The Role of Women: A Contrast between Juliet and Modern Society

William Shakespeare's timeless play, Romeo and Juliet, transports us to the 16th century, a period characterized by stringent gender roles. In this essay, we delve into the portrayal of women in the play, focusing on Juliet, and draw parallels to the contemporary role of women. The societal expectations and constraints on Juliet provide a captivating lens through which to explore the evolving nature of women's roles from the Elizabethan era to the present day.

During the 16th century, women were relegated to specific societal roles, primarily defined by their relationships as wives and mothers.

Juliet, a young girl navigating the expectations of her time, exemplifies this paradigm. In the Elizabethan era, affluent families often employed nurses to care for their children, and Juliet's connection with her Nurse was more profound than with her biological mother, Lady Capulet. This arrangement, though customary, underscored the limited autonomy women had in shaping their own lives.

Juliet's upbringing, overseen by her parents and the Nurse, reflects the prevalent belief that decisions regarding a girl's life were the sole prerogative of her parents.

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Wife

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

In contrast to contemporary times, where individual agency is emphasized, the 16th-century girl rarely had the authority to make her own choices. The parental influence extended to matters of marriage, as parents played a decisive role in selecting suitable suitors for their daughters.

Shakespeare skillfully places Juliet in the context of an arranged marriage, a common practice of the time. Lady Capulet, Juliet's mother, exemplifies the parental authority, expressing her expectation for Juliet to embrace the prospect of marriage to Paris.

Despite Juliet's initial reluctance, a deviation from the expected submissive response, she ultimately complies with her mother's decision, a stark departure from contemporary notions of free choice in marriage.

In the Elizabethan era, men wielded disproportionate power and influence over women. Women, considered possessions rather than individuals, were subjected to the authority of both fathers and husbands. Juliet's expected marriage to Paris typifies this dynamic, emphasizing the prevailing societal norms that confined women to predetermined roles. The concept of women as obedient wives, adhering to their husband's decisions, was ingrained in the social fabric of the time.

However, Juliet emerges as a nonconformist within this societal framework. Unlike the typical 16th-century girl, she challenges the prescribed roles and expectations. Her resistance to the arranged marriage and her desire for a love-based union showcase her defiance against the established norms. This departure from convention serves Shakespeare's dramatic purpose, creating a character that captivates the audience's attention and challenges the societal norms of the time.

Lady Capulet, representing the archetype of an upper-class mother in the 16th century, further emphasizes the constrained lives of women. Her early marriage and the delegation of maternal responsibilities to the Nurse underscore the societal expectations imposed on women, limiting their choices and personal fulfillment. The reliance on a nurse to nurture Juliet reflects the prevalent practice of the time, where mothers often distanced themselves from the physical aspects of childcare.

Shakespeare's deliberate choice to depict Juliet as atypical for her time serves as a commentary on the rigidity of 16th-century societal norms. By deviating from the expected behaviors and attitudes, Juliet becomes a vehicle for the audience to question and reflect upon the prevailing gender roles. The playwright strategically shapes the female characters to engage the audience, making the play not just a reflection of the past but a compelling exploration of human nature and societal expectations.

Expanding our exploration, it is crucial to examine Juliet's relationships beyond the familial sphere. In the play, Juliet defies not only her parents' expectations but also challenges the societal norms of the time by seeking a relationship based on love rather than adherence to familial and societal expectations. This defiance is evident in her clandestine love affair with Romeo, a member of the rival Montague family.

Romeo and Juliet's love story unfolds against the backdrop of a longstanding feud between their families, adding an additional layer of complexity to Juliet's defiance. The forbidden nature of their love not only defies the expectations of arranged marriages but also challenges the deeply ingrained animosity between the Capulets and the Montagues. Juliet's choice to pursue a relationship with Romeo is a bold departure from the established norms, highlighting her agency and autonomy in matters of the heart.

The balcony scene, where Romeo and Juliet profess their love for each other, is a pivotal moment that showcases Juliet's courage in expressing her desires. In this scene, Juliet transcends the societal constraints imposed on her gender, taking an active role in shaping her romantic destiny. Her willingness to challenge tradition and pursue a love that defies familial expectations demonstrates the evolving nature of women's roles, even within the confines of 16th-century society.

Moreover, Juliet's transformation throughout the play challenges the perception of women as passive entities. As the narrative unfolds, Juliet evolves from a dutiful daughter to a woman determined to carve her own path. Her decision to take a potion that simulates death, a desperate attempt to reunite with Romeo, showcases her agency and willingness to defy societal norms, even at the cost of her own life.

Shakespeare's portrayal of Juliet's defiance extends beyond the realm of romantic relationships. In the context of her interactions with the Nurse, Juliet challenges the traditional hierarchy between upper-class women and their caretakers. The intimate bond between Juliet and the Nurse goes beyond the formalities of class distinctions, portraying a genuine connection that defies societal expectations.

The Nurse, who had lost her own child, becomes a maternal figure to Juliet, bridging the gap between social classes. This unconventional relationship challenges the rigid social structure of the time, where interactions between classes were typically governed by strict protocols. Juliet's ability to form meaningful connections across class boundaries further reinforces her role as a catalyst for change within the confines of the play.

In the context of the play's overarching themes, Juliet's defiance becomes emblematic of a broader societal shift. While the 16th century was characterized by patriarchal dominance and rigid gender roles, Juliet emerges as a symbol of resilience and autonomy. Her actions not only serve the dramatic purpose of the play but also provide a subtle commentary on the potential for societal transformation.

As we reflect on Juliet's character and the broader societal implications, it becomes evident that Shakespeare's nuanced portrayal of women in Romeo and Juliet transcends the temporal confines of the Elizabethan era. Juliet, with her defiance and agency, becomes a timeless emblem of women's capacity to challenge societal norms and shape their own destinies.