Exploring the Theme of Appearances vs. Reality in Poetry

Human perception can be deceiving, often leading us to judge a book by its cover. Appearances frequently diverge from the truths hidden beneath the surface. Poems such as "Richard Cory" by Edwin Arlington Robinson, "We Wear the Mask" by Paul Laurence Dunbar, and "I'm Nobody! Who are you?" by Emily Dickinson delve into the theme of appearances versus reality. These poems exemplify how individuals and society, as a whole, often wear metaphorical masks to conceal their true emotions and identities. Through the use of poetic language and literary devices, these poets skillfully expose the stark contrasts between appearances and reality.

Appearances vs. Reality in "Richard Cory" by Edwin Arlington Robinson

Edwin Arlington Robinson's "Richard Cory" provides a poignant exploration of how appearances can deceive. The poem revolves around a man named Richard Cory, who is placed on a pedestal by those who know him. He is admired, envied, and revered by the people in his town. Robinson writes, "And he was always quietly arrayed, and he was always human when he talked; but still, he fluttered pulses when he said, 'Good morning,' and he glittered when he walked.

Get quality help now

Marrie pro writer

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

5 (204)

“ She followed all my directions. It was really easy to contact her and respond very fast as well. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

.." This vivid description highlights the awe and admiration that Richard Cory evokes among the townspeople.

However, the poem takes a tragic turn when it is revealed that Richard Cory, despite his external grandeur, harbors inner sorrow. In a surprising and ironic twist, Robinson writes, "And Richard Cory, one calm summer night, went home and put a bullet through his head." This abrupt and unexpected ending shatters the illusion of Cory's perfect life, exposing the stark contrast between his public image and private reality.

The Poetic Language of "Richard Cory"

Robinson employs poetic language to accentuate the theme of appearances versus reality in "Richard Cory." One notable technique is the use of imagery. Phrases like "he glittered when he walked" create a visual image of Richard Cory as a radiant and almost otherworldly figure. This imagery reinforces the townspeople's perception of him as a man of unparalleled stature.

Additionally, Robinson incorporates irony into the poem. The dramatic irony lies in the fact that the readers are aware of Cory's inner turmoil while the townspeople remain oblivious. This irony underscores the disconnect between how Cory appears to others and the hidden truth of his suffering.

Robinson's skillful use of poetic language evokes feelings of admiration and envy in the reader, mirroring the sentiments of the townspeople. However, it ultimately serves to expose the profound divide between appearances and reality, leaving a lasting impact on the audience.

The Mask of Society in "We Wear the Mask" by Paul Laurence Dunbar

Paul Laurence Dunbar's "We Wear the Mask" delves into the societal phenomenon of wearing masks to conceal one's true emotions. The title itself encapsulates the central theme of the poem—the idea that individuals often wear a metaphorical mask to hide their genuine feelings.

The poem describes this mask as something that "grins and lies," obscuring the wearer's cheeks and shading their eyes. The mask becomes a symbol of the facades people put on to present a cheerful and composed exterior, even when they are burdened by inner sorrow. Dunbar writes, "This debt we pay to human guile; with torn and bleeding hearts, we smile and mouth with myriad subtleties." Here, the poet emphasizes the societal expectation to maintain a façade of happiness, even when experiencing pain.

The Poetic Language of "We Wear the Mask"

Dunbar employs an extended metaphor throughout the poem, comparing the mask to a shield that conceals true emotions. This metaphorical language vividly illustrates the idea of wearing a mask as a form of protection, shielding individuals from judgment and ostracization by society. It conveys the sense that people feel compelled to conform to societal norms, even if it means concealing their genuine selves.

The poem also employs sensory language to evoke empathy and pride in the reader. Lines like "We smile, but oh, great Christ, our cries to thee from tortured souls arise" elicit a profound sense of empathy for those who hide their pain behind the mask. Simultaneously, the poem instills a sense of pride in the narrator for refusing to reveal their true self to a judgmental world.

Dunbar's use of tone in "We Wear the Mask" fluctuates between playful and comical, emphasizing the irony of the situation. The playful tone is evident in lines like "Nay, let them only see us while we wear the mask," highlighting the idea that individuals willingly participate in this charade. However, the underlying comical tone underscores the absurdity of the societal expectation to wear masks.

The Nobodies in "I'm Nobody! Who are you?" by Emily Dickinson

Emily Dickinson's "I'm Nobody! Who are you?" offers a unique perspective on the theme of appearances versus reality. The poem playfully explores the idea that being a "nobody" is preferable to being a "somebody" in society. Dickinson introduces the persona of a child who revels in the idea of being anonymous and unnoticed.

The poem presents a world where "somebody" is synonymous with self-importance and conformity to societal norms. In contrast, the "nobody" is free from the burdens of societal expectations and can exist authentically. Dickinson writes, "How dreary to be somebody! How public, like a frog, to tell one's name the livelong day to an admiring bog!" This whimsical portrayal highlights the irony that, in the quest for recognition and acceptance, individuals often sacrifice their true selves.

The Poetic Language of "I'm Nobody! Who are you?"

Dickinson employs similes and satire to convey the stark contrasts between being a "nobody" and a "somebody" in society. She humorously likens being a "somebody" to a frog croaking for attention in front of an admiring bog. This comparison emphasizes the absurdity of seeking constant recognition and admiration.

Through a playful tone and whimsical language, Dickinson encourages the reader to question societal values and the relentless pursuit of recognition. The poem's childlike persona creates a sense of innocence and authenticity, reinforcing the idea that embracing one's true self, even if it means being a "nobody," can lead to genuine contentment.

Conclusion

Exploring appearances versus reality in poetry reveals the complexities of human existence and the societal pressures that compel individuals to wear metaphorical masks. "Richard Cory" by Edwin Arlington Robinson, "We Wear the Mask" by Paul Laurence Dunbar, and "I'm Nobody! Who are you?" by Emily Dickinson each provide unique perspectives on this theme.

Robinson's poem exposes the tragic consequences of misjudging appearances, highlighting the stark contrast between Richard Cory's external grandeur and internal despair. Dunbar's work delves into the societal mask-wearing phenomenon, depicting the emotional toll of concealing one's true emotions. Dickinson's playful exploration of being a "nobody" challenges societal norms, encouraging authenticity over conformity.

Through the use of poetic language, including imagery, metaphors, irony, and tone, these poems evoke a range of emotions in the reader—admiration, empathy, pride, and amusement. They serve as powerful reminders that beneath the veneer of appearances, the reality of human experience is often far more complex and nuanced.

In a world where judgments are swift and expectations are high, these poems compel us to pause and consider the authenticity of our own lives and the masks we may don to navigate society. They remind us that sometimes, it is the "nobodies" who embrace their true selves and find genuine contentment in a world obsessed with being "somebody."