Sacrifice and Regret in Willa Cather's "A Wagner Matinee"

Throughout the 1800s, the Great Plains witnessed a surge in immigration, driven by the promise of free land offered through the Homestead Act. Families and individuals embarked on arduous journeys to seek their fortunes and establish new homes in what was once deemed the great American desert. This westward migration brought with it profound sacrifices, as people left behind their old lives to embrace the uncertainties of the frontier. Willa Cather's short story, "A Wagner Matinee," offers a poignant exploration of sacrifice, particularly through the character of Aunt Georgiana.

Her journey from Boston to the Nebraska frontier serves as a compelling illustration of the theme that sometimes choices demand sacrifices, and one love may need to be relinquished for another.

Characterizing Aunt Georgiana

Willa Cather employs characterization to delve into the theme of sacrifice in "A Wagner Matinee." The story immediately introduces Aunt Georgiana as a woman of remarkable accomplishment—a pianist who once held a prestigious position as an instructor at the Boston Conservatory of Music.

Get quality help now

KarrieWrites

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

5 (339)

“ KarrieWrites did such a phenomenal job on this assignment! He completed it prior to its deadline and was thorough and informative. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

It's crucial to appreciate the significance of this achievement, considering the time period in which the story is set. In an era where women's opportunities were often limited, Georgiana's status as a music instructor was extraordinary. The music she had to forsake was undoubtedly a deep source of passion and pride.

However, the physical descriptions of Aunt Georgiana reveal the toll that her sacrifices have taken on her. Her skin is described as yellow and leathery, a testament to the harsh conditions and hardships she endured on the Nebraska frontier.

Ill-fitting false teeth further emphasize the physical toll of her new life. Yet, it is her hands that bear the most striking testimony to her sacrifices. Once the skilled hands of a pianist, they have been transformed into twisted, knot-like appendages with fingers contorted in unusual angles. This repeated imagery of her hands serves as a powerful symbol of the sacrifices she made, as her hands were the very essence of her musical identity.

Aunt Georgiana's Words of Regret

Georgiana's statements throughout the story provide valuable insights into her profound sense of regret and sacrifice. There is a poignant moment when she opens her heart to her nephew, Clark, and imparts a solemn piece of advice: "Don't love it so well, Clark, or it may be taken from you. Oh! Dear boy, pray that whatever your sacrifice be, it is not that." In this moment, she refers to her cherished music, offering a profoundly pessimistic perspective. Her painful experience of forsaking her life's ambition lingers in her words, urging Clark not to become too attached to his own passions, fearing they may suffer a similar fate.

Another conversation between Clark and Georgiana during the concert reveals her deep remorse. She references the music they are currently enjoying, asking Clark, "And you've been hearing this ever since you left me, Clark?" Her question carries a weight of gentle reproach, hinting at a sense of longing and nostalgia that she cannot escape. Her wistful remembrance is palpable through her words, conveying the immense regret she harbors.

As the concert draws to a close, Aunt Georgiana can no longer contain her emotions. She bursts into tears, crying out, "I don't want to go, Clark, I don't want to go!" This raw outpouring of emotion serves as a direct and poignant example of the profound longing she feels for the music she sacrificed. Her yearning is undeniably intense and heartbreaking.

Actions Speak Louder Than Words

Aunt Georgiana's actions throughout the story provide a deeper insight into her theme of sacrifice and regret. Having spent thirty years isolated on a Nebraska farm, her return to the city is far from a seamless transition. She arrives in a near-trance-like state, disconnected from the bustling urban life she once knew. It is only the music that reconnects her to that world. As soon as the concert begins, her hand instinctively reaches out and clutches Clark's coat sleeve. She maintains this grasp until the conclusion of the song. This physical reaction demonstrates how deeply music still influences her, serving as a bridge between her past and present.

Throughout the concert, Aunt Georgiana is transported into a realm of memories and emotions. She even pantomimes playing a piano on her dress, reminiscing about her days at the conservatory. These actions clearly illustrate the significance of the music she left behind. The passion and love she once had for her art remain undiminished, despite decades spent on a harsh frontier. Through these actions, Cather skillfully conveys the depth of Georgiana's sacrifice.

Conclusion

Aunt Georgiana's characterization in Willa Cather's "A Wagner Matinee" serves as a poignant portrayal of sacrifice and regret. Her journey from the world of music and culture in Boston to the rugged Nebraska frontier highlights the choices individuals sometimes face when pursuing their dreams and ambitions. Cather's storytelling, characterized by rich physical descriptions, heartfelt conversations, and meaningful actions, effectively conveys the theme that sacrifices are often necessary in life, and one's deepest passions may need to be surrendered for the sake of other commitments.

Georgiana's story is not unique, as countless individuals in history and in contemporary life grapple with similar dilemmas. The story of her sacrifice serves as a reminder that life often demands difficult choices, and the weight of those decisions can leave enduring marks. Through Aunt Georgiana's character, Cather reminds us of the complexities of human existence and the bittersweet nature of sacrifice.

In conclusion, "A Wagner Matinee" by Willa Cather remains a timeless exploration of the theme of sacrifice and its profound impact on the human experience. The character of Aunt Georgiana, with her sacrifices and regrets, serves as a compelling representation of the choices people make when navigating the often tumultuous journey of life. Through careful characterization and storytelling, Cather delivers a powerful message about the enduring nature of love, longing, and the sacrifices we make along the way.