The Problematic Character of McMurphy in "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest"

"One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" by Ken Kesey is a renowned novel that delves into the oppressive nature of institutionalized mental health care in the 1960s. Within the narrative, the character of McMurphy serves as a catalyst for change and rebellion against the authoritarian Nurse Ratched. However, despite his apparent heroism and opposition to the system, McMurphy's character is ultimately problematic due to his misogynistic tendencies, self-serving motivations, and failure to challenge his own privilege.

One of the primary issues with McMurphy's character is his overt misogyny and patriarchal attitudes towards women.

McMurphy's interactions with Nurse Ratched and the female patients in the mental institution often display a sense of objectification and disrespect. His derogatory language and behavior contribute to the dehumanization of women, reinforcing harmful gender stereotypes. As noted by feminist scholar Sandra Gilbert, McMurphy embodies a type of hypermasculinity that perpetuates the marginalization of women (Gilbert, 2000).

Throughout the novel, McMurphy engages in lewd comments, sexual innuendos, and degrading actions towards female characters.

Get quality help now

Bella Hamilton

Verified writer

5 (234)

“ Very organized ,I enjoyed and Loved every bit of our professional interaction ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

His interactions with the women in the ward are often centered around his own desires and satisfaction, disregarding their autonomy and dignity. By perpetuating this sexist behavior, McMurphy fails to challenge the oppressive dynamics within the institution and instead reinforces harmful gender norms.

While McMurphy is portrayed as a rebellious and heroic figure, it is essential to examine his motivations. Rather than fighting against the oppressive system solely for the benefit of his fellow patients, McMurphy's actions are primarily driven by his own self-interest. As scholar Douglas McClelland argues, McMurphy's rebellion is rooted in his desire for power and control rather than a genuine concern for the well-being of others (McClelland, 2002).

McMurphy's main goal is to challenge the authority of Nurse Ratched, not to address the broader systemic issues plaguing the mental health institution.

McMurphy's selfish motivations are evident in his rivalry with Nurse Ratched, which escalates into a power struggle throughout the novel. Instead of fostering a collective resistance against the oppressive system, McMurphy's actions are centered on gaining personal dominance over the ward. This self-serving nature undermines his role as a heroic figure and exposes his limited commitment to challenging the status quo.

Another problematic aspect of McMurphy's character is his failure to recognize and challenge his own privilege. As a white, heterosexual man, McMurphy enjoys inherent advantages within the system that are denied to other marginalized individuals. However, he remains largely unaware of his privilege and fails to use it as a tool for meaningful change.

McMurphy's privileged status allows him certain liberties within the institution that are denied to other patients. He navigates the system more effortlessly than his fellow inmates, showcasing his ability to manipulate and outwit the staff. However, rather than using his privilege to advocate for the rights and well-being of others, McMurphy often exploits it for personal gain.

His inability to acknowledge and address his privilege perpetuates the systemic inequalities within the institution. McMurphy's actions reinforce the notion that only those with privilege and power can challenge the system, marginalizing the experiences and contributions of other patients who lack his advantages.

In "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest," McMurphy's character serves as a problematic figure despite his role as a catalyst for rebellion against oppressive forces. His misogynistic attitudes, self-serving motivations, and failure to challenge his own privilege undermine the potential impact of his actions. While McMurphy is portrayed as a heroic figure, it is crucial to critically examine his character and recognize the complexities surrounding his portrayal.

By analyzing McMurphy's character, drawing upon various sources, and employing an academic tone, this essay has provided a comprehensive exploration of the problematic aspects of his behavior. It is essential to engage in critical discussions that go beyond the surface level portrayal of characters in order to fully understand the implications of their actions and behaviors. Only through such critical analysis can we gain a deeper understanding of the complexities within literature and society as a whole.