To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
In "The Garden-Party", Mansfield challenges general assumptions of social classes by showing that there could be redeeming features among the working class as well as less-than-desirable traits in the upper class. To what extent do you agree? To be able to understand Mansfield's work, we have to understand the time in which her work was published. "The Garden-Party" was published at a time when modern-prose was developing and becoming popular. Modern prose was generally aimed at challenging and rebelling against the very shallow and narrow-minded society which existed by speaking of things that were considered taboo.
There was a great difference between the upper and lower classes at this time. I do agree that this story challenges general assumptions of social classes which existed the time
This story is aimed at scrutinizing and exposing the upper classes through comparing them with the lower classes whose qualities are revealed. From the start, we can already come to see that the Sheridan family sought to impress their guests intentionally with roses which would be noticeable and admired.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Garden
4.7 (657)
“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”
The very word 'impress' creates an impression on the reader that they have a great need to do so. It seems that almost without their ability to impress, they are nobodies. Mansfield is only able to bring out the flaws of the upper class, by showing us the distance and difference between the upper and lower class.
Mansfield emphasizes Laura's discomfort with holding bread and butter in front of these poor people as she was 'fearful' and 'ashamed'.
We are reminded of this fact once again when Laura points to the lawn using her empty hand. Another example of the segregation between classes is when Laura considers whether it was respectful for a workman to talk about bang slap in the eye. It is obvious that she is not able adapt to other peoples' ways making her upbringing seem very 'stuck-up'. Mansfield makes it clear that the upper class need big publicity stunts to enjoy the simple things in life.
For example, Mrs Sheridan needs to have the garden-party in order to buy the canny lilies. She is unable to enjoy life without flaunting as much possible. This is a stark contrast in comparison to the workman who can enjoy the smell of lavender. Another aspect in which the upper class, are stereotyped in this story, is the way in which the children start imitating their mother. Jose enjoys giving orders to her maids without using words like 'please' or thank you. The children are brainwashed and are used to a life of pampering.
Unlike the Sheridan children, the cook and other domestic workers are extremely polite to the family. We also learn about the indifference the upper classes have towards the lower classes when Mrs Sheridan exclaims worriedly at the thought of someone dead in her garden but instantly calms down when she realizes Mr Scott has died as though he is of no importance. Despite her own daughter's constant reminder, Mrs Sheridan refuses to cancel the party only stating, "People like that don't expect sacrifices from us.
It is almost as though the Scott's are not human. I believe Laura is the key character in the story, as she is the only member of the family who has a heart or some sense of conscience. It is through her observation and reactions to events that we can also see the difference between the upper and lower classes. She seems to be the only character with a heart. This is particularly evident when upon learning of the dead Mr Scott, Laura is the only one who realizes that it is only respectful to cancel the garden party.
Jose on the other hand, has no feelings or thoughts of condolence for the family but instead refers to Laura as being 'extravagant'. Jose's lack of respect for the poor is evident and it can be said that Jose in this instance is a representative of the upper class. When Laura forgets her heart with the hat that her mother bribes her with, it is a perfect example of how wealth has robbed the upper classes of their heart. It is ironic how the thought of the mourning family was unreal, 'like a picture' to Laura.
That was in fact reality and her garden party was causing her to evade reality. This is when it can be said that the upper class, live in their own world without understanding reality. To conclude, I believe that Mansfiled has successfully managed to provide the reader with redeeming traits of the lower classes while portraying the less desirable traits in the upper classes. Scrutinizing the upper class by their behaviour, portraying the influence wealth has over them, showing us the distance by using Laura are the ways in which Mansfield has achieved this.
Challenging Social Class Assumptions in Mansfield's The Garden-Party. (2020, Jun 02). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/garden-party-mansfield-challenges-general-assumptions-social-classes-new-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
