Comparative Analysis of Poems by Tony Harrison, Elizabeth Jennings, and Philip Larkin

Throughout the world of poetry, various poets explore the complexities of human relationships and emotions. In this comparative analysis, we will delve into the works of three renowned poets: Tony Harrison, Elizabeth Jennings, and Philip Larkin. Each poet provides a unique perspective on themes such as grief, family dynamics, guilt, and the passage of time.

"Long Distance" by Tony Harrison

Tony Harrison's "Long Distance" is a deeply personal poem that delves into the themes of grieving and love within the context of family.

The poem reflects on the author's father's love and grief for his departed mother, painting a poignant picture of a close-knit family.

The poem employs the literary technique of enjambment to create a sense of movement and the passage of time. Harrison's father, depicted in the poem, is caught in a cycle of grief and the daily routine of "putting up appearances." The poem's structure reflects the enduring nature of love and loss, with an "ABAB" rhyming scheme in the initial three paragraphs and an "ABBA" structure in the concluding verse, highlighting a significant change in the narrative.

Get quality help now

Dr. Karlyna PhD

Verified writer

Proficient in: Grief

4.7 (235)

“ Amazing writer! I am really satisfied with her work. An excellent price as well. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Harrison's use of blunt and stark language eschews metaphor and simile, conveying raw and unfiltered emotions. The poem resonates with readers by addressing the regrets and cracks in the author's relationship with his parents, ultimately emphasizing the enduring love that prevails despite the imperfections.

"Long Distance" by Tony Harrison is a poignant exploration of how grief and love can coexist within a family. The poem delves into the complexities of family dynamics and the lasting impact of loss.

Harrison's masterful use of literary techniques, such as enjambment and shifting rhyme schemes, adds depth to the narrative, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the poet's emotional journey.

One of the notable aspects of the poem is Harrison's portrayal of his father's grief. The poem opens with a description of the father's actions after his wife's death. He would "put you off an hour to give him time / To clear her things and look alone." This ritualistic behavior highlights the father's struggle to cope with his wife's absence. The act of clearing her belongings becomes a way to maintain a connection with her memory. It is an attempt to bridge the gap between the living and the deceased.

The theme of maintaining connections transcends physical boundaries in the poem. Harrison's father, despite his wife's passing, continues to engage in a peculiar habit of maintaining her presence in their lives. He "kept her slippers warming by the gas" and "put hot water bottles her side of the bed." These actions demonstrate a longing for the deceased and a refusal to accept her permanent absence. They are also a testament to the endurance of love beyond death.

Furthermore, the poem explores the role of memory and imagination in coping with loss. Harrison's father does not simply maintain physical reminders of his wife; he also communicates with her through imagined letters. He writes to her as if she were still alive, addressing her as "My dear." This practice allows him to preserve the emotional connection they once shared. It is a poignant reflection of how memories and imagination can serve as a source of solace when faced with the harsh reality of death.

While the poem primarily focuses on the father's grief, it also indirectly highlights the poet's own sense of loss and longing. The final stanza reveals that Harrison, too, is grieving the absence of his parents. He mentions how he "put my finger to the glass, and stroked." This act symbolizes an attempt to bridge the gap between the living and the deceased, similar to his father's rituals. It signifies the poet's yearning for a connection that transcends the boundaries of life and death.

In conclusion, "Long Distance" by Tony Harrison is a profoundly moving poem that explores the themes of grief, love, and the enduring bonds within a family. Through vivid imagery and poignant descriptions, Harrison delves into the complex emotions surrounding the loss of loved ones. The poem serves as a testament to the enduring power of love and memory, highlighting how individuals strive to maintain connections even in the face of death.

"My Grandmother" by Elizabeth Jennings

Elizabeth Jennings' "My Grandmother" offers a contrasting perspective on family relationships. The title initially suggests a close and loving bond between the granddaughter and her grandmother, but the poem unveils a distant and somewhat strained connection.

Jennings reflects on her grandmother's advanced age and her inability to manage the family shop. The poet realizes that her grandmother's attachment to antiques cannot replace genuine love. The poem evokes a sense of regret as the granddaughter acknowledges her own fear of getting too close to her grandmother, fearing she might become a possession in her grandmother's collection.

Amidst the antiques and relics, the absence of her grandmother's presence is palpable. The poet recognizes the hurt her grandmother may have felt when she declined her invitations, deepening the sense of guilt. The poem encapsulates the poignant realization that love, once neglected, cannot be reclaimed.

"My Grandmother" by Elizabeth Jennings is a reflection on the complex emotions surrounding family relationships and regret. The poem delves into the theme of missed opportunities and the impact of distance on familial bonds. Jennings' use of vivid imagery and introspective language allows readers to empathize with the poet's sense of guilt and longing.

The poem begins with the title, "My Grandmother," which immediately suggests a personal and intimate connection. However, as the poem unfolds, it becomes evident that the relationship between the granddaughter and her grandmother is distant and strained. The grandmother's age and the decline of her ability to manage the family shop create a sense of separation.

The poet's acknowledgment of her own fear is a central theme of the poem. She admits, "And I remember how I once refused / To go out with her since I was afraid." This fear of getting too close to her grandmother reflects a sense of apprehension about becoming emotionally entangled. The poet's refusal to spend time with her grandmother highlights the missed opportunities for connection.

The poem further explores the grandmother's attachment to antiques and relics. The lines, "She kept an antique shop - or so I thought - / Selling trinkets, curios," emphasize the grandmother's preoccupation with material possessions. It becomes apparent that the grandmother's attachment to these objects serves as a substitute for genuine affection.

As the poem progresses, the absence of the grandmother's presence becomes increasingly pronounced. The poet's visit to her grandmother's room reveals a space filled with untouched antiques and relics. The absence of fingerprints on the furniture symbolizes the lack of human contact and emotional connection. The poet realizes the extent of her own detachment and the impact of her decisions on her grandmother's loneliness.

The final stanza of the poem encapsulates the overarching theme of regret. The poet acknowledges that she can never go back in time and change her decisions. She cannot retrieve the missed opportunities for connection with her grandmother. The poem concludes with a poignant reflection on the grandmother's solitude, emphasizing the idea that love, once neglected, cannot be regained.

"Afternoons" by Philip Larkin

Philip Larkin's "Afternoons" explores the theme of marriage and the passage of time, offering a perspective on young mothers watching their children play in a playground. Larkin contends that marrying and having children at a young age result in mothers losing their identity and independence.

The poem's structure is straightforward, comprising three stanzas, each with eight unrhymed lines. Larkin's use of language emphasizes the recurring theme of emptiness within the young mothers and the regimentation of their lives after marriage.

The poem portrays the gradual fading of summer, symbolizing the prime of life slipping away. Larkin employs vivid imagery, describing the working-class women with "an estateful of washing" and "Our Wedding" album lying near the television, emphasizing the overshadowing of memories by the daily routine. The poem concludes with an image of responsibility taking over their lives.

"Afternoons" by Philip Larkin is a thought-provoking commentary on the impact of marriage and motherhood on individual identity. The poem explores the theme of societal expectations and the loss of self within the context of family life. Larkin's use of language and imagery conveys a sense of resignation and inevitability.

The poem begins with the line, "Summer is fading," setting the tone for a reflection on the passage of time. The gradual fading of summer serves as a metaphor for the fading of youth and vitality. Larkin's choice of words, "Summer is fading" rather than "summer has faded," suggests an ongoing process, emphasizing the inevitability of change.

The poem delves into the lives of young mothers who are tasked with watching their children play in a playground. Larkin describes them as "young mothers tethered," highlighting their sense of confinement and responsibility. The image of the playground, filled with the "breakage" of children's voices, symbolizes the demands of motherhood and the loss of personal freedom.

Larkin's portrayal of the mothers' lives is marked by routine and domesticity. He mentions "an estateful of washing" and the "Our Wedding" album lying near the television. These details emphasize the mundane aspects of married life and the overshadowing of personal memories by the duties of motherhood. The album, associated with weddings and romance, lies neglected, further highlighting the transformation of personal identities.

The poem's conclusion evokes a sense of resignation. Larkin describes the mothers as "wives in skillful disguises," suggesting that they have adopted roles and personas to fulfill societal expectations. The image of "An Odeon went past, a cooling tower" serves as a contrast between the fleeting pleasures of entertainment and the enduring responsibilities of marriage and motherhood.

In conclusion, "Afternoons" by Philip Larkin offers a contemplative exploration of the impact of marriage and motherhood on individual identity. The poem reflects on the loss of personal freedom and the transformation of self within the context of family life. Larkin's use of language and imagery conveys a sense of resignation and inevitability, inviting readers to reflect on the societal expectations placed on individuals within the realm of family.

Comparative Analysis

These three poems—Tony Harrison's "Long Distance," Elizabeth Jennings' "My Grandmother," and Philip Larkin's "Afternoons"—each provide a unique perspective on family relationships and the emotions that accompany them. While they differ in their themes and approaches, they collectively shed light on the complexities of human connections within the family unit.

In "Long Distance," Tony Harrison masterfully captures the enduring love and grief within a close-knit family. The poem's portrayal of the father's rituals and the son's reflections offers a poignant exploration of how family bonds persist even in the face of death. Harrison's use of enjambment and shifting rhyme schemes adds depth to the narrative, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the poet's emotional journey. The poem ultimately serves as a testament to the enduring power of love and memory.

Elizabeth Jennings' "My Grandmother" offers a contrasting perspective, highlighting the theme of missed opportunities and distance within family relationships. The poet's realization of the consequences of her choices and the palpable absence of her grandmother's presence create a sense of regret that resonates with readers. Jennings' poem serves as a reminder of the importance of nurturing familial bonds and cherishing moments of connection. Her use of vivid imagery, such as the untouched antiques, reinforces the theme of missed chances for closeness.

Conclusion

In summary, the works of Tony Harrison, Elizabeth Jennings, and Philip Larkin provide profound insights into human relationships, emotions, and the passage of time within the context of family. Harrison's "Long Distance" delves into enduring love and grief within a close-knit family, exploring the soul's selectivity in forming connections. Jennings' "My Grandmother" portrays distance and regret within familial bonds, underscoring the importance of nurturing relationships. Lastly, Larkin's "Afternoons" offers a commentary on marriage and motherhood, highlighting the sacrifices and changes that come with these life stages.

While each poem offers a distinct perspective, they collectively shed light on the complexities of family dynamics, love, loss, and the inexorable passage of time. These poets invite readers to reflect on their own experiences and emotions within the context of family relationships, making their works enduring and relatable.