To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Adolescence is a period characterized by significant physical, emotional, and psychological changes. It has been a subject of interest and debate among psychologists and researchers for decades. While some attribute the challenges of adolescence to biological factors, others emphasize the importance of psychosocial development. This essay delves into the diverse perspectives on adolescence, exploring the viewpoints of Hall (1916) and Erikson (1963), and considering the impact of cultural variations on the adolescent experience. It is crucial to recognize that the challenges and experiences of adolescents vary across different societies and regions.
G. Stanley Hall, a prominent psychologist in the early 20th century, introduced the concept of "storm and stress" during adolescence. Hall's theory posits that the tumultuous nature of adolescence is primarily attributed to biological factors, particularly hormonal changes. According to Hall, these hormonal fluctuations lead to mood swings and emotional turmoil, which are inevitable aspects of this developmental stage. In essence, Hall suggests that adolescence is primarily driven by internal biological processes rather than external factors (Hall, 1916).
Erik Erikson, a renowned psychologist in the mid-20th century, presented a contrasting viewpoint on adolescence.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Achievement
4.7 (348)
“ Amazing as always, gave her a week to finish a big assignment and came through way ahead of time. ”
He believed that adolescence is a crucial period for psychosocial development, marked by the quest for identity and a sense of belonging in the adult society. Erikson proposed that adolescents strive to establish a strong sense of identity, which is essential for their future roles as productive adults (Erikson, 1963).
In Western societies, adolescence is often characterized by a state of moratorium, wherein individuals experience a delay in transitioning to adulthood.
While this delay is intended to ease the transition, it can paradoxically lead to challenges and conflicts. The absence of a clearly defined path to adulthood can create a "generation gap," causing confusion and tension between adolescents and their parents.
Erikson's notion of a "generation gap" has been subject to scrutiny and debate over the years. Research conducted by Lerner, Karson, Meisels, and Knapp (1975) questioned the validity of Erikson's claim. For instance, Kandel and Lesser (1972) discovered that parents and their children often share more similar values and attitudes than adolescents and their peers. This finding suggests that the generation gap may not be as pronounced as Erikson proposed. Many psychologists have observed that, for the majority of adolescents, their parents' views are open to discussion and negotiation.
Moreover, studies conducted in various countries have consistently shown that young people maintain positive relationships with their parents and perceive them as significant figures in their lives. This global perspective challenges the notion of a pervasive generation gap. Adolescents from diverse cultural backgrounds often engage in constructive dialogues with their parents, suggesting that the generation gap may be less prevalent than initially thought.
Cultural factors play a significant role in shaping the adolescent experience. Non-Western cultures, such as Samoa, offer a stark contrast to the Western perspective. In Samoa, adolescence is described as "the age of maximum ease," characterized by minimal conflicts with parents. This cultural context fosters a more harmonious transition to adulthood, with less emphasis on rebellion and tension. In societies like Samoa, individuals seamlessly assume adult roles once they reach sexual maturity.
Research conducted by Shostak (1981) in southern Africa revealed a similar pattern. In this region, young people become economically self-sufficient during their early teenage years and can marry and have children as soon as they reach sexual maturity. The Canadian Inuit culture also demonstrates a different approach to adolescence, with young people considered adults upon reaching puberty, allowing them to marry and become parents at a young age.
Examining the multifaceted nature of adolescence across different cultures reveals a diverse array of experiences and challenges. While Western societies often grapple with the complexities of the adolescent transition, non-Western cultures offer alternative perspectives that prioritize a smoother transition to adulthood. Cultural variations in the perception of adolescence underscore the importance of recognizing that the challenges faced by adolescents are not universal.
Ultimately, the experience of adolescence is shaped by a complex interplay of biological, psychological, and cultural factors. Adolescents worldwide navigate this transformative period in their own unique ways. While it is clear that adolescence can be a time of storm and stress, it is equally essential to acknowledge the cultural nuances that influence this journey. By embracing diverse perspectives on adolescence, we can gain a more comprehensive understanding of this critical phase of human development.
The Complex Nature of Adolescence Across Cultures. (2020, Jun 02). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/identity-achievement-status-5203-new-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
