To install StudyMoose App tap and then “Add to Home Screen”
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Alfie Kohn, along with Nel Noddings, a professor emerita at Stanford University, shares their perspectives on the misconception of what defines a "well-educated person." The concept of a well-educated individual varies widely among people. In this essay, we will explore the notion of being well-educated based on Alfie Kohn's work in "What Does it Mean to be Well-Educated," examine insights from religious perspectives on a well-educated person, and reflect on personal experiences to formulate a comprehensive definition of a well-educated person.
The question of what constitutes being well-educated prompts us to delve into the intricacies of knowledge acquisition and the educational process.
Is being well-educated solely about possessing a vast amount of knowledge? What exactly is knowledge?
Alfie Kohn's observation, "Thanks to the internet, which allows writers and researchers to circulate rough drafts of their manuscripts, I've come to realize just how many truly brilliant people cannot spell or punctuate," challenges conventional notions of being well-educated.
Verified writer
Proficient in: Education
4.9 (247)
“ Rhizman is absolutely amazing at what he does . I highly recommend him if you need an assignment done ”
Similarly, personal experiences have led me to question whether being well-educated necessitates proficiency in areas like spelling and mathematics. Throughout my academic journey, I have often felt pressured to excel in subjects deemed essential, while my strengths in literature and art were undervalued.
Coming from a family of academically accomplished siblings, I constantly found myself comparing my own achievements. My mother graduated from high school at the age of 16, and all my siblings achieved consistently high grades. This pressure to perform academically raises important questions: Is the pursuit of good grades synonymous with genuine knowledge acquisition? Can a person be considered brilliant even if they struggle with what are commonly regarded as basic skills?
To discern the essence of being well-educated, it is essential to differentiate between knowledge and the state of being well-educated. Knowledge can be defined as "acquaintance with facts, truth, or principles, as from study or investigation; general erudition," while being well-educated signifies having undergone a structured educational process.
It is crucial to recognize that knowledge is built upon the accumulation of facts, principles, and truths acquired through study, investigation, or direct experience with a subject. In contrast, being well-educated reflects the culmination of a formal educational journey. While anyone can attend school and gain fragmented knowledge on various topics, the depth of understanding and practical application of that knowledge is what sets apart a well-educated individual.
Alfie Kohn asserts, "The best sort of schooling is organized around problems, projects, and questions – as opposed to facts, skills, and disciplines." This perspective emphasizes the importance of an education that fosters critical thinking and problem-solving abilities over rote memorization of facts. My personal experience in struggling with certain subjects, like mathematics, highlights the significance of effective teaching methods in facilitating genuine comprehension and learning.
In my high school years, I faced challenges in mathematics, a subject many of my classmates also struggled with. Our mathematics teacher, Ms. Faustino, hailed from the Philippines and came from a cultural background where math and science were taught rigorously from a young age. This cultural difference posed a barrier to effective teaching and understanding. Ms. Faustino's teaching style, coupled with language barriers, made it difficult for us to grasp mathematical concepts.
Despite our struggles, we persevered, but not without facing ethical dilemmas. Many students resorted to cheating to cope with the demanding curriculum. However, I refrained from cheating due to a strong sense of ethics and the fear of getting caught. Consequently, my grades in mathematics accurately reflected my understanding of the subject. But does this imply that I was less well-educated than my peers who resorted to cheating?
Another subject that challenged me during my middle school years was science, taught by a teacher from India. Her teaching method involved extensive note-taking and memorization, which deviated from the traditional teaching approach I was accustomed to. The emphasis on verbatim answers from our notes left little room for understanding.
Initially, I struggled to adapt to this teaching style, as I was used to comprehending concepts rather than rote memorization. It was not until later in my ninth-grade year that I succumbed to memorization, as it seemed the only way to meet the strict grading criteria. This transition from understanding to memorization raises the question: Does the ability to memorize facts, rather than truly understanding them, diminish one's status as a well-educated individual?
Alfie Kohn's assertion that "no single test is sufficiently valid, reliable, or meaningful that it can be treated as a marker for academic success" underscores the limitations of assessing education solely based on test scores. It implies that a holistic evaluation of an individual's education should consider factors beyond mere memorization of facts.
One's ability to apply knowledge in practical situations and derive wisdom from it is a crucial aspect of being well-educated. This is particularly relevant when examining the religious perspective on a well-educated person.
Proverbs 1:7 states, "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge, but fools despise wisdom and discipline." This verse emphasizes the importance of understanding the foundational principles and teachings of one's faith as the starting point of knowledge. It suggests that knowledge should not be acquired blindly but should be rooted in wisdom and discipline.
Furthermore, Proverbs 1:8-19 elaborates on the significance of parental teachings and adherence to the Word of God in the pursuit of knowledge. Those who fail to build a solid foundation of understanding and principles may be susceptible to false beliefs and misguided actions. Thus, knowledge without wisdom and discernment may lead to naivety rather than true education.
Therefore, to be considered well-educated, one must not merely accumulate facts but must also understand, interpret, and apply their knowledge in a thoughtful and discerning manner. Knowledge should serve as a basis for personal growth and ethical decision-making, rather than mere accumulation of information.
In conclusion, the definition of a well-educated person is a multifaceted concept that encompasses various dimensions of knowledge acquisition and application. While traditional education may emphasize rote memorization and test scores, being well-educated transcends these parameters.
From my perspective, a truly well-educated individual is one who possesses knowledge and wisdom, gained through study, experience, and practical application. It is someone who can critically evaluate information, understand its significance, and apply it to real-life situations. This definition acknowledges that the pursuit of knowledge is an ongoing process that extends beyond the classroom.
However, it is essential to recognize that the definition of a well-educated person is subjective and can vary from person to person. There is no universal standard for being well-educated, as learning is a continuous journey, and individuals evolve with each new experience and insight.
In essence, the quest for education should not be confined to meeting specific criteria but should be a lifelong endeavor aimed at continuous growth, understanding, and application of knowledge. Being well-educated is not a destination but a never-ending journey of intellectual and personal development.
Examining What Defines a Well-Educated Person. (2020, Jun 02). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/whats-definition-well-educated-new-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
