Assessing School Impact in Literary and Cinematic Narratives

The educational landscape, as depicted in literature and film, often serves as a canvas reflecting society's perceptions and challenges. In this reflection, we will delve into the contrasting views of school presented in the article "The Fun They Had" and the movie "A Beautiful Mind." Both works converge on a common theme — a critical examination of the educational system, highlighting its impact on students' creativity and individuality.

Negative Portrayal of School

School, as defined by societal norms, is an institution designed to impart knowledge and shape the future success of students.

However, both "The Fun They Had" and "A Beautiful Mind" cast a critical eye on this conventional view, presenting a narrative that skews towards the negative. The passage of years and progression through higher grades erodes students' individuality and stifles their ability to be imaginative and creative.

The central contention is that schools, in their attempt to streamline education, inadvertently dull the minds of students by enforcing rigid rubrics. These rubrics, created by the education system, limit students' capacity to take risks and produce something unique.

Get quality help now
Marrie pro writer
Marrie pro writer
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Creativity

star star star star 5 (204)

“ She followed all my directions. It was really easy to contact her and respond very fast as well. ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

The consequence is a stifled environment where conformity is rewarded, and deviation is penalized with low marks.

Impact on Students' Lives

As we examine how school affects the lives of students, it's essential to consider the broader context of contemporary influences. In today's world, students navigate through a maze of media and societal pressures, with school often taking a backseat in their minds. However, as students progress into higher grades, the educational journey becomes more arduous and stressful.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Topic
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

The increasing difficulty is attributed to the inflexible nature of the rubrics imposed by the education system, leaving students with little room for creativity and authentic expression.

Quoting John Nash, "Classes will dull your mind, destroy the potential for authentic creativity." Here, the creativity-killing effect of school is emphasized, suggesting that modern essays prioritize adherence to rubrics over imaginative expression. The analogy of schools being akin to jails, with students as unwilling prisoners, reinforces the idea that the educational system dictates what students must do, regardless of personal preference.

Teacher's Role in Fostering Creativity

The role of teachers in shaping students' educational experiences emerges as a critical aspect of the analysis. There is a distinction between teachers who merely follow traditional teaching methods and those who encourage students to think beyond the conventional boundaries.

An illustration from "A Beautiful Mind" showcases John Nash's disdain for textbooks, symbolizing the boundaries they impose on learning. He advocates for thinking outside the box, challenging students to explore new horizons beyond the limitations of prescribed content. This stance aligns with the assertion that teachers who promote innovative thinking deserve an opportunity to shape the educational narrative.

Another example from "The Fun They Had" contrasts a human teacher with a robotic one. While a human teacher may engage students to think creatively, a robotic teacher represents a mechanical, rule-based approach to education. The variance in teaching styles emphasizes the pivotal role teachers play in either fostering or stifling creativity in students.

Student's Responsibility in Education

Students also bear responsibility for their educational journey. Blaming the system or teachers for academic challenges is unjustified if students do not invest their best effort. The narrative shifts to students taking charge of their education and making conscious decisions to seek help and put in the required effort.

Students need to do their utmost, even in subjects that may not initially appeal to them. It highlights the example of a biology student compelled to attend a math class due to its compulsory nature. The student's dedication to learning, despite the initial struggle, is presented as a testament to personal responsibility and the importance of striving for excellence.

Compulsory Courses and Future Relevance

An exploration of compulsory courses and their potential relevance in future situations is integral to the analysis. Mandatory courses are designed with future applicability in mind. It acknowledges that while students may find certain subjects challenging, the compulsory nature ensures a foundational understanding that may prove essential in unforeseen circumstances.

An example from "The Fun They Had" amplifies this point. Margie's disdain for geography, a compulsory subject, showcases the struggles students face when compelled to engage with material that does not align with their interests. Such experiences are a result of a broader systemic design aiming to equip students with essential skills for their future.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the comparative analysis of "The Fun They Had" and "A Beautiful Mind" unravels a complex interplay between students, teachers, and the education system. The negative portrayal of school is a recurring theme, emphasizing the need for a balance between structured education and fostering creativity. The responsibility lies not only with the system but also with students who must actively engage in their education, seek help when needed, and embrace the challenges that pave the way for a holistic and enriching learning experience.

Updated: Jan 17, 2024
Cite this page

Assessing School Impact in Literary and Cinematic Narratives. (2016, Nov 05). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/the-fun-they-had-vs-a-beautiful-mind-essay

Assessing School Impact in Literary and Cinematic Narratives essay
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment