Amanda's Parenting in 'The Glass Menagerie': A Critical Analysis

It is not uncommon for one to perceive Amanda, the mother in Tennessee Williams' timeless play 'The Glass Menagerie,' as a flawed parent, prioritizing her own needs over those of her children, Laura and Tom. This essay will delve into the instances within the play where Amanda's actions may be seen as indicative of a lack of effective parenting, exploring the themes of selfishness, domineering behavior, and the consequences of unrealistic expectations.

As we scrutinize Amanda's character, a pattern emerges where she appears to exhibit a lack of maternal responsibility.

While traditionally the mother is expected to be the nurturing figure, Amanda seems to deflect her duties onto her son, Tom. This dynamic unfolds prominently when Tom is compelled to secure employment at the warehouse, effectively assuming the primary parenting role for Laura. Amanda's statement that Tom will only be 'free' once Laura is married and independent underscores the extent to which her priorities may be perceived as self-centered.

The Burden on Tom: Unfair Distribution of Responsibilities

As the matriarch, Amanda carries the responsibility of ensuring the well-being and provision of her children.

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

However, a striking pattern emerges where Tom, her son, is burdened with both Amanda and Laura's problems. An illustrative example is Tom being compelled to secure employment at the warehouse, effectively assuming the primary parenting role for Laura. Amanda's statement that Tom will only be 'free' once Laura is married and independent underscores the extent to which her priorities may be perceived as self-centered.

This unequal distribution of responsibilities raises questions about Amanda's suitability as a mother.

It prompts one to reflect on whether Amanda's actions align with societal expectations of maternal roles or if she deviates from conventional norms, possibly contributing to an unconventional family dynamic.

Amanda's Selfish and Domineering Traits

Amanda exhibits key characteristics of selfish and domineering behavior, particularly directed at Tom. A notable instance is her expectation for Tom to abandon his dreams of becoming a writer and sailing away, solely to ensure his constant presence for her and his sister. The irony lies in Amanda labeling Tom a 'selfish dreamer' when he expresses the desire to leave. Furthermore, Amanda's insistence on Tom finding a suitor for Laura from the factory reflects a lack of consideration for Tom's feelings, as she demands rather than discusses the matter.

This demand for Tom to shape Laura's romantic future not only showcases Amanda's domineering nature but also raises questions about her expectations. Does Amanda's interference stem from genuine concern for Laura's happiness, or does it reveal a desire to control and mold her daughter's life according to Amanda's preconceived notions?

A revealing facet of Amanda's parenting style is her constant emphasis on Laura's potential suitors. She delves into her own past, seemingly reliving her younger years through Laura. However, her disappointment at Laura's lack of gentlemen callers takes an unexpected turn. Instead of consoling her daughter, Amanda expresses concern over the future, fearing the absence of support for herself and Laura. This self-centered perspective contributes to the perception of Amanda as a potentially inadequate parent.

The Duality of Amanda's Character: Caring Yet Self-Centered

Amidst Amanda's seemingly selfish actions, glimpses of genuine care for Laura emerge. Amanda's efforts to pay for Laura's Business course and contribute financially to the family reveal a caring side. Despite her eccentric methods, Amanda's intentions appear pure. Her belief in the need to work harder due to Laura's disability reflects an understanding of societal prejudices. However, the paradox lies in Amanda's fear of being left alone or unprovided for, which often overshadows her genuine care for her children.

While Amanda's caring nature is evident, critics may argue that her fear-driven decisions make her susceptible to being perceived as a less-than-ideal parent. Her attempt to manage her children's lives, especially Tom's, disregards their individual aspirations and stifles their personal growth. Instead of allowing Tom to pursue his dreams, Amanda inadvertently places her own fears above his potential for fulfillment.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Amanda's Parenting

In conclusion, Amanda's parenting in 'The Glass Menagerie' is a complex interplay of caring and self-centeredness. While her genuine concern for her children is evident, her actions, influenced by fear and a desire for security, may lead to perceptions of inadequacy as a parent. Amanda's character serves as a poignant exploration of the delicate balance parents face between protecting their children and allowing them the autonomy to shape their own destinies. In a broader sense, 'The Glass Menagerie' prompts reflection on the multifaceted nature of parenthood and the challenges inherent in striking a harmonious balance between personal needs and familial responsibilities.