To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Folktales and fairy tales, passed down through generations, continually undergo transformations. The classic narrative of Cinderella, for instance, evolves with each retelling, from wicked step-sisters to benevolent ones, and from fairy godmothers to enchanted trees. Having delved into five diverse renditions of Cinderella, the task of selecting the most captivating version for my beloved child proved to be a thoughtful undertaking. After careful consideration, I have unequivocally settled on Walt Disney's rendition of Cinderella, a choice grounded in its unparalleled suitability for children compared to other adaptations more apt for older audiences.
Disney's adaptation not only embodies the quintessential fairy tale, commencing with the timeless phrase "Once upon a time" and concluding with the reassuring "lived in the palace and were happy ever after, too."
At the heart of the Cinderella narrative lies the tale of a kind-hearted young woman, oppressed by her stepmother and two stepsisters who subject her to a life of servitude. Amidst the drudgery of her daily chores, Cinderella yearns for a chance to attend the grand ball hosted by the king for all eligible young ladies in the kingdom, including her.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Arguments
5 (876)
“ Have been using her for a while and please believe when I tell you, she never fail. Thanks Writer Lyla you are indeed awesome ”
Despite her hopes, her cruel stepmother denies her the opportunity. Despondent, Cinderella encounters an elderly woman who reveals herself as her fairy godmother and declares, "You are going to the Ball." With a wave of her magical wand, Cinderella undergoes a stunning transformation, donning a beautiful gown, and a carriage pulled by horses materializes to escort her to the royal event.
However, a caveat accompanies the enchantment: the magic will wane at the stroke of midnight, necessitating Cinderella's departure.
At the ball, amidst anonymity, she captures the attention of the prince. Yet, heedless of the passing time, she rushes out at midnight, leaving behind a glass slipper. The ensuing search for the slipper's rightful owner becomes a pivotal element of the story. When the slipper fits Cinderella perfectly, she emerges as the chosen bride, sealing her fate as the princess who lived happily ever after.
While Walt Disney's version exudes charm and innocence, alternative renditions offer distinctive perspectives. Anne Sexton's "Cinderella" introduces subtle variations that, while intriguing, render it less suitable for young readers. Structured as a poem, Sexton's narrative weaves four succinct but impactful stories before delving into the Cinderella episode. This format may prove challenging for younger children to comprehend effectively. Additionally, Sexton introduces references, such as likening Cinderella's appearance to Al Jolson, which may elude the comprehension of young readers, necessitating further explanation and potentially interrupting the flow of the story.
A notable departure from the traditional narrative occurs in Sexton's version, where the stepsisters resort to extreme measures to fit into the glass slipper. Both sisters engage in self-mutilation, with one cutting off a toe and the other sacrificing part of her heel. This grim portrayal of self-inflicted harm raises concerns about the appropriateness of conveying such themes to impressionable young minds. The fairy godmother's intervention eventually exposes the sisters' deceit, highlighting the consequences of their actions.
The Grimm Brothers, Jakob and Wilhelm, present yet another variation of Cinderella, introducing moral complexities that may not align with the values deemed suitable for young readers. Similar to Sexton's version, the stepsisters in the Grimms' adaptation engage in drastic measures to force the slipper to fit, resorting to the macabre act of cutting off body parts. The implications of such actions, coupled with the involvement of the fairy godmother, raise questions about the appropriateness of introducing themes of bloodshed and self-harm to a young audience.
A particularly disconcerting element in both Sexton and the Grimms' versions involves the punishment meted out to the stepsisters. Instead of a benevolent resolution, the fairy godmother, portrayed as doves, pecks out the eyes of the stepsisters as retribution for their mistreatment of Cinderella. Such a grim and vengeful outcome may impart unsettling lessons to children, potentially shaping their perceptions in a less desirable manner.
After a thorough exploration of five captivating renditions of Cinderella, the merits of Walt Disney's adaptation, skillfully crafted by Campbell Grant, shine through as the most fitting for young readers, including my cherished child. Disney's Cinderella encapsulates the essence of a fairy tale with its enchanting narrative, emphasizing virtues of kindness, resilience, and the triumph of goodness over adversity.
The decision to favor Disney's version stems from its ability to present a happy and uplifting story without delving into the darker, morally ambiguous themes found in other adaptations. By opting for a narrative that maintains a sense of innocence and simplicity, parents can shield their children from unnecessary complexities until they are older and better equipped to navigate such nuances.
In conclusion, the enduring appeal of Cinderella lies not only in its ability to adapt across generations but also in its capacity to resonate with diverse audiences. Walt Disney's Cinderella, with its timeless charm, remains a timeless choice for young readers, imparting valuable lessons while preserving the magic and wonder of a classic fairy tale.
The Timeless Magic of Disney's Cinderella: A Delight for Young Hearts. (2016, Mar 09). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/cinderella-argument-paper-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
