To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Creation stories are intrinsic to various cultures, serving as foundational narratives that explain the origins of the world, the existence of higher powers, and the creation of humanity. In comparing the Christian belief in the Genesis story with the Iroquois creation myth, "The World on the Turtle's Back," intriguing similarities and profound contrasts emerge. This essay explores these differences in how the Native American Iroquois tribe and Christians perceive life, concepts of good and evil, their perspectives on nature, and the portrayal of their respective deities to humanity.
Both the Iroquois culture and the Christian faith acknowledge the dichotomy of good and evil, stemming from the concept of free will.
In the Iroquois myth, everyone is born with both good and evil within them, as represented by the "Left and Right" ruling the days (Iroquois 28; 29). Conversely, the Genesis story depicts humanity as initially pure and faultless, only succumbing to the allure of the forbidden tree through the woman's temptation and the man's subsequent choice to partake in disobedience (Genesis 3:1-24).
While the Iroquois emphasize a balance between forces, the Genesis narrative portrays a stark fall from perfection due to human disobedience.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Genesis
4.7 (657)
“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”
The Iroquois myth suggests a coexistence of opposing elements, whereas the Genesis story introduces the notion of original sin and the inherent imperfection of humanity.
The relationship between man and nature diverges significantly in the Iroquois culture and the Christian faith. The Iroquois, as reflected in their creation myth, view man and nature as equals.
Native Americans demonstrated deep respect for their territories, fostering relationships with animals instead of exploiting them for sustenance. The buffalo, for instance, was not merely a resource but a creature to be revered (Iroquois 30).
In contrast, the Genesis story grants man dominion over all creatures of the Earth (Genesis 1:28). This dominion has led to a historical pattern of exploitation, with mankind often hunting animals without the same reverence found in the Iroquois culture. This distinct perspective on nature profoundly influences the interactions between the respective cultures and their environments.
The portrayal of divine entities in the two narratives diverges significantly. In Christianity, there is a singular God, often depicted as a paternal figure. This God is both loving and just, as evidenced by His admonishment of disobedience in the Genesis story. The Christian God is associated with mercy but is also capable of delivering judgment to rectify human transgressions.
Conversely, the Iroquois culture features multiple gods, which eventually become elements in the natural world. The gods are revered and respected, and there is no explicit mention of punishment for human actions in the Iroquois myth. Both cultures share the belief that their deities or deity reside in a realm above the Earth – the Sky-World for the Iroquois and Heaven for Christians (Genesis 1:27; Iroquois 30).
In conclusion, the comparative analysis of the Genesis story and "The World on the Turtle's Back" reveals both shared themes and distinctive elements. Despite their differences, both narratives serve as foundational tales for their respective cultures, offering explanations for the origins of the world, humanity, and the intricacies of life.
The exploration of the duality of good and evil, the varying perspectives on nature, and the portrayal of deities reflects the cultural values and beliefs of the Native American Iroquois tribe and Christians. While the stories may diverge, their underlying purpose unites them – to provide meaning and understanding of the complex world in which each culture exists. Through these creation myths, we gain insights into the diverse ways in which human societies conceptualize their existence and relationships with the divine.
All Creation Tales: A Comparative Exploration. (2016, Dec 21). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/genesis-vs-iroquois-creation-myth-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
