Crack your assignment with step-by-step assignment guide
  • Step-by-step guide
  • List of credible sources
  • An outline of arguments

Analysis "On Being Human"

Categories: Being Human

C.S. Lewis gets straight to the point in his first lines, particularly with the very first 2 words ‘angelic minds.’ Readers will recognize instantly that Lewis is going to go over the idea of experience from the viewpoint of supernatural non-human beings such as angels. Readers may also guess, by comparing this concept to the poems title ‘On Being Human,’ that he means to go on to compare this concept with our experience of the world from the suggested lowliness of humanity’s viewpoint.

Students may wonder where the latter ramification originates from, and in this, at the start of the poem at least, C.S. Lewis is no aid at all in referring to a strange ‘they’ who obviously hold that angels use intelligence alone to comprehend the forms of nature, not needing the added senses taken pleasure in by more sensate humankind. Some readers may be advised here of the intense battles in between the angels and demons of Milton or the ‘arrows of desire’ of Blake.

Undoubtedly the nature of love and its forms was completely checked out and analysed in other places in the Four Enjoys by C.S. Lewis himself. As he details his argument in the next couple of lines, readers are left wondering which method Lewis is going to choose this.

They may question which dimension of experience the poet will state is finest – intelligence or sensory experience? Here, the idea of an enigma or puzzle offers the poem drive and suspense as students kept reading to find out what takes place next.

Top Writers
Dr. Karlyna PhD
Verified expert
4.7 (235)
Camilabach
Verified expert
5 (298)
Writer Jennie
Verified expert
4.8 (467)
hire verified writer

Initially C.S. Lewis provides, and continues to establish, the theory that those with purely spiritual, non sensual minds can unerringly recognize crucial ageless facts, ‘the verities’, through intelligence alone, without recourse to the five senses. People either absence knowledge of these facts or have come to learn them indirectly through the suggested less satisfactory ways of sensual experience. Facts of nature seem to be given specific weight by Lewis here as he informs readers of ‘earthness’ and ‘stoneness’ that can be perceived by angels from their clear uncluttered viewpoint – uncluttered by the expected inferior extraneous baggage of mortal sensate feelings and experiences.

Both in Lewis’s use of the word ‘unvarying’ and in his use of the word ‘unerringly’ in the opening lines, some readers may pick up echoes of the Roman Catholic belief in the infallibility of the Pope and the unwavering adherence to doctrine of the Roman Catholic church – even in the face of calls for relaxation and modernisation by common popular dissent. This serves to reinforce the notion of the fundamental nature of ancient truths. Being human, Lewis seems to ponder, may result in a clouding of the vision of fundamental principles by a veil or a muddled fog of distracting sensual experiences. It is at this point that the reader may perceive a divergence in Lewis’s view with that of the poets, theologians and philosophers of the ‘they’ in his initial lines. In his list of the understanding of the notion of ‘being,’ of existence, ‘being human’ is left out!

The angels appear to understand the scientific principles of the beauty of nature, the properties of a tree for example, or the evaporatory properties of the sea, but their achievements in the field of understanding human existence are not mentioned. C.S. Lewis then sketches, with exquisite delicacy, the human experience of the blissful coolness of shade as relief from the blistering unrelenting glare of the sun and, next, the severance of sun from shadow where the trees begin. This use of the word ‘severance’ also serves to mark the point where Lewis breaks faith temporarily with the ‘they’ of the first lines as he introduces humor, remarking that an angel has no skin and therefore (presumably) no conduit for the sense of touch.

Then follows a series of ravishing images, deftly painted by Lewis, of the ‘drinking-in’ of experiences of nature’s loveliness – such as the sweetness of a peach basking in the warmth of a sunlit wall or the delightfully natural fragrances of the countryside. Here Lewis picks up again the comical atmosphere that underlies the conversational narrative style of the poem, adding that angels are unable to appreciate the delights of the fragrance of the field, new mown hay, the sea smells and the therapeutic incense of wood smoke. With humor he bluntly posits that an angel has no nose!

The poet then appears to struggle between two possibilities – firstly that angels get the best deal as they are not burdened with the five confusing senses. Conversely, he wonders whether humans are the better off of the two beings. After all, they are guarded from the shock of perceiving the whole of existence ‘the heavens’ at once, because mankind’s distracting senses obscure the truth of it.

Crucially, in terms of understanding Lewis’s own opinion on the subject, the poet draws attention to the way in which God himself may want us to have one small area of our personalities devoted to appreciating the environment through our senses. Perhaps in so doing we are the better able to comprehend the sheer scale of the wonders of nature and sense that He has provided for our happiness. The angels with their cold intelligence may be unable to profoundly appreciate, thank and love God to the full. Indeed, some lines from the Roman Catholic church service, ‘The Mass’, may spring to mind when reflecting upon the benefits this ‘being human’ has in our relationship with God – the lines refer to a Christ ‘who humbled himself to share in our humanity.’ As Lewis puts it, we ‘share a privacy that is forever ours, not theirs.’

Cite this page

Analysis "On Being Human". (2016, May 04). Retrieved from http://studymoose.com/analysis-on-being-human-essay

Are You on a Short Deadline? Let a Professional Expert Help You
HELP ME WITH WRITING
Let’s chat?  We're online 24/7