Exploring Justice and Morality in Mérimée's 'Mateo Falcone'

Categories: Short Story

Introduction

Paris, on September 28, 1803, witnessed the birth of Prosper Mérimée, a versatile French literary figure who left an indelible mark through his prowess in drama, history, archaeology, and short stories. His works, characterized by a Romantic theme yet executed with Classical finesse, ushered in a renewal of Classicism in an era dominated by Romanticism. Notable among his creations is the short story "Mateo Falcone," a narrative steeped in the complexities of family honor, set against the historical backdrop of Corsica in the seventeenth century.

Story

"Mateo Falcone," penned in 1829, stands as the culmination of Mérimée's trio of short serious operas, the predecessors being "Feast in Time of Plague" and "Mademoiselle Fifi." Originally subtitled "Les moeurs de Corse" ("The Ways of Corsica"), the story unfolds with the killing of a ten-year-old boy by his father, delving into intricate themes admired by contemporaries like Stendhal, Henry James, and Walter Pater. Pater, in fact, deemed "Mateo Falcone" as "the cruellest story in the world.

Get quality help now
Bella Hamilton
Bella Hamilton
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

star star star star 5 (234)

“ Very organized ,I enjoyed and Loved every bit of our professional interaction ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

" The narrative intricately weaves together at least five points of view and explores four distinct "ways of life," encapsulated in the original subtitle's "moeurs." Themes of betrayal, honor, savagery, civilization, vendetta, law, custom, and morality converge in this brief yet complex tale.

Setting

Corsica, during the seventeenth century, provides the atmospheric backdrop for "Mateo Falcone," specifically in the region of Porto-Vecchio, nestled between the town of Corte and the mâquis, the wild Corsican highlands harboring outlaws and societal misfits. In this picturesque yet treacherous setting, Mateo Falcone, a prosperous sheep rancher at the age of forty-eight, grapples with the intricate balance of familial duty and moral choices.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Topic
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

Characters

The dramatis personae in "Mateo Falcone" are intricately woven into the narrative fabric. Mateo Falcone, the patriarch, a man of forty-eight with three married daughters and a ten-year-old son, Fortunato, serves as the linchpin. Fortunato, touted as the "hope of the family," becomes embroiled in the unfolding tragedy. Other characters include Guiseppa, Mateo's wife; Tiodoro Gamba, an adjutant and distant relative; and Gianetto Saupiero, an outlaw whose arrival catalyzes the narrative's tensions.

Rising Action

The narrative unfolds as Mateo sets off to gather his flock, leaving Fortunato alone in the autumn sun. The idyllic scene takes a dramatic turn as gunshots echo nearby, capturing Fortunato's attention. Enter Gianetto Saupiero, a wounded man seeking asylum and implying a tie to Falcone, a connection that sparks a moral quandary for Fortunato. The tension escalates with the arrival of soldiers led by Adjutant Tiodoro Gamba, Fortunato's cousin. Fortunato's decision to conceal Gianetto sets the stage for a riveting climax.

Climax

The climax of "Mateo Falcone" is marked by the confrontation between Fortunato and Gamba. The soldiers, led by Gamba, interrogate Fortunato about a man on the trail, suspecting complicity with Gianetto. Despite threats, Fortunato, cognizant of his father's wrath, remains resilient. The unsuccessful search and Gamba's attempt to bribe Fortunato with a shiny new watch intensify the narrative tension.

Falling Action

Mateo and Guiseppa return from the pastures, unaware of the unfolding drama. Gamba cautiously briefs Mateo on the events, leading to a poignant moment of truth. Mateo, upon learning the facts, questions Fortunato's parentage. Fortunato, overcome with emotion, collapses in tears. Mateo's command for Fortunato to accompany him into the high country serves as the falling action, setting the stage for the denouement.

Denouement

As Mateo and Fortunato ascend the mountains, Guiseppa, in a contrasting scene, seeks solace in prayer. In a ravine, Mateo instructs Fortunato to kneel and say his prayers, leading to a tragic resolution. Fortunato, pleading for mercy, faces an unyielding Mateo who, embodying justice, raises his rifle and executes the irrevocable act. The denouement encapsulates the overarching theme that justice prevails, sometimes with a heavy toll.

Theme Analysis

In the aftermath of the tragic denouement, the narrative leaves readers with a profound exploration of themes. The concept that "justice prevails" emerges as a central tenet, albeit at a grievous cost. The idea that the "end justifies the means" echoes through the narrative, resonating with the complex interplay of morality and societal expectations.

Symbolism

"Mateo Falcone" employs symbolism to deepen its narrative layers. Mateo Falcone, the embodiment of justice; Fortunato, representative of sin; and Gamba and Gianetto, personifying temptation, contribute to a rich tapestry of symbolic elements. Guiseppa, in her act of prayer, embodies love and sympathy. These symbolic nuances elevate the narrative, infusing it with deeper meaning and resonances.

Foreshadowing, Flashback, and Conflict

Prosper Mérimée skillfully employs literary devices to enrich the storytelling. Foreshadowing, as seen in Gamba's attempt to bribe Fortunato, adds a layer of anticipation. Flashbacks, detailing Gianetto's actions and Fortunato's role, provide essential context. Various conflicts, from Fortunato's internal struggle to the overarching conflict between land and familial duty, contribute to the narrative's complexity.

In conclusion, "Mateo Falcone" transcends its brevity, offering readers a profound exploration of morality, justice, and the intricate dance between societal expectations and personal choices. Mérimée's masterful storytelling, infused with rich symbolism and nuanced characters, stands as a testament to the enduring power of the short story genre in exploring the depths of the human experience.

Updated: Jan 02, 2024
Cite this page

Exploring Justice and Morality in Mérimée's 'Mateo Falcone'. (2017, May 24). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/mateo-falcone-by-prosper-merimee-short-story-analysis-essay

Exploring Justice and Morality in Mérimée's 'Mateo Falcone' essay
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment