To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Speeches are a powerful medium for conveying messages, emotions, and ideas to a wide audience. In this essay, we will analyze two contrasting speeches: George W. Bush's address to the American nation in the wake of the 9/11 terrorist attacks and Leonardo DiCaprio's impromptu speech during the 2016 Oscars. These speeches serve different purposes – Bush's speech aimed to reassure and unite the American people during a national crisis, while DiCaprio's speech sought to raise awareness about climate change. We will employ the rhetorical technique of antithesis to examine these speeches in-depth.
George W. Bush's speech, delivered just twelve hours after the tragic 9/11 terrorist attacks, remains an iconic moment in American history. His posture, attire, and location all conveyed strength and authority, essential for a world leader. Bush's initial calm and empathetic tone acknowledged the gravity of the situation, establishing a connection with the audience that had just suffered a profound loss.
Bush's speech effectively utilizes Pathos to connect with the audience emotionally.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Persuasive Speech
4.7 (235)
“ Amazing writer! I am really satisfied with her work. An excellent price as well. ”
He employs antithesis in the statement, "terrorist attacks can shake the foundation of our biggest buildings, but they cannot touch the foundation of America." This metaphorical expression reinforces the idea that while physical structures may have been destroyed, the spirit and dreams of America remain unbreakable. This emotional resonance fosters a sense of unity and resilience among the American people.
The speech also incorporates Logos, as Bush provides factual information to highlight the urgency and tragedy of the situation. He vividly describes the events with phrases like "pictures of airplanes flying into buildings, first burning - huge structures collapsing," emphasizing the shocking reality of the attacks.
Furthermore, Bush's mention of implementing the government's emergency plan reassures the audience of his prompt and professional response, building trust.
Bush appeals to Ethos by emphasizing American values, freedom, and human dignity. He underscores these principles when he speaks about the nation's shared ethics. The frequent use of "our" as a personal pronoun underscores the collective suffering and determination of the American people. This rhetorical strategy reinforces a sense of unity and shared responsibility (Crutcher, 2012).
Throughout his speech, Bush employs analogies and metaphors to convey his message effectively. The phrase "we are the brightest beacon for freedom, and no one will keep that light from shining" presents America as a symbol of hope and opportunity. The analogy of America as a bright beacon underscores the message that even in the face of tragedy, hope endures. The metaphor "These acts shattered steel, but they cannot dent the steel of American resolve" serves to remind the attackers that they cannot undermine the core values and beliefs of America, which include peace and the pursuit of dreams.
Bush's speech employs various persuasive techniques. He uses propaganda, mentioning terms like 'military' and 'federal agents,' to reassure the audience that measures are in place to protect the nation. Imagery is also utilized when he says, "the pictures of airplanes flying into buildings," painting a vivid mental picture of the horrific events. By including a Bible verse, Psalm 23, Bush provides comfort and taps into the audience's emotions, invoking the concept of facing adversity with faith (Chambers, 2012).
Stylistically, Bush's speech features alliteration, as seen in phrases like "mass murder," "biggest buildings," and "brightest beacon." These repetitions create a sense of rhythm and emphasize key points. Repetition is also used, with words like "freedom" and "foundation" reinforcing the speech's central themes.
In conclusion, George W. Bush's speech following the 9/11 attacks effectively employed various rhetorical techniques to unite, reassure, and inspire the American people. It appealed to their emotions, logic, and ethics, fostering a sense of resilience and shared responsibility. The use of metaphors, analogies, and persuasive techniques further strengthened the speech's impact.
In contrast to Bush's carefully planned address, Leonardo DiCaprio's speech at the 2016 Oscars was spontaneous and unexpected. DiCaprio's purpose was twofold: to express gratitude for winning an Oscar and to raise awareness about climate change.
DiCaprio's speech begins with gratitude, a customary aspect of award acceptance speeches. He expresses thanks to fellow actor Tom Hardy using personal pronouns like "brother," evoking emotions and pathos. His expressions of gratitude to his parents and friends are laden with emotive language, aligning with the expectations of an award ceremony.
The second part of DiCaprio's speech shifts to Logos and Ethos, focusing on climate change. He uses facts to inform the audience about the alarming reality, stating, "the world collectively felt in 2015 as the hottest year in recorded history." This logical appeal is bolstered by references to "billions and billions of underprivileged people," appealing to the audience's sense of ethics and empathy. The repetition of emotive language in this part of the speech underscores his message (Hoffman, 2016).
DiCaprio's passion for the climate change cause becomes evident in his speech, especially when he discusses environmental issues. His voice becomes slightly louder, and he emphasizes words like "urgent" to convey the importance of the issue. The stress on the word 'children' when he says, "for our children's children," highlights his concern for future generations and aligns the audience with his message (Hanley, 2016).
In conclusion, Leonardo DiCaprio's spontaneous Oscars speech served dual purposes: expressing gratitude for his award and raising awareness about climate change. Through the use of emotive language, Logos, and Ethos, he effectively engaged the audience's emotions and intellect. His passion and commitment to the climate change cause were palpable, inspiring the audience to consider their role in addressing this global issue.
Both George W. Bush's 9/11 speech and Leonardo DiCaprio's Oscars speech employed rhetorical techniques to achieve their respective goals. Bush's speech aimed to unite and reassure a nation in crisis, while DiCaprio's speech sought to inspire action on climate change.
Bush's speech relied heavily on Pathos, emphasizing emotions and shared values to foster unity and resolve. It used metaphors, analogies, and persuasive techniques to convey the message of American resilience effectively. In contrast, DiCaprio's speech balanced gratitude with a call to action, employing Logos and Ethos to convey the urgency of climate change.
In terms of delivery, Bush maintained a strong and authoritative demeanor throughout, while DiCaprio's spontaneous and heartfelt speech showcased his genuine passion for the climate change cause. Both speeches effectively connected with their audiences and left a lasting impact.
Speeches are powerful tools for conveying messages and inspiring action. George W. Bush's response to 9/11 and Leonardo DiCaprio's Oscars speech serve as compelling examples of effective communication in different contexts. Bush's speech united a nation in crisis, while DiCaprio's speech raised awareness about a pressing global issue. By employing rhetorical techniques and appealing to the emotions, logic, and ethics of their respective audiences, both speeches achieved their intended goals, leaving a lasting impression on their listeners.
Comparison of George W. Bush's Response to 9/11 and Leonardo DiCaprio's Oscars Speech. (2021, Sep 10). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/a-comparison-between-the-speeches-of-george-bush-and-leonardo-dicaprio-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
