The Moral Education Between Public School And An Islamic Boarding School

Categories: Education


This article describes the moral education between public school and an Islamic boarding school. Actually, Applying moral education in this era is not easy the teacher must make a rule or educate their students to keep the behaviour in every place. The people have to realize about education in our country because moral education is the character of students as their identities. It is Not about the best school in the world that have moral value, but about the principle of morality that they are given.

And the fact, religious education is possible have all package to offer the students to keep their character and identities. Not only intellectual education but also moral education can they get.

Keyword; moral education, public school, Islamic boarding school.


Nowadays, we encounter a lot, especially in excellent schools. They feel proud and superior not because of their character, mentality, and morality, but only to the extent that the culture is taken from the West.

Get quality help now
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Education

star star star star 5 (339)

“ KarrieWrites did such a phenomenal job on this assignment! He completed it prior to its deadline and was thorough and informative. ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

Confess quality because it uses a foreign language. It even hopes to be distinguished from other schools because it is more international.

These model schools have been trapped in prestige. Efforts to align themselves by forgetting the identity and meaning of education itself. Coupled with the perception of a society that has been influenced by consumerism and materials that requires their children to be able to compete on this side. The community demands that the school provide a future for children to have adequate life. Religious and moral issues can be secondary.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

If we only glance at education in Japan, education can not only apply and develop knowledge but also still be given their character education and cultural knowledge. So they still love and also understand their origin with the culture of their ancestors. Because education does not only prioritize intellectual intelligence but also moral, spiritual and emotional intelligence.

The public should be aware, that the education system in our country tends to only prepare students for entry into the next level and then college or only for those who do have talent at academic potential (a measure of high IQ). Just look at the weight of subjects directed at developing the academic dimensions of students which are often only measured by the ability of logic-mathematics and abstraction (language skills, memorization, abstraction or IQ measures). Though there are many other potentials that need to be developed because based on Howard Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences, the academic potential is only part of the other potential.

Schools have strategic responsibilities in order to improve all basic intelligence of every child. Broadly speaking, intelligence should cover 3 main areas, namely, moral education, intellectual education, and skill education

Moral Education

The word morals come from Arabic which according to language means character, temperament, behaviour, or character. If in everyday language morals are related to courtesy manners, decency, and behaviour. In Greek, morals are called ethics or ethos, meaning that there are habits, inner feelings or the inclination of the heart to do something.

Moral education is very necessary and needed in this day and age. Because good culture comes from human beings who are loaded with good morals. Moral education is expected to help the nation's problems, especially young people. Armed with morals, someone will know and be able to sort and choose good and bad deeds. Putting things in their place and in effect humanizing humans with noble relationships.

Moral Intelligence Factor of each individual improves every development. Individual moral development is divided into four main domains, namely punishment, behaviour, feelings, and personality. According to Piaget and Kohlberg (Santrock, 2007: 132), the moral development of this class is called by the role of parents and school. Research conducted by Walker, Hennig, and Krettenauer (In Santrock, 2007: 133) shows parents and peers can contribute to the moral maturity of children if children can obtain opinions and check to allow them. In the view of Ross Thompson (in Santrock, 2007), children are moral holders, struggles to obtain what is moral. People can help in this struggle with sensitive guidance from adults at home who give lessons about morality in everyday life. Some important aspects of parent and child relationships that contribute to children's moral development improve the quality of relationships, discipline from parents, proactive strategies, and conversational dialogue. A. According to Thompson (in Santrock, 2007: 133), the quality of the relationship between parents and children in terms of introducing children to reciprocal relationships in terms of close interpersonal relationships is an important basis for positive moral growth in children. In this connection Intelligence that is the ability to perform task-directed, critical thinking, and overcomes the environment effectively. It can be concluded that intelligence is an intellectual potential that requires a rational notion process. Therefore, intelligence cannot be accessed directly, it should be eliminated from more than a few concrete actions that are manifestations of the rational thought process.

The Prophet Muhammad SAW chosen man whose morality is praised by Allah: And indeed you are truly noble and noble. (Surat al-Qalam: 4), as well as humans sent to educate human morals as the sound of the hadith narrated by Bukhari: Surely I was sent to perfect (educate) human morals.

Public School

School is a place to study, interact, socialize, and behave by implementing the rules that have been made. Here, it is home to the students who are expected to become a role figure in the future. There are various aspects desired in terms of education that students want, including language lessons, numbers, skills, hobbies and so forth. However, on the other hand, the teacher becomes a parent to educate according to the norms of the rules. Moral, courtesy, and immoral education is applied to foster a sense of consciousness as a human being.

However, in the progress of this age, the behaviour of a student is truly empowered. Even if it because of association outside the school, or school management is lacking in delivering. Basically, the behaviour of a student to the teacher must be full of respect and obedience. But now, the teacher at school is treated the same as a friend, whose sense of courtesy is no longer there. this might also be considered very reasonable by teachers in public schools, maybe their approach to students should be done like that way. In contrast to education in Islamic boarding schools where politeness to the clerics is the key to the knowledge inherent in the students themselves. Thus, the teacher's role should really be applied properly in educating students to become better.

Islamic Boarding School

Islamic boarding school is an Islamic educational institution that was first established in Indonesia and has a very important role in preparing the nation's generation in terms of education and study of religious sciences. The birth of the Islamic boarding school did not escape the history of the entry of Islam in the archipelago. In the modern era like today, the Salaf Islamic boarding school is faced with rapid changes in social and technological systems. Today's society has experienced many changes in values ​​in its social life as well as a modern society with its characteristics as a comparison of traditional society. However, during civilization changes that occur within the community, there is still a boarding school that does not fully participate.

Several things exist in the Salaf Islamic boarding school, including; First, the learning system used is the classical method. The learning system was taken from Middle Eastern countries (Arabian Peninsula, Egypt, Palestine, and parts of the African Continent). Second, the management system of Islamic boarding school that is, there is no organizational system and all kinds of regulations in it are centred on the Kyai, as well as the teaching and learning process, for example, the methods applied, the books taught, and the time of their implementation are Kyai's decisions. Third, technology, which is up to the present era, boarding schools are distancing themselves from technologies such as radio and television, even though the device has quite good benefits, but there are also negative impacts.

Education in Islamic boarding schools must make efforts to change the understanding of their teachings so that they can remain relevant and are not affected by changes that can close developments in the Islamic boarding school. Besides, Islamic boarding schools must also be able to balance their education system between world relations and the hereafter, a system that combines tradition with modernity. There are several types of boarding schools that develop in the community. First, the traditional boarding school is a boarding school that still retains its original form by teaching books written by 15th-century scholars using Arabic or also called the yellow book / classic book with teaching patterns using a system of consultation which is usually carried out in the mosque and the curriculum depend on the clerics of the caretakers of the hut. Second, modern Islamic boarding schools, Islamic boarding schools whose learning orientation takes from the entire learning system classically and leaves the traditional learning system and the curriculum used is the national school curriculum. Third, the boarding school is a comprehensive boarding school that combines traditional systems with modern systems and teaches the salaf book with the method of sorogan and bandongan, but regularly the school system also continues to develop and there is also skills education

Islamic boarding schools must take steps to adjust to reforms that can benefit their students, as well as support the sustainability of Islamic boarding schools, such as the establishment of a planned, clear and orderly curriculum. According to Zamakhsyari Dhofier in his book The Pesantren Tradition there are five elements that must be present in boarding schools, including the boarding house as a place that is useful as a hostel (residence) for students; mosque as a place used for worship; the teaching of the yellow books (classical) which is a study of classical Islamic books written by the great scholars at that time; students who are students who live in boarding schools; and the clerics as caregivers as well as teachers for the students.

In a modern era like this, the existence of the Salaf Islamic boarding school is a question for some parties about its relevance to be maintained. In this era, a lot of progress in science and technology is happening and has had a positive or negative influence on human life. The positive influence is that it is a very effective means of supporting learning to be used as a tool in the learning process. And the negative influence is felt more by the students and the community, namely by the emergence of various kinds of moral/moral damage. Therefore, when compared to public schools, Islamic boarding schools have advantages in an education system that is more moral/moral. Until this modern era, Islamic boarding schools still exist and are growing more rapidly and will still be needed in the future because they can provide good mental and spiritual guidance. However, the system must also be adjusted to the times.

To face this modern era, the boarding school must be able to maximize its role through, among others; Improving HR in Islamic boarding schools so that residents who are in it are not out of date. So, Islamic boarding schools must be able to think openly, freely, and wisely in responding to changes that occur, such as doing foreign language learning, for example, English; Can balance between world science with the afterlife, because both are equally important for one's life; Islamic boarding schools must be able to develop critical thinking patterns so that they are not only fanatical about the law in the yellow books and also the opinions of the salaf scholars.

However, they must also be able to combine the law of the Salaf with the current conditions. In this way, the mindset of the boarding school residents will be more critical and dynamic. Thus, they can make wise decisions when responding to new problems in this modern era, can filter out the good or bad cultures, and go according to the current development of the times without having to get out of the shari'ah taught in Islamic boarding schools.

So, the development of Islamic boarding schools must be carried out without having to change the original form of the Islamic Boarding School. If the boarding school rejects the existence of advances in science and technology, it will be alienated and may even be unable to contribute to the lives of surrounding communities.


From the description that has been stated, it can be concluded that moral education in schools is important to do by teachers and all the component of school citizens in order the comprehensive moral education will be achieved.


  1. Armstrong, T., 2000. Multiple Intelligence in The Classroom. Alexandria, Virginia US: ASCD Esam Abdullah Al Jaddou. Existential intelligence among graduate students at the World Islamic Sciences University in Jordan. (2018). Academic Journal. Vol. 13(13), pp. 534-542.
  2. Hamid Abdulloh; Putu Sudira. Inculcating The Character Values Of The Student Of Smk Salafiyah Of Expertise Program Of Computer Technology And Network Kajen, Margoyoso, Pati, Jawa Tenga: Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta.
  3. Howard Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences, Northern Illinois University.pdf, Faculty Development and Instructional Design Center,, 815.753.0595 Howard Gardner Dalam Tradisi Pendidikan Pesantren)
  4. Rukiyati, (2017). Pendidikan Moral Di Sekolah., Fakultas Ilmu Pendidikan Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta: Jurnal Humanika Th. XVII, No. 1
  5. Sayyidah Syaehotin, Kecerdasan Majemuk Pesantren Tradisional (Studi Aspek-AspekMultiple Intelligences Perspektif Smith, Mark K. (2002, 2008) ‘Howard Gardner and multiple intelligences’, the encyclopedia of informal education,
  6. Utama, Okta Yoga. (2016). Perbedaan Tingkat Moral Siswa Antara Sekolah Berbasis Islam Dengan Sekolah Umum: Fakultas Psikologi Dan Fakultas Agama Islamuniversitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta:
Cite this page

The Moral Education Between Public School And An Islamic Boarding School. (2021, Feb 24). Retrieved from

The Moral Education Between Public School And An Islamic Boarding School
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment