Reverend Parris vs. Reverend Hale: Contrasts in 'The Crucible'

Introduction

Over three centuries ago, the witch trials unfolded in Massachusetts, inspiring Arthur Miller's iconic play "The Crucible" written 56 years ago. Within this narrative, two central characters, Reverend Parris and Reverend Hale, emerge as pivotal figures.

Initial Impressions: Reverend Parris

At the outset of Act 1, Reverend Parris is depicted at his daughter Betty's bedside, ostensibly praying for her recovery. However, a closer examination suggests Parris's primary concern is self-preservation. The play unfolds with Parris prioritizing his reputation, reflecting parallels with McCarthyism—an era marked by America's fight for self-preservation.

The sorrowful tone surrounding Parris in the opening scenes aims to evoke sympathy, but as the narrative progresses, a stark transformation reveals Parris's true nature.

Evolution of Parris's Character

Moving beyond the initial facade of sorrow, Miller unveils the selfish tendencies of Reverend Parris. As the play unfolds, Parris's motivations become increasingly transparent, exposing his disregard for his ailing daughter in favor of personal gain. This shift serves as a compelling reason for developing a disdainful view of Parris.

Get quality help now

Writer Lyla

Verified writer

Proficient in: Philosophy

5 (876)

“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

One notable instance highlighting Parris's self-centeredness is his preoccupation with personal matters, even neglecting his daughter's critical condition. This is evident in the small argument over his salary: "I regard that six pounds as part of my salary." This demonstration of prioritizing personal gain over familial responsibility contributes to the growing resentment towards Parris.

Furthermore, Parris's deceptive nature comes to the forefront as he lies about the absence of witchcraft to protect his interests: "A wide opinion's running in the Parish that the devil may be among us, and I would satisfy you that you are wrong.

" Despite his knowledge of the truth, Parris manipulates the narrative for his benefit, deepening the audience's contempt for his character.

Initial Impressions: Reverend Hale

Contrastingly, Reverend Hale is introduced as a skilled, authoritative figure with the potential to address the town's issues. Miller strategically employs descriptors such as "intellectual," "respectable," and "eager" to establish Hale's high standing. The playwright sets the stage for an initial admiration of Hale's character, projecting him as a force capable of resolving the community's problems.

Hale's entrance into Salem is marked by Parris's attempt to ingratiate himself, underscoring the power dynamics between them. Hale's measured responses and attempts to assert influence reveal a nuanced relationship, with Parris seeking Hale's favor while Hale maintains a position of power.

Hale's Approach to Witchcraft

Notably, Reverend Hale's approach to Betty's condition differs from the prevailing superstitions. He resists jumping to conclusions about witchcraft and instead attempts a rational analysis. This measured response showcases Hale's intellectual prowess and refusal to succumb to prevailing fears and superstitions.

While Hale does not immediately succumb to the town's paranoia, he eventually realizes the presence of witchcraft. His journey from skepticism to acknowledgment demonstrates a character with depth and a commitment to truth. This nuanced approach to the unfolding events elevates Hale in the eyes of the audience.

Parris's Selfishness and Deception

Reverend Parris's neglect of Betty during discussions unrelated to her condition, such as salary disputes, highlights his self-centered nature. Parris consistently prioritizes personal interests over the well-being of his daughter, contributing to a growing disdain for his character. Parris's lies, aimed at protecting himself, further underscore his selfish motives.

These instances of Parris's deception and neglect, coupled with his reluctance to acknowledge the truth about witchcraft, create a stark contrast with Hale's evolving character. Parris's actions fuel a sense of frustration and aversion among the audience, solidifying their negative perception of him.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the evolving perceptions of Reverend Parris and Reverend Hale throughout "The Crucible" can be clearly traced throughout the story. Admiration for Hale and disdain for Parris are rooted in their distinct actions, motivations, and responses to the Salem witch trials. Arthur Miller crafts complex characters that invite reflection on human nature and morality within the crucible of societal turmoil.

Overall, the exploration of these characters adds depth to the narrative, prompting a nuanced understanding of the dynamics at play in the face of societal hysteria and personal motivations.