What of This Goldfish Would You Wish?: Choices and Consequences

Life is a tapestry woven with choices, each one a thread that contributes to the intricate pattern of our existence. In the short story "What of This Goldfish Would You Wish?" by Etgar Keret, the protagonist, Yonatan, is faced with a profound moral dilemma when he discovers a talking goldfish that grants wishes. This essay delves into the themes of the story, examining the choices made by Yonatan and their consequences. Through this exploration, we will reflect on the nature of desires, the ethics of power, and the unpredictable outcomes of our decisions.

The Temptation of Desires

Desire is a powerful force that often drives human actions. In Yonatan's case, the discovery of a magical goldfish that can grant wishes awakens a cascade of desires within him. He becomes torn between his own desires and the consequences of his wishes.

Yonatan's initial wish is to be left alone, a desire rooted in his need for solitude and independence. However, as the story unfolds, his wishes become increasingly complex and intertwined with the lives of others.

Get quality help now

Doctor Jennifer

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

5 (893)

“ Thank you so much for accepting my assignment the night before it was due. I look forward to working with you moving forward ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

He wishes for world peace, attempts to address global conflicts, and even tries to undo his previous wishes. These evolving desires showcase the intricacies of human nature, as our wants and needs are often subject to change and adaptation.

The story serves as a poignant reminder of the complexity of desires and how they can shape our choices. It prompts us to reflect on the true nature of our wishes and the extent to which we are willing to go to fulfill them.

The Ethics of Power

Yonatan's possession of the talking goldfish confers upon him a remarkable power—the ability to have his wishes granted. This newfound power raises ethical questions about the responsible use of power and the consequences of our actions.

Yonatan's initial wishes are relatively benign, but as he grapples with the weight of his decisions, he faces ethical dilemmas. He wishes for world peace, an admirable desire, but he soon realizes the complexity of such a wish. Achieving global harmony involves the erasure of individuality and the suppression of conflict, raising questions about the ethics of imposing one's will on others, even for a noble cause.

The story also highlights the unintended consequences of wielding power. Yonatan's wishes for world peace inadvertently lead to mass amnesia, erasing people's memories and individual identities. This unintended consequence underscores the idea that power can have far-reaching and unpredictable effects, challenging our assumptions about control and responsibility.

The ethical dimension of Yonatan's choices invites us to consider our own responsibilities when given power or influence over others. It prompts us to reflect on the balance between personal desires and the welfare of society as a whole.

The Unpredictable Outcomes of Choices

The story "What of This Goldfish Would You Wish?" illustrates the unpredictability of choices and their far-reaching consequences. Yonatan's initial wish for solitude seems harmless, but it sets in motion a chain of events that spiral out of control.

As Yonatan attempts to navigate the complexities of his wishes, he discovers that the outcomes are not what he anticipated. His quest to undo his initial wish for solitude results in the loss of individual identity, a consequence he could not have foreseen. This theme of unintended consequences serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us that our choices can have repercussions that extend beyond our immediate intentions.

Furthermore, the story challenges the notion of free will and determinism. Yonatan's wishes seem to be a form of determinism, where external forces dictate the course of events. This raises questions about the extent to which we have control over our choices and whether our desires ultimately shape our destinies.

The story encourages readers to consider the unpredictability of life and the interconnectedness of our choices. It reminds us that the consequences of our actions may not always align with our intentions, and that navigating the complexities of life requires a degree of humility and acceptance of the unknown.

Conclusion: Choices, Desires, and Reflection

The short story "What of This Goldfish Would You Wish?" by Etgar Keret serves as a thought-provoking exploration of choices and consequences. Through the lens of Yonatan's journey, we are reminded of the intricate nature of human desires, the ethical considerations of power, and the unpredictable outcomes of our decisions.

As we reflect on the story, we are encouraged to examine our own choices and desires. We are prompted to consider the responsibility that comes with power and the moral implications of our actions. Ultimately, the story challenges us to embrace the complexity of life, acknowledging that our desires and choices are woven into the tapestry of our existence, shaping our destinies in ways that may remain beyond our comprehension.