To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
The 1930s marked a transformative era in the United States, characterized by profound economic depression and heightened ethnic tensions. In this tumultuous period, literature emerged as a powerful medium to reflect on societal issues. Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird stands out by introducing the theme of "provincialism," a nuanced exploration that adds depth and complexity to the narrative. This essay delves into the multifaceted dimensions of provincialism in Maycomb County, examining three major aspects: the distrust of those perceived as different, socio-economic disparities, and racial intolerance.
Harper Lee adeptly uses the general attitude of Maycomb's inhabitants toward individuals considered untrustworthy to shed light on a crucial facet of provincialism.
An exemplary case is the town's perception of Miss Maudie, an elderly woman devoted to her garden. Maycomb residents cast suspicion on her, believing she should spend more time indoors reading the Bible. Miss Maudie discloses the town's judgment to Scout: "Did you know some of them came out of the woods one day and told me that me and my flowers were gonna go to hell..." (p.50).
Verified writer
Proficient in: Race and Ethnicity
4.7 (657)
“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”
This episode vividly illustrates the community's tendency to distrust those deviating from societal norms.
Atticus Finch, initially a respected figure, experiences a loss of dignity when he defends a black man in court. Francis, a relative of Scout, expresses disdain during a Christmas celebration: "I guess it ain't your fault if Uncle Atticus is a nigger lover...but it certainly does mortify the rest of the family" (p.89).
Atticus's commitment to justice is perceived as a stain on the family name, emblematic of Maycomb's narrow-mindedness. The Radley family faces similar scrutiny for their reclusive behavior, challenging the town's ingrained prejudices. As Scout observes, "The Radleys, welcome anywhere in town, had kept to themselves, a predilection unforgivable in Maycomb" (p.15).
These instances exemplify how Maycomb's residents, in their adherence to societal norms, contribute to the climate of provincialism by scrutinizing and distrusting those who deviate from the expected behaviors.
Expanding on this theme, the novel not only presents individual instances of distrust but also explores the collective mindset of the town. Maycomb becomes a microcosm of a society bound by traditions and resistant to change. The inhabitants, driven by a fear of the unknown and a desire to conform, perpetuate a culture of suspicion. This culture, rooted in provincialism, stifles individuality and fosters an environment where anyone perceived as different becomes a target for skepticism and exclusion.
Furthermore, the theme of distrust extends beyond personal idiosyncrasies to encompass broader societal expectations. The pressure to conform to established norms is palpable in Maycomb, with residents quick to judge and ostracize anyone who challenges the status quo. This collective distrust contributes to the perpetuation of provincialism, creating a cycle that reinforces rigid societal boundaries and stifles progress.
Harper Lee utilizes the socio-economic stratification within Maycomb to underscore another facet of provincialism – the economic hierarchy. The town exhibits a clear caste system, with blacks at the bottom facing severe social and racial discrimination. Blacks endure segregation, using separate facilities and experiencing inequality in various aspects of life. Mrs. Merriweather's perspective on the dissatisfaction among blacks reflects the prevailing prejudice: "The cooks and field hands are just dissatisfied, but they're settling down now..." (p.238).
Farmers, constituting the second group, grapple with economic challenges due to the Depression. Atticus explains the plight of the Cunninghams, highlighting the impact of the economic downturn: "The Cunninghams are country folks, farmers, and the crash hit them the hardest" (p.27). Maycomb's educated elite, represented by figures like Aunt Alexandra, contribute to the class distinctions. Aunt Alexandra, despite her genteel manners, perpetuates a judgmental attitude, belittling the Cunningham family: "They're not good folks like us" (p.135).
These examples underscore how Maycomb's economic disparities contribute to a hidden caste system, where an individual's wealth takes precedence over their character and other attributes, fostering a climate of provincialism.
Expanding on the economic dynamics in Maycomb, it becomes evident that the economic depression of the 1930s exacerbates existing social hierarchies. The struggles faced by farmers, such as the Cunninghams, highlight the interconnectedness of economic instability and provincial attitudes. As Maycomb grapples with the economic fallout, societal divisions become more pronounced, with judgments based on wealth gaining greater significance.
Moreover, the introduction of Aunt Alexandra as a representative of the educated elite adds another layer to the exploration of socio-economic disparities. Her character embodies the class-conscious mindset prevalent in Maycomb, where one's pedigree and social standing are paramount. This perpetuates a culture of exclusivity, further entrenching provincialism within the fabric of the community.
Harper Lee emphasizes racial intolerance as a pivotal element of provincialism within Maycomb County. The town, representative of many small-minded American communities, subjects its black population to degrading treatment. During Tom Robinson's trial, Bob Ewell's testimony epitomizes the dehumanization of blacks: "I seen that nigger rutting on my Mayella" (p.179). Here, Ewell equates a black person to an animal, underscoring the town's pervasive racism.
Those who stand with the oppressed, like Atticus, face ostracism. Cecil Jacobs taunts Scout about Atticus: "Your daddy was a disgrace, and a nigger ought to hang from the river-tank" (p.82). White individuals aligned with black causes are deemed shameful, highlighting the community's ingrained biases. The physical separation of the black and white communities, symbolized by an imposing wall, accentuates the isolation and distinct worlds inhabited by each group.
Even within the black community, a desire for privacy is evident, as seen when Calpurnia takes Jem and Scout to the black church. Lula articulates this sentiment: "You ain't got no business bringing white chillun here, they got their church, we got our'n. This is our church, ain't it Miss Cal" (p.125). Maycomb becomes a battleground where different ethnic groups clash ideologically, contributing to the overarching theme of provincialism.
Expanding on the racial dynamics, the novel portrays Maycomb as a microcosm of the deeply ingrained racial prejudices prevalent in the American South during the 1930s. The trial of Tom Robinson serves as a focal point, highlighting not only the injustice faced by the black community but also the town's collective refusal to confront its own biases.
Furthermore, the characters' reactions to Atticus's decision to defend Tom Robinson offer insights into the deeply entrenched racial intolerance within Maycomb. The verbal attacks on Atticus, labeling him as a "nigger lover," exemplify the town's hostility towards anyone challenging the status quo. This reaction serves as a stark reminder of the consequences faced by those daring to challenge the prevailing provincial mindset.
Moreover, the novel subtly explores the psychological impact of racial intolerance on individuals, both black and white. Characters like Calpurnia, Tom Robinson, and Atticus navigate a complex web of societal expectations, confronting the harsh realities of racial discrimination. Their experiences add depth to the narrative, shedding light on the personal toll of living in a community rife with provincialism.
In conclusion, Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird masterfully captures the essence of provincialism in Maycomb County. The three dimensions explored – distrust of those who differ, socio-economic disparities, and racial intolerance – collectively paint a vivid picture of a community grappling with narrow-mindedness and prejudice. Through Scout's eyes, Lee exposes the flaws and complexities inherent in a society governed by provincialism. Maycomb becomes a microcosm of the broader societal challenges faced during the 1930s, serving as a compelling reflection on human behavior and the consequences of entrenched biases.
Provincialism in Maycomb County: A Critical Analysis of Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird. (2016, Jun 22). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/provincialism-in-to-kill-a-mockingird-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
