To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
The dynamic between teachers and students is a complex and multifaceted aspect of the educational experience, explored in both Tom Wayman's poem "Students" and Mary Lawson's short story "Crow Lake." This essay delves into the nuanced portrayal of teacher-student relationships in these literary pieces, emphasizing the challenges faced by educators and the importance of fostering meaningful connections in the realm of education.
Tom Wayman's autobiographical poem, "Students," opens with a stark realization of the generation gap between the teacher and his students.
The shock expressed when Wayman questions the accuracy of the computer's assessment of his students' ages sets the tone for the struggle he faces in communicating with this younger generation (line 3). Despite this initial shock, Wayman demonstrates a deep respect for the wisdom of his students, emphasizing that their innate intelligence remains unchanged (lines 9-10).
Wayman employs metaphors such as "The Vaccination Theory of Education" and "The Dipstick Theory" to illustrate the diverse ways in which students absorb knowledge.
4.8 (309)
“ Writer-marian did a very good job with my paper, she got straight to the point, she made it clear and organized ”
The slightly satirical tone of the poem hints at the challenges posed by the generation gap, highlighting Wayman's ongoing battle to bridge the divide and engage students effectively. Through Wayman's lens, we gain insight into the complexities of teaching a generation with distinct motivations and learning styles.
In contrast, Mary Lawson's "Crow Lake" provides a narrative of a teacher's realization of her limitations. Lawson, more of a research expert than an experienced teacher, grapples with relating to her university students.
Through flashbacks, Lawson unveils her passion for nature, realizing that her students lack the same experiences, resulting in their indifference to her lesson (p14).
As Lawson acknowledges her role in boring her students, she takes a drastic step by leaving the lecture hall, suggesting a decision that might mark the end of her teaching career (p16). Unlike Wayman, Lawson confronts her shortcomings head-on, highlighting the significance of recognizing one's limitations as a teacher. The story illustrates the potential consequences when educators fail to connect with their students on a personal level.
Both texts underscore the inherent difficulty teachers face in relating to their students. In a world where education plays a pivotal role, these literary works emphasize the teacher's responsibility to be creative and inspirational. The mere act of assessing students with grades or presenting material in a monotonous manner falls short of the educator's duty to cultivate a passion for learning.
As Wayman perseveres in his attempts to bridge the generation gap and Lawson grapples with her limitations, the underlying message becomes clear: effective teaching goes beyond the conventional role of an instructor. It demands creativity, adaptability, and a genuine effort to understand and connect with students. The relationship between teachers and students is not merely transactional; it is a dynamic exchange that shapes the educational experience for both parties.
In conclusion, "Students" and "Crow Lake" provide nuanced explorations of the challenges inherent in teacher-student relationships. The generation gap, as depicted by Wayman, and the acknowledgment of limitations, as portrayed by Lawson, contribute to a broader understanding of the dynamics within the educational sphere. These literary works serve as reminders that the role of a teacher extends beyond the dissemination of information; it involves fostering connections, inspiring curiosity, and recognizing the individuality of each student.
Teacher-Student Relationships in Literary Works. (2016, Jul 21). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/grade-10-english-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
