To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
F. Scott Fitzgerald's masterpiece, The Great Gatsby, stands as an enduring American novel that has captivated generations with its exploration of thought-provoking issues and the portrayal of tragic pivotal characters. Two figures, Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby, both entwined in their love for Daisy, emerge as complex and intriguing individuals. While society perceives them differently, their similarities and tragic fates form a captivating study. This essay delves into their characters, comparing and contrasting their backgrounds, personalities, and the tragic elements that define them.
Jay Gatsby, born James Gatz in poverty, transforms himself into a wealthy and enigmatic figure.
His fear of others discovering his humble origins drives him to create a persona that aligns with his Platonic conception. Fitzgerald writes, "He was a son of God—a phrase which, if it means anything, means just that—and he must be about His Father’s business, the service of a vast, vulgar, and meretricious beauty" (p. 104).
Verified writer
Proficient in: Comparison
4.8 (309)
“ Writer-marian did a very good job with my paper, she got straight to the point, she made it clear and organized ”
Gatsby's tragic flaw lies in his unrelenting pursuit of a dream—winning back Daisy. His genuine love for her makes him a sympathetic character, and his tragic end leaves readers pondering the cost of unrequited love and the American Dream.
On the contrasting end of the spectrum is Tom Buchanan, a man born into wealth and privilege. His athletic prowess, fueled by opportunities to play sports, paints a different picture of privilege. However, beneath this exterior lies a man deeply flawed. Tom's racism and elitism, evident in his disdain for those he considers beneath him, including minorities and the less affluent, reveal a dark complexity.
His choice of literature, such as "The Rise of the Colored Empire," underlines his prejudiced worldview. Tom's tragedy lies in his moral decay, as he exploits his wealth and social standing, engaging in multiple affairs and perpetuating the cycle of infidelity.
The divergence in the backgrounds and education of Gatsby and Tom adds another layer to their complexity. Gatsby, born into poverty, attains his wealth through organized crime and bootlegging. His lack of a formal education does not diminish his intelligence, as evidenced by his strategic rise to affluence. In contrast, Tom Buchanan's wealth is inherited, providing him with a refined upbringing. Tom's education at Yale and graduation signify his privileged background, but his choices reveal a different kind of moral bankruptcy.
Gatsby's time at St. Olaf and later at Oxford showcases a different path, one where he sought education after serving in the war. While he didn't graduate, his self-made success and cunning illustrate a different form of intelligence. The juxtaposition of their educational journeys highlights societal expectations and the unconventional routes individuals may take to achieve success.
Both Gatsby and Tom share the tragic element of infidelity, entangled in relationships that contribute to their downfall. Gatsby's love for Daisy, though genuine, leads him to pursue her while she is still married to Tom. His willingness to overlook moral boundaries raises questions about the consequences of blind passion. Tom, on the other hand, engages in numerous affairs, demonstrating a disregard for the sanctity of marriage. The parallel tragedy lies in the destructive impact of their actions on the lives of those involved.
While Gatsby's yearning for Daisy is fueled by genuine love, the moral ambiguity of his pursuit raises ethical questions. Daisy's ultimate choice to remain with Tom, despite the dysfunctionality of their relationship, adds a layer of tragedy. The complexities of love, loyalty, and societal expectations intertwine to create a poignant narrative of human relationships.
In conclusion, The Great Gatsby unfolds as a tapestry of tragedy, weaving the fates of Jay Gatsby and Tom Buchanan into the fabric of American literature. Their complexities, shaped by societal expectations, personal choices, and the pursuit of the American Dream, contribute to the novel's enduring appeal. Gatsby's unfulfilled dream and Tom's moral decay resonate as cautionary tales, prompting reflection on the consequences of unchecked desires and societal expectations. Fitzgerald's portrayal of these characters transcends time, leaving readers with a profound exploration of the human condition.
Exploring Tragedy and Complexity in The Great Gatsby. (2016, Nov 10). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/comparisoncontrast-of-tom-buchanan-and-jay-gatsby-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
