To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
In delving into the diverse perspectives presented in two passages on the Boston Tea Party, we embark on a journey to understand how these viewpoints intricately shape our comprehension of historical events. The initial passage, "Excerpt from Mr. Revere and I," employs a first-person narrative, offering a distinctive lens that centers on personal inconveniences and labor. In contrast, the subsequent passage, "Excerpt from The Many Rides of Paul Revere: The Boston Tea Party," takes on a third-person perspective, emphasizing the expansive scope of the colonists' determination and patriotism.
These contrasting viewpoints contribute to a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the Boston Tea Party.
The first passage immerses us in the vivid, first-person perspective of Paul Revere's horse, providing a fictionalized account of the Boston Tea Party. This enslaved horse, devoid of an understanding of the significance of the Revolutionary War, narrates its experiences amidst constant threats from the British.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Boston Tea Party
4.9 (984)
“ Ok, let me say I’m extremely satisfy with the result while it was a last minute thing. I really enjoy the effort put in. ”
The horse's primary concern lies in the disruption of its daily life and the intensifying, somewhat "miserable" labor demanded by the war. It feels a profound sympathy towards Paul Revere, its master, whose loyalty to the colonies subjects both of them to heightened busyness and interrupted routines.
For the horse, the Revolutionary War translates into an uncomfortable adjustment to a new daily routine. Expressing irritation, the horse recounts the challenges, such as a "miserable cold wet ride to Marblehead and Salem," highlighting the physical discomfort it endures. Its perspective offers little concern for the broader implications of the war, revealing a narrative centered on personal inconveniences and sympathy towards Paul Revere's increased workload.
The horse becomes a witness to a disrupted normalcy, emphasizing the perceived meaninglessness of the Boston Tea Party in the context of its own experiences.
The horse's narrative extends to moments where its routines are disrupted due to Paul Revere's constant calls to duty. Paragraph 22 vividly describes a "miserable cold wet ride to Marblehead and Salem," portraying the challenging conditions faced during these journeys. The horse, despite being an essential part of Revere's expeditions, displays a lack of understanding of the larger context, emphasizing its enslaved status. Its complaints and sympathy towards Revere create a unique lens through which readers witness the Boston Tea Party, framed by the lens of personal inconvenience and labor.
The second passage adopts a thoughtfully distant, 3rd person perspective, steering clear of the personal experiences of an enslaved horse. Unlike the horse's narrative, this passage sees the Revolutionary War from a broader standpoint, appreciating the colonists' relentless determination and their refusal to tolerate British tyranny. The author, through this perspective, admires Paul Revere's hard work, loyalty, and significant contributions to the Sons of Liberty.
While listing the events of the Boston Tea Party in consequential order, the author expresses gratitude towards Paul Revere for consistently traveling long distances and carrying out duties, even under challenging conditions. Phrases like "Paul must have been an excellent rider," suggest admiration for Revere's contributions beyond personal inconveniences. The 3rd person perspective aims to evoke appreciation for the colonists' patriotism, loyalty, and determination, portraying their collective effort against British oppression.
The author of the second passage extends the narrative to emphasize the colonists' collective effort during the Boston Tea Party. By highlighting Paul Revere's role as an excellent rider and praising his contributions, the author encourages readers to admire the colonists' patriotism and bravery. The emphasis on the Sons of Liberty standing guard and carrying urgent messages reinforces the urgency and seriousness with which the colonists approached the Boston Tea Party. This perspective, free from personal biases, paints a vivid picture of the colonists' bravery and determination in the face of British oppression.
Each passage significantly influences the reader's perception of the Boston Tea Party. The 1st person perspective of "Excerpt from Mr. Revere and I" offers insights into the upheaval of normal life, where the Sons of Liberty, including Paul Revere, are portrayed as busier due to constant calls to action. The horse's narrative suggests a sense of meaninglessness to the Boston Tea Party, emphasizing the physical discomfort and disruption it brings to daily life. The focus on personal inconvenience shapes a narrative that perceives the event as an imposition on individual routines.
On the other hand, the 3rd person perspective in "Excerpt from The Many Rides of Paul Revere: The Boston Tea Party" provides a broader understanding of the colonists' motivations and collective effort. By highlighting Paul Revere's role as an excellent rider and praising his contributions, the author encourages readers to admire the colonists' patriotism and bravery. The emphasis on the Sons of Liberty standing guard and carrying urgent messages reinforces the urgency and seriousness with which the colonists approached the Boston Tea Party.
This perspective, free from personal biases, paints a vivid picture of the colonists' bravery and determination in the face of British oppression. It invites readers to appreciate the complexity of the Boston Tea Party beyond individual experiences, presenting a more nuanced and comprehensive view of the historical events that unfolded during that period.
In conclusion, the exploration of two distinct perspectives on the Boston Tea Party provides a richer understanding of this pivotal historical event. The 1st person narrative of Paul Revere's horse sheds light on the personal inconveniences and disruptions to daily life, emphasizing the perceived meaninglessness of the event. In contrast, the 3rd person perspective admirably portrays the colonists' determination, patriotism, and collective effort against British tyranny, elevating the significance of the Boston Tea Party. Together, these perspectives contribute to a multifaceted comprehension of a crucial moment in American history.
Horse's Lament and Patriot's Valor: Views on the Boston Tea Party. (2023, Apr 05). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/different-writing-perspectives-can-affect-understanding-of-boston-tea-party-events-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
