To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Human potential knows no bounds, and the indomitable spirit to overcome adversity is a testament to the extraordinary capabilities residing within every individual. This sentiment is vividly portrayed in the film "Simon Birch" and the short story "The Scarlet Ibis," where two young boys, Simon and Doodle, confront and defy the limitations imposed by their disabilities. Despite facing challenges that could have confined them to a life of limitations, both characters exemplify that true strength is not bound by physical health and that embracing tolerance should be a universal practice.
Doodle and Simon Birch share a commonality in being born with handicaps that might have hindered their lives significantly.
Doodle, with his developmental delay, and Simon, with his small stature, find themselves reliant on the support and assistance of those around them. Fortunately, the kindness of Joe Wentworth towards Simon and the unwavering attention of Doodle's brother create an environment where these young boys can lead lives far beyond societal expectations.
From learning to swim and walk to engaging in activities like boxing and baseball, both Doodle and Simon embark on journeys of self-discovery with the assistance of their dedicated support systems.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Comparison
5 (204)
“ She followed all my directions. It was really easy to contact her and respond very fast as well. ”
Doodle's brother, fueled by a sense of shame and embarrassment, becomes the driving force behind Doodle's determination to overcome his physical limitations. In contrast, Simon Birch's friend, Joe, treats him without seeing his handicap, bringing him into various aspects of life that others deemed impossible for him. The world, once perceived as limiting, transforms into a canvas where they learn to defy the constraints of their bodies.
The journey of defying expectations takes these two young heroes on a path of shared struggles and triumphs.
Doctors, skeptics of their potential, doubted Simon's capabilities, yet he defied all odds, becoming a handicapped hero by saving a bus full of children. Similarly, Doodle's early prognosis suggested he would never walk, but through persistent efforts, pain, and an unyielding spirit, he accomplished the unimaginable by walking on his own by the age of six.
Despite the remarkable similarities in their narratives, the treatment they received from those around them differed significantly. Doodle's brother, motivated by a sense of pride, teaches him to walk, providing unwavering support and care. On the contrary, Simon Birch encounters a world that struggles to comprehend his differences, leading to isolation, mockery, and even dismissive comments from a priest. The stark contrast in their social environments shapes their perceptions of self and their places in the world.
Notwithstanding their shared strengths and accomplishments, the paths of Simon Birch and Doodle ultimately diverge in their fates. Simon Birch, despite the societal challenges he faces, meets a heroic end, saving others. In contrast, Doodle's story takes a tragic turn as his brother, burdened by pride, leaves him behind in a moment of vulnerability, leading to Doodle's untimely demise.
Simon's triumph is a testament to the impact of unconditional acceptance, as Joe's unwavering friendship allows him to rise above societal prejudices. Doodle's fate, on the other hand, is sealed by the weight of pride and societal expectations, revealing the darker consequences of intolerance and embarrassment. The premature deaths of these two boys serve as poignant reminders of the importance of embracing diversity and fostering an environment of acceptance.
Simon Birch and Doodle, despite their differences, share an inner strength that transcends physical limitations, nurtured by their support systems. Their sacrifices paint a vivid picture of how societal attitudes can shape destinies, with one rising to a hero's challenge while the other succumbs to the misery of being pushed beyond his limits. In these unlikely narratives, the profound lessons of tolerance and the destructive nature of pride emerge.
These stories remind us that heroes come in all forms, and true heroism lies in looking beyond surface-level differences. The call to abandon pride echoes loudly, urging us to create a world where acceptance and understanding flourish. As we reflect on the lives of Simon Birch and Doodle, we are compelled to acknowledge that anyone can be a hero, and the true essence of heroism lies in our capacity to transcend preconceived notions and embrace the beauty found in diversity.
In conclusion, the tales of Simon Birch and Doodle serve as poignant narratives that underscore the importance of embracing differences and fostering a culture of acceptance. These young heroes, bound by physical limitations, defy societal expectations and leave an indelible mark on those around them. Their stories challenge us to reassess our attitudes, urging us to create a world where pride takes a backseat to understanding, and tolerance becomes a universal practice.
Strength and Acceptance: A Tale of Two Unlikely Heroes. (2016, Sep 10). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/death-be-not-proud-simon-birch-to-the-scarlet-ibis-comparison-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
