The Knightley Brothers in Jane Austen's 'Emma'

Categories: Fiction

Essay, Pages 4 (894 words)

Views

220

Introduction

In Jane Austen's 'Emma,' John and George Knightley stand as exemplars of virtue, embodying the essence of archetypal heroes. This exploration delves into their characters, relationships, and the potential perception of monotony resulting from their unwavering goodness.

As the story unfolds in the quaint town of Highbury, the Knightley brothers emerge as pillars of virtue. However, a lingering thought raises a query—could their unshakeable virtue make them appear a bit dull to readers?

Comparison with Mr. and Mrs.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get your custom essay on

“ The Knightley Brothers in Jane Austen’s ‘Emma’ ”
Get custom paper
NEW! smart matching with writer

Elton

Jane Austen, a master of character crafting, imbues her creations with varying shades of morality. The Eltons, subtly leaning towards villainy, serve as a foil to the Knightley brothers, especially George, who embodies the quintessential hero with steadfast virtue and goodness.

Characterization of George Knightley

George Knightley, a central figure in the 'Emma' narrative, finds himself intricately woven into the story's fabric. His close ties to the Woodhouse family, through both land ownership and family bonds, position him as a reliable hero.

George's cheerful nature and frequent visits to Mr. Woodhouse not only highlight his virtuous character but also showcase his warm familial connections.

Having known Emma since birth, George assumes a fatherly role. His unique perspective, free from excessive admiration for Emma's perfection, sets him apart. As the story unfolds, George's role evolves from a family friend to a voice of reason and, eventually, a suitor to Emma.

It's worth noting that George's character isn't just defined by his interactions with Emma but also by his broader role in Highbury.

His influence extends beyond the Woodhouse family, contributing to the overall moral fabric of the community. The town, in a sense, finds stability in the presence of a figure as virtuous as George Knightley.

Characterization of John Knightley

The story's somber tones find expression in John Knightley, George's elder brother. Described as a tall, clever man with a more serious demeanor, John complements George's cheerfulness with his stoic presence. His occasional clashes with Mr. Weston, attributed to a less amiable temper, reveal a different facet of heroism—one that endures despite inherent imperfections.

During social events, John's nuances become apparent, especially in his reluctance to fully embrace the festive atmosphere. However, his adept peacekeeping skills, observed during the Christmas gathering, add depth to his heroism. In the tapestry of heroes, John's gruff exterior seamlessly intertwines with George's cheerful countenance.

Delving deeper into John's character, one discovers a man shaped by responsibility and duty. His commitment to maintaining peace and order, even in the face of personal displeasure, underscores his dedication to the well-being of the community. It's this sense of duty that distinguishes John as a hero not just in his familial relations but in the broader social context of Highbury.

Comparison of the Knightleys' Traits

Among Austen's heroes, the Knightley brothers emerge as particularly angelic, displaying virtues with remarkable consistency. Their sharp judgment, embodied by George and occasionally mirrored by John, sets them apart in a world where folly often reigns. George's sensitivity, especially towards the Woodhouses, becomes a defining feature, avoiding the pitfalls that could render him uninteresting.

Moreover, George assumes the role of a guardian, watching over Emma with a paternal eye. His ability to appreciate her diligence and offer commendation, as seen in her early reading lists, adds layers to his character. Many within the narrative, and even Emma herself, perceive George as the epitome of an ideal man.

John, on the other hand, offers a different brand of heroism—one grounded in pragmatism and a steadfast commitment to his responsibilities. His occasional gruffness doesn't diminish the sincerity of his character; rather, it adds a layer of authenticity to his role as a hero in Highbury.

George's Flaw and Jealousy

Yet, in George's otherwise pristine character, a flaw surfaces—his thinly veiled jealousy for Frank Churchill. This jealousy stems from Frank's overt flirtations with Emma, behavior that irks George. His criticism of Frank, attributing the need for duty to vigor and resolution rather than maneuvering, adds a touch of moral righteousness to his character.

This flaw humanizes George, challenging the notion of his perfection. The interplay of jealousy introduces a dynamic element, showcasing the complexity inherent even in the most virtuous characters. It's a reminder that heroes, despite their virtues, grapple with human emotions, adding depth to their personas.

Conclusion

In conclusion, it becomes apparent that the Knightley brothers, while embodying virtue to the utmost degree, may risk being perceived as somewhat dull. The absence of dark secrets and the unblemished nature of their characters might create an image of monotony. However, within the context of the flawed heroines they accompany, particularly Emma and her sister, the Knightleys emerge as fitting counterparts, restoring balance to the intricate social tapestry of Highbury.

As we traverse the nuanced world of 'Emma,' the Knightley brothers stand not as mere characters but as enduring symbols of virtue, inviting readers to ponder the complexities of heroism and the ever-present interplay of flaws and strengths.

While the Knightleys may seem to embody an idealistic portrayal of heroism, their journey in 'Emma' invites readers to reflect on the nature of heroism itself. The nuanced exploration of their characters prompts a broader consideration of the qualities that define a true hero and the challenges they face, making the Knightley brothers not just protagonists in a story but thought-provoking symbols in Austen's rich literary tapestry.