The Odyssey: Grief's Impact on Odysseus' Evolution

As we delve into Homer's "The Odyssey," a profound theme emerges—the role of grief in shaping the character of the epic's protagonist, Odysseus. Grief, often overshadowed by the hero's triumphs and adventures, becomes a focal point, unraveling the intricacies of Odysseus' psyche and bringing forth a more nuanced portrayal of the 'Trojan War Hero.'

Grieving on Calypso's Island: Nostos and the Dual Meaning

The Odyssey begins with the backdrop of grief, a powerful force weaving through the lives of its characters.

Penelope's anxiety over the potential loss of her husband and Telemachus' struggle against the suitor's aggression are palpable. However, the most striking manifestation of grief lies in Odysseus' entrapment on Calypso's island, Ortygia.

Odysseus, typically perceived as the epitome of strength and bravery, undergoes a transformative experience, revealing the intricate layers of his character. The crucial question arises—what does 'nostos,' or the return home, truly signify for a soldier like Odysseus?

Leaving home, like many soldiers, Odysseus seeks 'kleos,' or glory.

Get quality help now

Marrie pro writer

Verified writer

Proficient in: Journey

5 (204)

“ She followed all my directions. It was really easy to contact her and respond very fast as well. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

However, 'nostos' takes on a dual meaning for him—a general homecoming and a personal 'coming to.' This internal conflict, juxtaposed against his external circumstances, allows grief to unfold, offering a profound understanding of his character beyond the heroic façade.

The Emasculated Odyssey: A Change in Character

Up until Book 5, we are presented with glorified war stories of Odysseus. Kings Nestor and Menelaus, along with Helen, regale Telemachus with tales of Odysseus' valor. However, Book 5 introduces a stark contrast as we find Odysseus on Calypso's island, in an unexpectedly emasculated state, shedding tears on the beach.

The poignant image of Odysseus, described as, "Wrenching his heart with sobs and groans and anguish," marks a departure from the traditional hero. His seven-year entrapment on Calypso's island denies him the active challenges he thrived upon. Calypso, meaning 'eclipse,' symbolizes the overshadowing of his known life and identity—a life of a warrior and hero eclipsed by longing and frustration.

Here, grief becomes the catalyst for Odysseus' transition, steering him away from the trajectory of a 'War Hero' towards a man who accepts grief, desperation, and helplessness as part of his journey.

Identity Redefined: Grieving Period and Behavioral Shift

Odyssesus' identity undergoes a profound redefinition during his grieving period. A comparison of his past behavior with the changes post-Underworld encounter reveals a significant shift. Earlier, his actions seemed reckless, driven by an insatiable desire to explore foreign lands, as evidenced in his decision to investigate the Cyclops' land despite uncertainty.

However, grief becomes a compelling teacher. Odysseus' encounter with the Cyclops highlights an error in judgment—a revelation of his identity against his men's wishes, placing them in peril. The very qualities that served him in battle become his stumbling block in times of peace.

Yet, as Odysseus sails towards the island of the Sun, a newfound restraint surfaces. Learning from the grief following the Cyclops episode, he warns his men against further peril, illustrating a transformation in his approach—one marked by a restraint on his thirst for adventure.

Restraint and Caution: Lessons Applied

This restraint persists upon Odysseus' return to Ithaca. In a departure from the impulsiveness seen with the Cyclops, he avoids the pompous mistake that befell Agamemnon. Disguised as a beggar, he navigates the city with caution. When insulted by the goatherd Melanthius, he steels himself, showcasing a newfound control over his reactions.

This shift in behavior is reflected in the change of the Homeric epithet attached to Odysseus' name—from 'cunning' to 'cool tactician.' The once impulsive hero, driven by a 'warrior's heart,' now displays a calculated and strategic approach, emphasizing the transformative impact of grief on his character.

Understated Arrival at Ithaca: Vulnerability Unveiled

Odysseus' return to Ithaca, initially anticipated with grandiosity, unfolds in an understated manner. Disguised as a beggar, he appears unrecognizable to Penelope. The once mighty hero is now perceived as a 'huddled mass of rags.'

Book 23 captures Penelope's struggle to reconcile the changed Odysseus, marking a metaphorical unmasking. Odysseus, no longer the invincible hero in complete control, reveals vulnerability—a vulnerability born out of grief and maturation through acceptance of his limitations.

Unexplored Second Journey: Ambiguities and Unanswered Questions

The Odyssey concludes with ambiguity surrounding Odysseus' second journey—a quest advised by Tiresias to appease Poseidon. The imperative, "But once you have killed those suitors in your halls … go forth once more, you must," hints at an unfinished odyssey, raising doubts about Odysseus' attainment of peace.

The narrative choice to leave this second journey unexplored suggests an open-ended resolution. Perhaps, Odysseus never achieves the sought-after peace of mind, leaving readers pondering the lasting impact of war on a soldier's soul.

Deeper Questions and Concluding Thoughts

The Odyssey prompts us to contemplate universal questions—can soldiers truly reclaim their former selves after the crucible of war? Odysseus' Hero's Journey, often confined to tales of cunning and heroism, transcends into a journey of 'coming to.'

While heroic actions portray him as a two-dimensional character, grief emerges as the true catalyst for Odysseus' development. His acceptance of vulnerability and inability to control every situation transcend the confines of traditional heroism, offering a profound narrative that transcends the superficial expectations of a 'Trojan War Hero.'

In conclusion, "The Odyssey" masterfully weaves the transformative power of grief into the fabric of Odysseus' character. Through grief, he evolves from a one-dimensional hero into a multifaceted, emotionally mature individual, challenging our perception of heroism and revealing the profound complexities within the human spirit.