Gender Dynamics from Shakespeare to 20th Century

Essay, Pages 5 (1153 words)

Views

1040

Introduction

Exploring the dynamic adaptation of Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew" in the 1999 film "10 Things I Hate About You" unveils a profound shift in values across historical and cultural contexts. As a university student delving into literary analysis, it's intriguing to dissect the evolution of societal norms, particularly regarding gender roles, power dynamics, and language use, over the four centuries separating these two works.

Comparison of Historical and Cultural Contexts

In the Elizabethan era, a prevailing belief in male superiority dominated societal norms, a sentiment intricately woven into Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get your custom essay on

“ Gender Dynamics from Shakespeare to 20th Century ”

Get custom paper

NEW! smart matching with writer

" The play mirrors this era's entrenched misogyny, exemplified in the forceful marriage and submission of Katherina, underscoring the accepted dominance of men. In stark contrast, "10 Things I Hate About You," a cinematic appropriation of Shakespeare's narrative, boldly challenges these historical values. Set in a modern high school environment, the film reflects contemporary beliefs in gender equality and women's empowerment, diverging significantly from the patriarchal landscape of Shakespeare's time.

Power Dynamics and Social Systems

The power dynamics at play in "The Taming of the Shrew" are emblematic of Elizabethan societal norms. Katherina's coerced marriage, orchestrated by Petruchio and her father, epitomizes the authoritative sway men held over women during that era. The narrative unfolds with Katherina's objections being nullified by her inferior status, emphasizing the deeply ingrained gender hierarchy. Conversely, "10 Things I Hate About You" propels itself into a modern setting, where the film accentuates the influence and power wielded by women and the youth. The Stratford sisters' interactions with their love interests and father serve as a canvas for the portrayal of equality, defying the constraints of the 16th-century European context seen in Shakespeare's play.

Modern Context and Feminism

Directed towards a contemporary teenage audience with progressive views shaped by the rise of feminism, "10 Things I Hate About You" boldly explores the power dynamics within relationships. Kat, the modern counterpart to Katherina, embraces her non-conformist views openly, finding resonance with feminist figures like Sylvia Plath and Charlotte Bronte. The film strategically incorporates 'riot grrrl' music, epitomizing the rebellious spirit of the era, to define Kat's character from the very onset. This feminist lens fundamentally challenges the original text, where Katherina's resistance to societal norms would have been deemed unacceptable and repressed.

Repression and Acceptance

Hortensio's mockery of Katherina in Shakespeare's play, manipulating her words to silence her, reflects the accepted repression within that era. Katherina's ultimate submission to Petruchio's dominance is not only exaggerated but also socially sanctioned. In contrast, "10 Things I Hate About You" vehemently rejects such repression, resonating with the evolving values of a society that no longer tolerates such gender-based oppression. Kat, in the modern context, stands as a testament to the changing tide, expressing her autonomy without the oppressive weight carried by Katherina.

The liberties afforded to Kat in the film become evident as she challenges her father's authority, particularly in instances like her attendance at Sarah Lawrence College. Unlike Baptista in Shakespeare's play, Walter in the film recognizes and acknowledges Kat's capacity to control her own life, marking a departure from the unwavering subjugation accepted in the Elizabethan context of "The Taming of the Shrew."

Marital Relationships and Social Values

The stark contrast in marital relationships between the two works becomes apparent when examining the societal values embedded in the narrative. "The Taming of the Shrew" epitomizes the Elizabethan norm of arranged marriages, where the men, namely the husband and the father, dictated the course of romantic unions. The concept of dowries, symbolized by Baptista's offer to Petruchio, further solidifies the adherence to societal expectations. This historical context, however, is subverted in "10 Things I Hate About You." The film portrays a modern society valuing freedom in romantic relationships, as seen in the Stratford daughters dating instead of adhering to the Elizabethan tradition of arranged marriages.

The film meticulously critiques the societal norms of its own time, portraying the immorality of payment for wooing Kat, a stark departure from the expected dowries in "The Taming of the Shrew." Petruchio's initial inquiry about the dowry in Shakespeare's play highlights the economic transaction inherent in marital arrangements during that era. This contrast further underscores the significant shift in social values, where the film challenges not only the authority of characters like Baptista but also questions the ethicality of monetary exchanges within relationships.

Love and Language

The portrayal of love and the language used to express it serves as a poignant reflection of the differing contexts. In "The Taming of the Shrew," Petruchio's ludicrous metaphoric objectifications of Katherina emphasize his intention to assert dominance, despite his seemingly jovial wordplay. Conversely, "10 Things I Hate About You" diverges significantly by showcasing Patrick's chivalry and respectful treatment of Kat. The film challenges traditional assertions of male dominance in relationships, creating a stark contrast to Petruchio's authoritative demeanor. The endearing love story between Patrick and Kat stands in sharp contrast to the debatable nature of Petruchio and Katherina's love, with the latter's acceptance of male supremacy in her final speech.

The very language used in the two works further accentuates the evolving societal attitudes. While characters in Shakespeare's play utilize refined speech and wordplay to reflect status and intelligence, those in "10 Things I Hate About You" employ colloquial language. The film embraces a more casual linguistic style, reflecting the contemporary preference for authenticity and relatability. Moreover, the film establishes a direct link between intelligence and linguistic prowess, with characters like Kat and Patrick, who manipulate language adeptly, being viewed as intelligent and virtuous, challenging the traditional notions upheld in Elizabethan society.

Joey "eat me" Donner's simplistic language in the film projects a poorer image of his character, illustrating the contemporary societal disdain for intellectual mediocrity. This linguistic distinction serves as a microcosm of the prevailing values, where modern society places a premium on intelligence rather than wealth, diverging from the materialistic inclinations evident in the Elizabethan context of "The Taming of the Shrew."

Conclusion

In dissecting the storyline and themes of "The Taming of the Shrew" and its adaptation in "10 Things I Hate About You," the profound transformation becomes evident. The four-century gap between these works encapsulates a metamorphosis in societal values concerning gender, status, and youth. "10 Things I Hate About You," tailored for a 20th-century teenage audience, mirrors Shakespeare's approach in expressing the values pertinent to its contemporary context. Just as Shakespeare crafted his narrative to resonate with the Elizabethan audience, the film strategically modifies the original text to align with the evolving norms and expectations of its own time.

This exploration of literary evolution, as perceived through the lens of a university student, not only illuminates the adaptability of classic works but also underscores the reciprocal relationship between literature and societal values. As we navigate the intricate tapestry of these narratives, it becomes evident that the essence of storytelling is, in many ways, a reflection of the collective consciousness of the society in which it is crafted and received.