Bottom Up Approach Of Urban Planning Environmental Sciences Essay

Some developing states like India and China have adopted the 'bottom-up attack ' in urban planning, work outing the urban jobs faced by their metropoliss. The ground of the outgrowth of this phenomenon was obvious that the cardinal authoritiess of the developing provinces need to pay more attending to hike the state 's economic system while metropoliss of the provinces are still confronting a batch of urban jobs like hapless life environment, hapless public substructure, deficiency of lodging, over-crowding, pollutions or even widespread poorness.

'Bottom-up attack of urban be aftering ' by and large means that local authoritiess or commissions formed by local citizens are responsible for urban planning of their ain territories, work outing the urban jobs and be aftering their hereafter development, and therefore the territories link together to do the whole state or part become more developed. In this paper, advantages and disadvantages of the attack will be covered and illustrations of metropoliss in developing states like China and India will be cited before holding the concluding decision.

Get quality help now

Dr. Karlyna PhD

Verified writer

Proficient in: Environment

4.7 (235)

“ Amazing writer! I am really satisfied with her work. An excellent price as well. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

It can non be denied that the 'bottom-up attack ' is more 'man-centered ' than the authoritative 'Top-down attack ' which means the territories need to follow the guidelines and instructions of the cardinal authorities to develop. Besides, the voices of the citizens can be listened during the policy devising and planning of the hereafter development of the territories. Decision devising is faster and despairing and serious jobs of territories could be alleviated or solved in a shorter clip.

AR.UTTAM K.ROY ( 2009 ) had a research on West Bengal in India and wrote a study called 'Integration of Top down and Bottom up attack in Urban and Regional Planning: West Bengal Experience of Draft Development Plans ( DDP ) and beyond ' . Harmonizing to the study, West Bengal enacted the West Bengal Municipal Act in 1993 to deconcentrate spacial and socio-economic planning of different territories. Municipalities and municipal corporations are required to fix the Draft Development Plans of five old ages. AR.UTTAM K.ROY ( 2009 ) found that DDP could truly affect people in 'the job designation, prioritization and proof of the program ' and despairing and serious urban jobs faced by the people were alleviated.

Besides, 'Bottom-up attack ' could cut down the load of the cardinal authorities and more cardinal resources could be used for macro-economic development. As mentioned by P.K. Mohanty ( 1999 ) , the Director of Ministry of Urban Affairs and Employment of New Delhi in India, in a book chapter, 'Decentralization Reforms and Innovations in Municipal Management in India ' , ' Decentralization, if pursued decently, is likely to give assorted benefits, including: ... ..freeing of cardinal resources for macroeconomic concerns such as stabilisation, structural accommodation, and poorness relief. '

On the territory degree, local resources could be exploited and allocated better. Therefore, the efficiency of service bringing could be improved. Besides, as citizens have a greater opportunity to affect in urban planning and determination of policies, grass-root democracy could be promoted. As their sentiments could be listened and accepted and societal jobs could be solved, societal stableness can besides be raised. Stable and peaceable society benefits the development of local economic system.

However, such planning attack besides has some disadvantages. Firstly, some long-run planning can non be drawn up sometimes. When local people can acquire involved in urban policy devising, they may merely concentrate on the issues related to the immediate demands of citizens. Harmonizing to the book 'Planning from the underside up ' written by professor Anirban Pal ( 2008 ) of Delft University of Technology and the repor by AR.UTTAM K.ROY ( 2009 ) metropoliss which used the 'bottom-up attack ' , the local planning organisations or commissions like the territories in West Bengal in India can seldom come up with the development undertakings for future residential growing or future spacial land usage programs. And little scale undertakings like opening up of green infinite, creative activity of wellness centres, beautification of Parkss remain the bulk of the work of the local commissions and organisations. Therefore, some professionals doubt that whether the 'bottom-up attack ' is a good urban planning method for metropoliss ' sustainable development or non. In fact, the deficiency of long-run program of the development of the metropolis and spacial land usage programs would do the land usage form of the metropoliss become helter-skelter, raising other sorts of societal jobs and impeding the long-run development of the metropoliss.

Second, the 'bottom-up attack ' can take to competitions between different territories within metropoliss which can ensue in societal instability. Professor Anirban Pal ( 2008 ) used Beijing, the capital of China, as an illustration in his book ' Planing from the underside up ' . Different territories in Beijing are now seeking to transport out different policies to raise their ain attraction for foreign investings. The territory degree authoritiess compete in transporting out widespread renovation and forced evictions. This has led to societal agitation in Beijing. Therefore, it can be seen that 'bottom-up ' attack may take to societal instability if territory degree authoritiess are excessively ambitious.

Third, the procedure of be aftering would non be genuinely 'bottom-up ' if the local territory power is concentrated in the custodies of one political organisation and there are few channels for the local citizens to acquire involved in the planning procedure. Such job can be found in Kolkata harmonizing to V.Ramaswamy. The governing party in Kolkata has great power and high societal position and therefore there is no effectual resistance to it. And the governing party control the urban policy devising and planning and local citizens do non hold so much opportunity to acquire involved in the planning procedure.In this instance, the procedure of planning is non truly 'bottom-up ' to a big extent. This besides shows that the planning organisations should be independent of the opinion parties. If non, the 'bottom-up attack ' can ne'er be truly effectual.

Furthermore, there is a job of deficiency of expertness in LDCs. It is non uncommon that citizens of LDCs do non keep a high instruction degree. Although local citizens have the rights in be aftering the development and the land uses of the metropoliss, most of them do non hold the professional cognition in the country of urban planning and urban policy. Just like in India the instruction degree is low, more than 140,000,000 people do non hold primary educational degree and merely approximately 400,000 people have received third instruction degree. Therefore, it is really hard to vouch the programs drawn up by the local organisations without expertness are long-run programs which can profit the growing and development of the metropoliss. The local groups may merely concern about the immediate demands of the local people, pretermiting environmental preservation and long-run socio-economic development.

From the above, it can be seen that the 'bottom-up attack ' besides has certain restrictions and such attack may even harms the long-run development of the metropoliss in LDCs. However, it is really obvious that the urban jobs faced by citizens in LDCs can non be solved easy by the traditional Top-down attack as the cardinal authorities may concentrate on the development of whole state instead than territory issues and it is really difficult for the cardinal authorities to acknowledge every territory issues. Therefore, it seems the bottom-up attack is the most effectual method to work out the immediate issues in the territories and fulfill the demands of the local people. Furthermore, if the local immediate jobs like poorness, hapless life environment could non be solved, the development of whole state would be hindered.

To set it merely, the 'bottom-up attack ' is a good urban planning method for LDCs when undertaking the urban jobs in the territories but non so good for farther development. In order to accomplish sustainable development, metropoliss of LDCs should follow an attack which consists the elements of 'Top-down attack ' and 'bottom-up attack ' .This means the authorities can put up general guidelines and instructions for the territories to follow while allowing them adequate freedom and resources in undertaking local personal businesss and pulling up programs of future development. Besides, Kurian Joseph, R. Nagendran ( 2007 ) and Kumar. SA Jay ( 2007 ) recommended in their documents, Top-down And Bottom-Up Approach For Sustainability Of Waste Management In Developing Countries ' and 'Participatory Spatial Planning A Model from Kollam District ' , espectively that groups of multi skill professional should prosecute in the procedure of planning and undertaking urban jobs. In fact, undertaking issues like environmental jobs particularly needs the battle of the professionals.

What 's more, in order to ease the urban planning procedure, the cardinal authorities should ordain Torahs to curtail the engagement of politicians like members of governing parties and authorities functionaries in local urban planning, educate the populace and raise their consciousness on the urban jobs around them and get down present the construct of sustainable development to the communities.

For the general development of whole state, cardinal authorities should supervise the development of different territories and avoid barbarous competition between the territories which may take to societal agitation. When barbarous competition emerges, cardinal authorities should step in in order to do the political scene and society stable. However, it should be noted that the province authorities should non step in so much if there is no barbarous competition between metropoliss. Harmonizing to the paper which is called 'Vision 2021: Urban Governance in India by Dinesh Mehta ( 1999 ) , the province authorities should step in 'as small as possible ' if the metropoliss develop in a right manner.

All in all, the bottom-up attack is a good urban planning method which can truly turn to the jobs faced by the local citizens of LDCs. But the authoritative 'Top-down attack ' still can non be forgotten as it is good for metropoliss ' farther development. Therefore, an attack which integrates both attacks would be a suited manner for metropoliss of LCDs to accomplish sustainable development.