9 (984)

“ Ok, let me say I’m extremely satisfy with the result while it was a last minute thing. I really enjoy the effort put in. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Their undifferentiated identities and unwavering loyalty form the strong and stable foundation upon which the love triangle is built.

The Introduction of Emily: Restructuring the Triangle

The introduction of Emily as the object of desire marks the third point of the love triangle, triggering a profound transformation in the narrative's geometry. Love at first sight serves as the catalyst for this shift, imbuing Palamon and Arcite with newfound individuality and dimensionality. Initially, both cousins seem to share a similar approach to Emily.

However, subtle distinctions begin to emerge. Palamon, the first to lay eyes on Emily, accuses Arcite of harboring a "mystical…holy love" for her, in contrast to his own love, which he views as more grounded in reality. Chaucer's narrative commentary on the disparity between romanticized "courtly love" and the sincerity of "true love" becomes evident through this distinction. Although Palamon and Arcite share a common desire for Emily, their evolving perceptions of love sow the seeds of discord and resentment.

Despite their growing differences, Palamon and Arcite remain bound by their shared longing for Emily. The psychological rivalry between them endures, even as Palamon remains imprisoned and Arcite gains his freedom. Arcite, fearing that Palamon may secure Emily's affection, laments that his cousin now possesses "the fruit" of their shared desire. This tragic rivalry, intensified by their mutual competition, underscores the inherent tension within a love triangle. Strong relationships are typically built on the connection between two individuals rather than three. A love triangle, by its very nature, signifies discord and dissatisfaction, akin to a dissonant chord in music. Such triangles inherently seek resolution.

In "The Knight's Tale," this resolution is ultimately imposed by Theseus, who engineers a decisive jousting tournament to determine the fate of the conflicted trio. In the lead-up to this inevitable showdown, each of the three characters selects a different deity to hear their prayers. Arcite beseeches Mars for assistance in winning the battle, while Palamon implores Venus to help him win Emily's heart. These choices reveal the underlying motives of both friends. Arcite's desire for victory stems from a thirst for the glory associated with winning Emily's hand, rather than a genuine love for her. This revelation contradicts the reader's initial perception of Arcite's motivations. In a dramatic turn of events, Arcite tragically meets his demise by falling on his chest while riding toward Theseus, rather than Emily, his apparent prize. His self-aggrandizing actions suggest that his primary motivation was the prestige accorded to him by Theseus, rather than a genuine affection for Emily. Conversely, Palamon's unwavering devotion to Emily reflects the notion that true love can endure and triumph even in the most hopeless circumstances.

Emily's Role: Equidistant Object of Desire

Throughout the majority of the narrative, Emily's role primarily revolves around being the object of desire within the love triangle. However, her own ambivalence toward her suitors keeps her equidistantly removed from both men. Emily's desire to maintain her virginity and resist marriage to either Palamon or Arcite arises from her identity as the sister of Hippolyta, an Amazon at heart. Before the climactic battle, Emily fervently prays at the temple of Diana, beseeching the goddess to preserve her chastity and allow her to remain a perpetual virgin huntress. Emily's initial plea for chastity preservation is denied, as Diana, a goddess herself, understands the inevitability of change in life. Emily ultimately acquiesces to this higher power, modifying her request to marry the one who loves her most.

The Symbolism of the Triangle

The triangle holds a special place in mathematics as the most fundamental and stable shape. Larger polygons can be deconstructed into triangles, and the sum of their interior angles always totals a constant 180 degrees, irrespective of their side lengths. In "The Knight's Tale," a pair of points initially defines a simple relationship, while the addition of a third point establishes a plane, symbolically alluding to the complexity of society. The tale's conclusion brings a semblance of equilibrium as the desires of the central characters are ultimately fulfilled: Arcite emerges victorious in the battle, Palamon secures his true love, and Emily marries the one who loves her most.

Moreover, the triangle's mathematical properties draw a parallel to the paradoxical concept that love and hate originate from the same emotional foundation, merely turned 180 degrees apart. While the triangle signifies balance, it also represents the Greek letter delta, a symbol of change. One of the central themes in "The Knight's Tale" revolves around the seemingly arbitrary nature of fate. The narrative underscores that a person's character bears minimal influence on their destiny. Change, as exemplified by the triangular shape, is an inevitable aspect of life that individuals must accept, as it lies beyond personal control.

Conclusion

Love, as the most powerful and elusive of human emotions, governs our relationships and, by extension, our society. Its inherent abstractness only serves to amplify its influence. In "The Canterbury Tales," specifically in "The Knight's Tale," Geoffrey Chaucer fearlessly confronts the enigma of love. Through the complex love triangle involving Palamon, Arcite, and Emily, Chaucer celebrates the omnipotence of love.

The emotional intricacies that pervade the relationships among the three lovers are mirrored symbolically in the geometric properties of triangles. Ultimately, the enduring and multifaceted three-way relationship, which simultaneously binds and separates the characters, affirms that love is an unwavering force capable of conquering all obstacles.