The Impact of Urban Development in Boey Kim Cheng's "The Planners"

Boey Kim Cheng's poem, "The Planners," offers a poignant exploration of the consequences of urban development and modernization on the natural world and human identity. Through evocative imagery and a critical tone, the poet delves into the idea that the relentless pursuit of perfection, as embodied by the planners, erases the rich tapestry of history and the essence of humanity. In this essay, we will dissect the various layers of meaning within the poem, examining the poet's disapproval of the planners' quest for perfection and its implications for society.

The Loss of Imperfections: Erasing History

At the heart of "The Planners" lies a profound critique of how urban planners, in their relentless pursuit of perfection, obliterate the imperfections of the past. Boey Kim Cheng highlights the erasure of historical blemishes as a metaphor for the sanitization of history itself. The poet's accusatory tone is evident as he asserts that these planners, with their craving for perfection, erase the flaws and blemishes of the past with surgical precision:

They erase the flaws, the blemishes of the past, knock off useless blocs with dental dexterity.

Get quality help now

WriterBelle

Verified writer

Proficient in: Attitude

4.7 (657)

“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

The choice of the word 'blemishes' conveys a negative connotation, suggesting that the planners view historical imperfections as something undesirable. Blemishes, typically associated with physical flaws, are often sought to be eradicated in a quest for an idealized appearance. Similarly, the planners seek to eliminate any historical imperfections, treating them as unwanted flaws that mar the image of a perfect society.

The phrase "useless blocs" carries an undertone of arrogance, as it implies that the planners have the authority to determine which aspects of history are of no value.

It raises the question of who grants them the right to decide what should be preserved and what should be discarded. The erasure of history in the pursuit of perfection is portrayed as unnatural, for it is the mistakes and imperfections of the past that have contributed to the shaping of the present and the essence of humanity.

An Extended Metaphor: The Perfect Smile

The second stanza of the poem employs an extended metaphor, comparing the country to a set of teeth. Words such as 'dental dexterity,' 'shining teeth,' 'anaesthesia,' 'piling,' and 'drilling' are strategically chosen to emphasize the planners' obsession with perfection. In this metaphor, the Planners seek to rectify every imperfection, just as one might seek dental treatment to achieve a flawless smile. The use of 'anaesthesia' implies that the process is painless, further emphasizing the idea that the pursuit of perfection should be seamless and without resistance.

Through this metaphor, the Planners attempt to perfect not only the present but also their imperfect past. This endeavor is portrayed as nearly impossible, as altering historical events is akin to reshaping teeth that have already grown in a specific way. The poet underscores the futility of erasing history and attempting to achieve an unattainable standard of perfection.

Wealth as a Facade

Within the poem, the Planners resort to using wealth and prosperity as a facade to cover up imperfections and create an illusion of perfection. The line, "All gaps are plugged with gleaming gold," suggests that any gaps or deficiencies in society are concealed by the outward display of affluence. This wealth serves as a veneer that masks any underlying imperfections.

The use of 'gleaming gold' carries a dual connotation. Gold symbolizes opulence and material wealth, which can be used to distract from societal flaws. However, gold also represents something superficial and artificial, much like the pursuit of a perfect appearance. The poet implies that the Planners prioritize appearances over substance, using the allure of wealth to hide the underlying issues within society.

Perfection at What Cost?

Ultimately, "The Planners" raises questions about the cost of perfection. Boey Kim Cheng suggests that the relentless pursuit of an unattainable ideal comes at the expense of history, identity, and authenticity. The poem serves as a cautionary tale, warning against the erasure of imperfections, which are an integral part of human existence.

While the planners strive for an immaculate and flawless society, the poet's critical tone and accusatory language underscore the inherent dangers of such a pursuit. The poem invites readers to reflect on the value of imperfections, the richness of history, and the essence of humanity, all of which may be sacrificed in the relentless quest for an unattainable standard of perfection.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Boey Kim Cheng's "The Planners" serves as a powerful critique of urban development and modernization, highlighting the detrimental effects of the relentless pursuit of perfection. Through vivid imagery and a critical tone, the poet conveys his disapproval of the planners' mission to erase history's imperfections. The poem warns of the high cost of such a pursuit, emphasizing the value of imperfections, the importance of preserving history, and the essence of humanity itself.

As society continues to grapple with the consequences of rapid urbanization and the pursuit of an unattainable ideal, "The Planners" remains a thought-provoking reflection on the price society pays for its relentless quest for perfection.