To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Sharon Block's insightful work, "Lines of Color, Sex, and Service: Sexual Coercion in the Early Republic," sheds light on the harrowing experiences of two women who suffered mistreatment at the hands of their masters during a tumultuous period in American history. The stories of Rachel Davis, a white servant in the Cress household, and Harriet Jacobs, an enslaved black woman in the Norcom household, provide a compelling backdrop for examining the dynamics of sexual coercion, gender roles, and the limited agency women had in confronting such injustices.
The experiences of Rachel and Harriet reveal a distressing pattern of masters making sexual advances toward their young female servants.
In both cases, their mistresses, Becky Cress and Mary Norcom, became suspicious of their husbands' inappropriate relationships with the young women, leading them to demand that the servants leave their households immediately.
However, the removal of Rachel and Harriet from their masters' homes did not put an end to their torment.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Slavery And Freedom
4.7 (235)
“ Amazing writer! I am really satisfied with her work. An excellent price as well. ”
Instead, their masters persisted in their predatory behavior by visiting the women at their new residences. This ongoing harassment placed Rachel and Harriet in distressing situations where they had to fend off unwanted advances.
One particularly troubling incident involved Mary Norcom, who attempted to protect Harriet by having her sleep in her room to prevent her husband's advances. Mary even went as far as whispering in Harriet's ear as if she were her husband, highlighting the disturbing lengths to which women went to safeguard their servants. Despite these efforts, Mary's husband continued his sexual overtures, illustrating the powerlessness women often felt in their attempts to control their husbands' actions.
Becky Cress and Mary Norcom both confronted their husbands about the inappropriate relationships with their servants.
However, their husbands, William Cress and James Norcom, responded by denying any wrongdoing, leaving their wives in emotional turmoil. These verbal confrontations failed to deter the masters from their predatory behavior, highlighting the profound power imbalance between men and women during this era.
One may wonder why Becky and Mary did not take more drastic measures, such as removing their husbands from the household or seeking divorce. It is crucial to understand the societal norms and constraints of the time, which heavily favored men. Divorce was stigmatized, and women faced significant obstacles in pursuing it, especially when it involved allegations against their husbands.
Moreover, these cases underscore how men often manipulated their way out of dilemmas through persuasive tactics, leaving women with few options to assert their rights and prove their husbands' wrongdoing.
The consequences that followed these two cases varied significantly, shedding light on the disparities in the treatment of white and black women during this period. Rachel Davis, a white woman, had a distinct advantage due to her racial background and the support of her father. When Rachel's father learned of the sexual abuse she endured, he initiated a rape prosecution against William Cress, leading to a guilty verdict and a ten-year prison sentence for her abuser.
In contrast, Harriet Jacobs, an enslaved black woman, faced a far more challenging situation. Enslaved women like Harriet lacked access to the protection and legal recourse offered by patriarchal figures. Despite the striking similarity in the nature of the abuse experienced by Rachel and Harriet, Harriet's race rendered her powerless to engage the local legal system effectively.
Harriet's ordeal grew even more challenging when Mary Norcom demanded her removal from the household upon discovering Harriet's pregnancy, which she used as evidence to support her claims against her husband. Harriet had to resort to becoming a runaway slave, seeking refuge in her free grandmother's attic to escape her master's relentless sexual coercion.
While both masters treated Rachel and Harriet in a similar manner, the differences in their outcomes illuminate the stark inequalities faced by black women during this period. Harriet's grandmother lacked the means to intervene as Rachel's father had, exemplifying the systemic obstacles encountered by enslaved black women in their pursuit of justice.
Sharon Block's meticulous examination of sexual coercion in the early republic serves as a poignant reminder of the complex interplay of power, gender, and race during this turbulent era in American history. The stories of Rachel Davis and Harriet Jacobs shed light on the disparities in treatment between white and black women and the constrained agency available to women in confronting sexual abuse.
While Rachel's case led to legal intervention and consequences for her perpetrator, Harriet's experience underscores the systemic challenges faced by enslaved black women in their quest for justice. These historical accounts serve as enduring reminders of the enduring legacy of gender and racial inequalities in American society, underscoring the ongoing struggle for justice and equality.
Sexual Coercion in the Early Republic: A Comparative Analysis. (2017, Jan 14). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/lines-of-color-sex-and-service-sexual-coercion-in-the-early-republic-by-sharon-block-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
