Heathcliff in "Wuthering Heights": Navigating Tragedy and Malevolence

Introduction

Delving into the intricacies of Emily Brontë's "Wuthering Heights," the character Heathcliff emerges as a complex figure, oscillating between victimhood and villainy. This essay aims to navigate the labyrinth of Heathcliff's character, questioning whether his status as a victim justifies the immoral actions that, in turn, label him as a true villain. While acknowledging Catherine's inherent selfishness, the narrative scrutinizes Heathcliff's manipulative and vengeful behaviors, painting a portrait of a character embodying both tragedy and malevolence.

Heathcliff as a Victim

The narrative unfolds with a focus on Heathcliff's victimhood, intricately woven into the tapestry of Wuthering Heights.

Nelly, a key character, unwillingly becomes a catalyst for Heathcliff's plight. Her failure to acknowledge Heathcliff's presence during a crucial moment allows him to overhear Catherine's hurtful remarks. Had Nelly intervened, Heathcliff might have been privy to the positive sentiments Catherine later expresses about him.

Heathcliff's victimhood extends beyond mere romantic complications. Catherine's marriage to Edgar, driven by her selfish desire for wealth and social status, denies Heathcliff his true love.

Get quality help now

Doctor Jennifer

Verified writer

Proficient in: Villains

5 (893)

“ Thank you so much for accepting my assignment the night before it was due. I look forward to working with you moving forward ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

This act of selfishness casts Heathcliff as a victim of circumstances—abandoned by his parents and subjected to prejudice due to his darker skin. The Lintons, in particular, exemplify this prejudice, judging Heathcliff solely based on appearances.

Catherine as a Victimizer

As the narrative unfolds, Catherine's role as a victimizer comes to the fore. Her decisions inflict profound emotional wounds on Heathcliff. Despite recognizing Heathcliff as her soul mate, Catherine marries Edgar, choosing financial stability over true love. This act of selfishness becomes a recurring theme, a source of turmoil throughout the novel.

Catherine's betrayal reaches its zenith when Edgar visits Wuthering Heights. Instructing Heathcliff to leave her alone with Edgar, she betrays their profound connection. The strength of Heathcliff and Catherine's relationship crumbles in the face of her selfish choices. Catherine's expectations of unquestioning obedience further reveal her self-centered nature, leading to instances of physical aggression, such as pinching Nelly in fits of passion.

Heathcliff as a Villain

Transitioning from victimhood to villainy, Heathcliff's actions take a darker turn. Purposefully influencing Hareton, a young child, to hate his father, Heathcliff perpetuates a cycle of animosity. His negative influence causes Hareton to curse and brand his father, Hindley, as the devil. Heathcliff's marriage to Isabella becomes another testament to his villainous nature, marked by mistreatment and cruelty.

Heathcliff's brutal acts, such as hanging Isabella's dog, exemplify the depths of his hatred and the lengths to which he would go for revenge. This deliberate cruelty extends to his actions against innocent people associated with the Lintons. Taking custody of Linton, who lives in perpetual fear of his father, Heathcliff exploits the young boy's weakness, sickness, and vulnerability to secure his fortune at Thrushcross Grange.

Heathcliff's manipulation reaches its zenith when he coerces young Cathy into marrying Linton. Holding her love for her dying father hostage, Heathcliff exhibits a level of selfishness that knows no bounds. This calculated cruelty underscores the extent to which he is willing to go to achieve his goals, even at the expense of innocent lives.

While Heathcliff's experiences as a victim may have contributed to his strength and determination, the narrative staunchly rejects any justification for his expression of anger on innocent people. As sympathy wanes for his early misfortunes, the latter part of the novel reveals the true extent of Heathcliff's malevolence.

Conclusion

Concluding our exploration of Heathcliff's character in "Wuthering Heights," the nuanced interplay between victimhood and villainy emerges as a central theme. Heathcliff's trajectory, shaped by his tumultuous experiences, illustrates the thin line between tragedy and malevolence.

This exploration prompts a reconsideration of the initial sympathy felt for Heathcliff's early misfortunes. The character's evolution forces readers to grapple with the moral complexities inherent in his actions. In the end, Heathcliff stands not only as a victim of circumstance but as a harbinger of darkness, leaving an indelible mark on the landscape of classic literature.