Understanding Federalism in the United States

What is the definition of Federalism?

The United States has a highly intricate government system known as federalism. This system involves multiple levels and subdivisions, with a constant fluctuation in the connections between the national, state, and local governments. Sometimes, these levels of government operate independently, while other times they become so intertwined that it becomes difficult to distinguish their respective responsibilities. Federalism is one of the three primary power systems employed by the United States.

There are two alternative ways to organize power between national and regional governments, aside from pure federalism or a federal system.

In a federal system, the central and regional governments have divided powers and responsibilities, each operating independently. This allows for a representative government in which voters elect candidates at both the regional and central levels to legislate on their behalf. On the other hand, a unitary system concentrates power in the central government.

The unitary system is demonstrated by France's government, in which the central government holds authority and grants special powers to the regional governments.

Get quality help now

Prof. Finch

Verified writer

Proficient in: Local Government

4.7 (346)

“ This writer never make an mistake for me always deliver long before due date. Am telling you man this writer is absolutely the best. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Voters elect individuals into the central government, which then assigns them to the regional governments. On the other hand, the confederal system or confederacy concentrates power more in the regional governments than the central government. Voters elect representatives into the independent regional governments, which subsequently bestow legal authority upon the central government. The Confederate States of America serves as an example of a confederal system.

In the United States, there exists a federal system of power. This allows for independent coexistence between regional governments (states and localities) and the central government. As a result, these regional governments have the opportunity to engage in policy experimentation, which has earned them the nickname "laboratories of democracy."

Traditionally, federalism has been linked to devolution - the transfer of powers from the national government to state governments. This contradicts the principle of equal independence in federalism as states gain more power. The reason behind this shift could be states misusing their authority to experiment with policies. However, despite possible abuses of power, experimenting is generally viewed as advantageous.

One of the benefits of federalism is the ability to experiment. This system allows for flexibility in state laws and institutions, reducing complications and facilitating citizens' interests, as seen through improved trade. Federalism also helps achieve national goals, as evidenced by the successful creation of the interstate highway system in the 1950s. However, federalism also has its drawbacks.

Federalism is complex and confusing, which can be inconvenient. The division of power between state and federal governments is vague, leading to confusion. Moreover, federalism leads to duplication of efforts and reduces accountability. It also creates difficulties in coordination, as shown by the inability of police and fire departments in different cities or states to communicate. The Three Mile Island accident demonstrated this problem when it almost caused a catastrophic event. Additionally, federalism results in inequality in services and policies. Despite its imperfections, federalism is not an ideal system but rather one that has both advantages and disadvantages.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency, otherwise known as FEMA, exemplifies how federalism influences policy. In its attempt to assist in the recovery efforts for hurricane Katrina, FEMA was unable to effectively communicate and coordinate relief with state and local governments. Nevertheless, when confronted with hurricane Sandy, FEMA successfully provided substantial aid and relief due to efficient communication and coordinated procedures. This demonstrates how FEMA's resiliency within the framework of federalism can yield a shift from inadequate to effective coordination.

The United States has a Constitutional basis for federalism. The Constitution explicitly grants powers to the different levels of government. Enumerated powers, which are written in the Constitution, are grants of authority given to the federal government. One important provision in the Constitution is the national supremacy clause, which states that federal law supersedes all other laws. This allows the federal government to override areas regulated by state law, known as preemption. Exclusive powers, another set of powers in the Constitution, are granted only to the federal government. These include creating and maintaining an army and navy, declaring war, and regulating commerce. However, education falls under state jurisdiction as it is not listed as an exclusive power. The Constitution also includes concurrent powers.

Both the federal and state governments possess concurrent powers, such as taxation, borrowing, and spending. Moreover, the federal government possesses implied powers granted by the Constitution to address the changing needs of the nation. These implied powers encompass provisions like the general welfare clause, necessary and proper clause, and interstate commerce clause. The general welfare clause empowers Congress to guarantee the overall well-being of the country.

The Constitution's necessary and proper clause allows Congress to enact laws that are considered "necessary and proper" for carrying out its responsibilities as stated in the Constitution. Additionally, Congress has been given the authority to regulate interstate commerce through the interstate commerce clause. These clauses have been widely interpreted, leading to an extension of Congress's implied powers.

Although the Constitution grants Congress more power, it does not clearly specify the duties of state governments. However, there is a provision called the full faith and credit clause within the Constitution. This provision requires states to acknowledge each other's public records and actions. As a result, contracts, wills, and marriages are legally acknowledged in all states as long as they are valid in one state. Essentially, this clause establishes the economic basis for state and local governments. Another important provision regarding states is the privileges and immunities clause which prohibits discrimination against residents from other states.

The Constitution's Bill of Rights restricts the power of the federal government and safeguards the rights of individuals and states. The Tenth Amendment highlights the dominance of states, granting them exclusive powers along with people. Additionally, through the Fourteenth Amendment, state authorities are defined by their prohibition from denying citizens their rights and ensuring equal treatment and fair legal proceedings. Federalism is a crucial element in the U.S. government as declared in the Constitution.

Federalism is a complex system that includes different types, such as dual-federalism. This type emphasizes the division and unique authorities of both the federal and state governments. Dual-federalism can be seen as a middle ground between nation-centered federalism, which prioritizes the national government, and state-centered federalism, which favors governance at the state level. Supporters of states' rights support the compact theory and advocate for a government that prioritizes individual states' interests.

The belief in states' rights is the support for states to have independence in decision-making without interference from the federal government. This belief is based on the compact theory, which suggests that the Constitution represents an agreement among independent states to create a unified government. In the 1820s and 1830s, nullification was taken to an extreme as southern states grew more discontent with national policies, resulting in arguments for secession. Conversely, cooperative federalism highlights collaboration and shared authority between state and federal governments. There are various forms of cooperative federalism.

"Layer Cake Federalism" is the initial form of cooperative federalism, characterized by clear divisions between federal, state, and local governments. This type is not widely practiced. On the other hand, "Marble Cake Federalism" represents the second type of cooperative federalism, where the boundaries between federal, state, and local governments are so intertwined that they become indistinguishable.

The United States practices a form of federalism known as "Picket Fence Federalism" or centralized federalism. In this system, the federal government takes the lead in creating national policies, while state and local governments aid in their implementation. This approach has led to a shift of power from the states to the federal government, as evidenced by grants offered by the federal government to state governments.

The federal government offers different types of grants-in-aid, including categorical grants which provide funds for specific programs and have limited flexibility in how state and local governments can utilize the money. Conversely, general revenue sharing grants have fewer restrictions and grant states or localities almost complete discretion in allocating the funds. It is important to note that all federal grants come with crosscutting requirements.

Crossover sanctions are federal requirements that grant recipients must follow to receive funding, while unfunded mandates are direct orders to states and localities without financial support. These grants have historically shifted power from state to federal governments, but a new form of federalism is now returning power to the states.

New federalism, also known as this form of federalism, advocates for granting states more power and authority while decreasing financial assistance from the federal government. Block grants were the preferred type of grants under new federalism. These grants are referred to as federal grants-in-aid and are given for general policy areas, allowing states and localities considerable flexibility in determining how to allocate the funds within the specified policy area. Ad hoc federalism, on the other hand, is a type of government that can change over time.

Ad hoc federalism is a flexible approach to federalism that adapts to specific issues, choosing between a state-centered or nation-centered perspective based on political convenience. In other words, ad hoc federalism can shift towards either the states or the federal government depending on the party in power in Congress. During the Bush era, the United States practiced ad hoc federalism. It is crucial to understand that this form of federalism is not permanent and can evolve over time.

In summary, federalism is a complex and dynamic system of government with different forms that distinguish it from others. It includes diverse aspects, both positive and negative, and can be observed in various areas of governance. As the United States moves forward, federalism will keep developing and adjusting to new situations.