Legalizing Organ Sales: A Lifesaving Initiative

Essay, Pages 3 (714 words)

Views

3349

Legalizing Organ Sales: A Lifesaving Initiative

In her compelling essay, "Organ Sales Will Save Lives," Joanna MacKay explores the critical issue of kidney failure and advocates for the legalization, rather than the prohibition, of the sale of human organs. According to MacKay's thesis, governments should regulate organ sales instead of banning them, with the primary objective of saving lives (92). The essay delves into the complex landscape of organ transplants, examining the ethical, economic, and humanitarian dimensions surrounding this contentious topic.

The Urgent Need for Legalizing Organ Sales

Kidney failure is a dire health concern affecting approximately 350,000 Americans annually.

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get your custom essay on

“ Legalizing Organ Sales: A Lifesaving Initiative ”

Get custom paper

NEW! smart matching with writer

MacKay emphasizes the urgency of the situation, asserting that legalizing organ sales would significantly alleviate the strain on the healthcare system and potentially save thousands of lives (92). Currently, individuals facing organ failure encounter challenges in accessing suitable donors due to legal restrictions. MacKay argues that by legalizing and regulating organ sales, more people would be incentivized to contribute their kidneys, thereby increasing the organ supply and addressing the growing demand for life-saving transplants (94).

MacKay draws attention to the existence of a black market for kidneys, where desperate individuals pay exorbitant amounts, often facilitated by unscrupulous brokers exploiting the vulnerable. Legalization, she contends, would eliminate this illicit trade, ensuring fair compensation for donors and preventing the exploitation of the financially distressed (93). The author underscores the ethical imperative of providing a legal framework that protects the rights and well-being of all parties involved in the organ transplantation process.

The Morality and Economics of Organ Donation

MacKay explores the moral aspects of organ donation, highlighting the selfless individuals who willingly donate organs out of altruism.

However, she acknowledges that the current system leaves donors without any compensation, while hospitals and medical professionals profit from organ transplant operations. To address this imbalance, MacKay suggests government intervention to regulate and ensure that donors receive fair financial compensation for their life-saving contributions. By doing so, the author argues, more individuals would be motivated to become donors, ultimately increasing the availability of organs for transplantation.

Furthermore, MacKay contends that the government's involvement would not only establish a fair compensation system but also streamline the entire organ transplantation process. Legalizing and regulating organ sales would enable authorities to implement comprehensive oversight, ensuring the safety and well-being of both donors and recipients. This, she argues, would be a more effective way to manage organ transplantation compared to the current system, plagued by the dangers of the black market and inadequate organ supply (93).

Addressing Concerns and Enhancing Control

While acknowledging the potential concerns associated with the legalization of organ sales, MacKay proposes that governmental regulation would mitigate these issues. She emphasizes that the financial gains from legal transactions could be substantial, with donors potentially receiving up to $25,000. This not only provides a powerful incentive for individuals to become donors but also contributes to the economic aspects of organ transplantation, benefitting both donors and the healthcare system as a whole.

MacKay counters potential opposition by asserting that the government's regulatory role would bring about a more controlled and organized system. Unlike the chaotic and dangerous black market, a legalized and regulated organ trade would ensure transparency, traceability, and adherence to ethical standards. The author persuasively argues that the benefits of legalizing organ sales far outweigh the risks, offering a practical solution to the organ shortage crisis and preventing the exploitation of vulnerable individuals (93).

Conclusion: A Call for Reform

In conclusion, Joanna MacKay's essay presents a compelling case for the legalization and regulation of organ sales as a means to save lives. By addressing the pressing issue of kidney failure and the challenges associated with organ transplantation, MacKay advocates for a paradigm shift in current policies. Legalizing organ sales, she argues, would not only increase the availability of organs but also establish a fair and ethical framework that protects the rights of all involved parties.

MacKay's essay, while passionately advocating for her position, invites further exploration of opposing views to enrich the discourse on this complex issue. Nevertheless, her well-supported arguments, backed by statistics and a thorough analysis of the current state of organ transplantation, make a compelling case for the urgent need to reconsider existing regulations. Legalizing organ sales under government regulation emerges as a viable solution to address the organ shortage crisis and save countless lives.